Evaluating Myths, Religious and Otherwise, of St. Patrick

c. 2006 Religion News Service (UNDATED) St. Patrick’s Day in the United States means clover-colored clothing, paper shamrocks, bagpipes, Irish folk music and dancing, corned beef and cabbage, green beer. Often, the man of honor gets lost. At its core, the holiday is a holy recognition of St. Patrick’s commitment to spreading Christianity throughout Ireland. […]

c. 2006 Religion News Service

(UNDATED) St. Patrick’s Day in the United States means clover-colored clothing, paper shamrocks, bagpipes, Irish folk music and dancing, corned beef and cabbage, green beer.

Often, the man of honor gets lost. At its core, the holiday is a holy recognition of St. Patrick’s commitment to spreading Christianity throughout Ireland. It falls on March 17, the day he is believed to have died more than 1,500 years ago.


Over the centuries, Ireland’s patron saint has become a mythical figure, widely pictured with a long beard, standing tall on the lush Irish coast in ceremonial robes, wearing a bishop’s miter (or hat), holding a shepherd’s staff. Snakes scatter from his feet.

It’s an image that feeds into widely held misconceptions. To set the record straight:

_ St. Patrick wasn’t Irish. There is disagreement over his precise birthplace, but it was somewhere in Roman Britain.

_ He didn’t introduce Christianity to Ireland. St. Palladius was the first bishop to travel to Ireland to convert the pagans, who believed in many gods.

_ He didn’t drive the snakes from Ireland. Geological studies have determined there were no snakes. The story symbolizes St. Patrick casting off paganism.

_ He likely never used the three-leafed clover to teach about the Holy Trinity, the belief that God exists as the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit. That notion surfaced centuries after St. Patrick’s death.

“There is a huge contrast between the historical St. Patrick and the legendary St. Patrick,” said Dermot Quinn, author of “The Irish in New Jersey: Four Centuries of American Life” and history professor at Seton Hall University in South Orange, N.J.

“All sorts of things get folded into the memory of the saints.”

Historians reason that St. Patrick was the son of an aristocratic landowner, captured by marauders when he was about 16, taken to Ireland and made a slave. During six years sheepherding in relative solitude, he found God.


Patrick escaped and returned to Britain, but he longed to one day minister to the Irish. He studied for the priesthood and eventually was ordained a bishop. Sources vary on Patrick’s time line, but in the early 430s, Pope Celestine sent Patrick back to Ireland.

Patrick spent decades baptizing, founding churches and otherwise spreading Christianity. He may have died in his 70s, though some sources say he lived past 100.

In Ireland, March 17 became a day of religious celebration. But centuries later in the United States, it turned into more. Irish immigrants who poured into this country during the 18th and 19th centuries found a hard life, struggling in exhausting jobs and suffering discrimination.

“People started looking back romantically at the motherland,” said Philip Freeman, author of “St. Patrick of Ireland: A Biography” and associate professor of classics at Luther College in Decorah, Iowa.

Parades, enlivened with Irish music and dancing, emerged, beginning treasured traditions in cities built with Irish hands.

This year, Cleveland will celebrate its 139th St. Patrick’s Day Parade.

Marilyn Madigan, 52, of Cleveland, said the “true Irish” will observe that day by first attending Mass in the morning.


“It’s become such a secular holiday,” said Madigan, a deputy director of the Cleveland parade. “We’re glad that everybody wants to partake with us, but we do not want to forget the meaning of the day of St. Patrick.”

The Rev. Rock Badgerow, pastor of St. Patrick Parish in Parnell, Mich., said he has to remind the children in the parish school, “It’s a day, not a season.” He said that’s hard to remember when St. Patrick’s Day decorations appear in stores and restaurants for days or weeks, making the holy day a commercial venture.

Pam Chamberlain, 34, of Pittsburgh and of Irish descent, sees nothing to celebrate. She’s a pagan, and St. Patrick’s Day reminds her of Patrick’s dissolution of pagan culture.

“Everybody says, `You can celebrate your Irishness,”’ Chamberlain said. “I say, if you’re an Irish Catholic, go right ahead.”

But many embrace the holiday’s more cultural trimmings.

“Everybody’s Irish on St. Patrick’s Day,” as everyone may join the festivities, said Thomas P. Giblin, 58, of Montclair, N.J. Giblin has helped organize the Newark, N.J., St. Patrick’s Day Parade over the years, as his father did before him.

He said the holiday fosters Irish-American pride and brings attention to descendants of poor, Irish immigrants who have become leaders in business, labor and politics. “That’s also cause for celebration,” he said.


(OPTIONAL TRIM FOLLOWS)

Those who feel like partying have countless options around St. Patrick’s Day.

One such spot, Kells Irish Restaurant & Pub in Portland, Ore., holds an annual festival with bands, dancers, traditional food and “bevvies.” No green beer, though. That’s simply not Irish.

“It’s an opportunity to come together and celebrate the richness of (Irish) culture,” said Lucille McAleese, one of Kells’ co-owners.

And sometimes it’s just about the beer.

Erica Blasdel, 23, of Columbus, Ohio, laughs when she remembers her college’s student tradition: “Green Beer Day.” Because St. Patrick’s Day fell during spring break, students created a pre-Patrick holiday. Revelers started drinking before sunrise. No doubt St. Patrick would not have approved.

Now in graduate school, Blasdel is throwing a St. Patrick’s Day party at her apartment this year to introduce friends from different parts of her life.

“It’s more of a fun holiday,” said Blasdel, who has Irish ancestors. “There’s nothing that says you have to celebrate it a certain way.”

MO/LF/PH END MELENDEZ

Editors: To obtain an iconic image of St. Patrick go to the RNS Web site at https://religionnews.com. On the lower right, click on “photos,” then search by subject or slug.


Donate to Support Independent Journalism!

Donate Now!