From inside a doublewide, a shot at the Prosperity Gospel

(RNS) Forty years ago, in the bedroom of a single-wide trailer in Columbus, Ga., 13-year old Karen Spears — now Karen Spears Zacharias — knelt in despair and beseeched God to come into her life. Young Karen had suffered a terrible tragedy: Her soldier father, David Spears, had been killed in Vietnam when she was […]

(RNS) Forty years ago, in the bedroom of a single-wide trailer in Columbus, Ga., 13-year old Karen Spears — now Karen Spears Zacharias — knelt in despair and beseeched God to come into her life.

Young Karen had suffered a terrible tragedy: Her soldier father, David Spears, had been killed in Vietnam when she was 9 and the loss had taken a heavy toll on the family.


“My mother shut down emotionally with the Lord,” recalls Zacharias, a journalist and author, looking back on her childhood. “She felt betrayed by God.”

But Zacharias, inspired by a youth pastor, prayed to God at the time: “I ask you to come into my heart, cleanse my sins, be my Lord.”

“I was crying,” she remembers.

Storyteller, editorial writer and author of a provocative new book on God and money, “Will Jesus Buy Me a Double-Wide?”, Zacharias’ faith has only deepened from that transforming moment in a Georgia trailer park.

Zacharias’ first book, a memoir in 2005, was “After the Flag Has Been Folded: A Daughter Remembers the Father She Lost to War — and the Mother Who Held Her Family Together.”

Her second, in 2008, plunged into the post-9/11 psyche of America: “Where’s Your Jesus Now? Examining How Fear Erodes Our Faith.”

Zacharias’ new book is both a foray into her personal feelings about prayer and money — having had little of the latter when young — and into stories of people who offer “parables,” she says, that illustrate her theme.

She sees her work as a “corrective” to what’s known as the “prosperity gospel,” or as she writes: “We treat God like a slot machine, yanking on the prayer cable, hoping that the triple 7s will appear.”


William Paul Young, author of mega-selling “The Shack,” gives this dustjacket endorsement: “If the prosperity gospel had a heart, Karen has stomped that sucker flat.”

There is no endorsement from the hugely popular televangelist Joel Osteen. Indeed, Osteen is one of the purveyors, Zacharias says, of the notion that prayer can bring down riches on one’s head.

“Joel Osteen is a good man,” she says, “but wrong about the message he’s giving.”

“The folksy Osteen,” she writes in her book, “comes across as harmless but the gospel he’s selling isn’t. The wounded in this world are dying and despairing by the thousands while prosperity preachers are offering up home-brewed remedies of Entitlement theology. These charlatans are selling salve to the sick when salvation is what people really need to fix what’s ailing them.”

She also takes issue with interpretations of Bruce Wilkinson’s monumental bestseller, “The Prayer of Jabez,” that asks, in part: “Oh, that you would bless me, indeed, and enlarge my territory.”

The “increase in territory,” Zacharias says, is about the spiritual presence in one’s heart, not financial domain.


In person, Zacharias is easy-going, amiable, both a widely-traveled writer and a country gal who claims to “speak two languages — English and hillbilly.”

A resident of Oregon, where she and husband Tim raised their four children, she has spent considerable time back in the Deep South.

In study questions Zacharias has added to the back of her new book, she suggests a study topic for the jubilee chapter: “Consider Leviticus 25:8-17. Contrast the biblical definition of Jubilee to that of the current teachings in the church regarding Jubilee. How do they differ?”

For study questions tied to the chapter, “The Redhead,” about the struggle of a close friend with cancer, she suggests: “Have you ever struggled with the death of a loved one? What good is the God of prosperity in such moments?”

Zacharias emphasizes that she is not romanticizing what it means to be poor. “I’m not in favor of poverty, having lived it!”

But “the obligation” for bringing in income, she says, “is on us, not on God.


“God is not our sugar daddy,” Zecharias says.

She says she offers the same prayer for every book she publishes. “I’m not asking God to make this a bestseller,” but to “make the book everything you intend for it to be. Nothing more. Nothing less.”

In addition to faith, and love of family, and writing, what else keeps her going?

Her eyes fill with tears as she becomes that 9-year old girl again, hearing news of her father’s death in battle.

“I try to live my life so my father would be as proud of me” — she pauses, wiping at her eyes as the tears quicken — “as I am of him.

(Roy Hoffman writes for The Mobile Press-Register in Mobile, Ala.)

Donate to Support Independent Journalism!

Donate Now!