Nuns question Vatican probe

(RNS) An umbrella group of Catholic nuns has asked the Vatican to disclose why it is being investigated and who is funding the probe, and questioned why the sisters will not be allowed to see the final investigative report submitted to church leaders. The Leadership Conference of Women Religious, which met last week (Aug. 11-14) […]

(RNS) An umbrella group of Catholic nuns has asked the Vatican to disclose why it is being investigated and who is funding the probe, and questioned why the sisters will not be allowed to see the final investigative report submitted to church leaders.

The Leadership Conference of Women Religious, which met last week (Aug. 11-14) in New Orleans, pledged to cooperate with a Vatican investigation of the sisters’ fidelity to Catholic doctrine on female ordination, homosexuality, and the role of the church in salvation.

A separate Vatican investigation, announced last January, aims to take a broader look at nearly 350 communities of women religious in the U.S., examining everything from finances to how leaders deal with sisters who dissent from Catholic dogma.


In a statement released Monday (Aug. 17), the LCWR requested that “those conducting the inquiries alter some methods being employed.”

“Among the expressed concerns are a lack of full disclosure about the motivation and funding sources for the studies,” the LCWR statement said. “The leaders also object to the fact that their orders will not be permitted to see the investigative reports about them that are being submitted directly to the Vatican.”

With about 1,500 members who are elected leaders of their religious orders, the LCWR represents about 95 percent of the estimated 59,000 Catholic sisters in the U.S.

“We are used to evaluations. We have no problems with evaluations,” Sister Helen Garvey told National Catholic Reporter, an independent newspaper, in New Orleans. “But we need a sense of fair play. There needs to be transparency.”

In the statement, the sisters said they are committed to “serving at and speaking from the margins of the Catholic Church.”

American nuns are widely credited with building and for many years maintaining the Catholic school system and hospital network, both of which are among the largest private institutions in the world. But their numbers have dropped drastically over several decades as the vast majority of communities struggle to find new members, according to a study released last week.


In addition, some conservative Catholics complain that a number of sisters have publicly avowed progressive views that contradict church teachings.

Donate to Support Independent Journalism!

Donate Now!