Retired Los Angeles cardinal punished over abuse revelations

Print More
Cardinal Roger M. Mahony of Los Angeles stands outside St. Joseph's Church in New York following an ecumenical prayer service presided over by Pope Benedict XVI in 2008. Photo by Gregory A. Shemitz

Cardinal Roger M. Mahony of Los Angeles stands outside St. Joseph's Church in New York following an ecumenical prayer service presided over by Pope Benedict XVI in 2008. Photo by Gregory A. Shemitz

Active RNS subscribers and members can view this content by logging-in here.

(RNS) Retired Los Angeles Cardinal Roger Mahony has been stripped of his official duties in an unusual public rebuke by his successor that followed the release of thousands of pages of internal church documents showing how Mahony and aides for years conspired to cover up the sexual abuse of children by clergy.

  • Pingback: Retired Cardinal Roger Mahony tied to church abuse claims, stripped of duties – Washington Times | Devise Hive()

  • Mike

    The Catholic Church has been corrupt and abusive for 2,000 years. It will never change until lay people end all financial support to the Church. Only then will they get the attention of the Church’s unspeakably pompous hierarchy.

  • As a priest as well as being a victim of clergy sexual abuse the actions of Bishop Gomez are too little, and too late.

    When I experienced my flashback in the fall of 2001 I was totally unaware of what was brewing in Boston. While I am a Boston priest, I had served in the USN as a chaplain and had retired in 1997. I chose NOT to return to Boston — I did not know exactly why, but I knew I was not comfortable there. What kept me from returning was the slow realization that I had been raped.

    The theology training I had received in the seminary has me “intimately” associated with the hierarchy. Theologically I am an “extension of” the bishop (or apostle.) In essence I am one of them in that I represent all that they say and do. After my flashback I went into counseling. I struggled to remain in ministry but it was becoming harder and harder. Each day that I read about Mahony’s antics in the courtroom trying to evade the release of information or documents pushed me into a corner. I could no longer represent the bishops. I could no longer be a part of their conspiracy, their deception, their cruelty.

    In November 2005 I contacted the Archdiocese of Boston and requested “retirement.” I flew to Boston to meet with Bishop Lennon and within fifteen minutes was granted medical leave. I never did hear from O’Malley. I thought, surely, a priest struggling with remaining in active ministry would be worth a few minutes of his time – but that did not happen. I was scheduled to leave my assignment as chaplain at the Washington Hospital Center on 1 June 2006. On Tuesday of Holy Week I made the announcement at noon Mass in the chapel, and I explained “why” I would be leaving. Within hours I was reported to the Diocese of Washington and I was IMMEDIATELY relieved of my faculties, in short, I WAS FIRED for speaking the truth.

    And so, thanks to the likes of Mahony, George, Todd, Brown and all the others, I languish outside of Ministry that I so enjoyed. As I said earlier, this “banishment” of Mahony is too little, too late. Now, had the vatican stripped him of the title “Cardinal” I MIGHT have a different attitude – but then, what about all the others??

  • Pingback: dotCommonweal » Blog Archive » Is Cardinal Mahony barred from public ministry?()

  • Pingback: Cardinal Mahony rebuked as more 'brutal' priest abuse files released – Los Angeles Times | Nolan River Mall, Cleburne TX()

  • David Lorenz

    So am I to believe that during the last 6 years while the Church has been fighting the release of these documents, Gomez had no knowledge of what was in them. Am I to believe he woke up today, looked at the released docs and said “OMG I guess I should do something about this – I had no idea.” REALLY! That’s what I’m supposed to believe? The sad fact is he is only taken this action because of the public pressure being placed on him because the public now sees these documents. Gomez needs to be relieved of his duties as well because of negligence since he took the office of bishop.

  • Judy Jones

    Finally the ugly truth is being exposed, finally the victims may feel validation, and finally these church officials might be held responsible for covering these sex crimes, so that no other child is sexually abused again.

    But this is curious…..How is it possible that Cardinal Mahony (who deserves to be prosecuted for covering up sex crimes against innocent kids) can be removed of his duties.?….And yet convicted criminal KC Bishop Finn can not..?

    They make up their own rules.. which is so sad for all the victims of clergy sex abuse..Keep in mind, the LA Archdiocese is not unique in how they handle sex crimes against kids.

    Judy Jones, SNAP Midwest Associate Director, 636-433-2511.,
    (Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests)

  • Pingback: Embattled LA Cardinal stripped of duties due to involvement in child sex scandals | God Discussion()

  • Pingback: Why Nuns Are In, And Priests Are Out | Social Justice & Other Liberal Ideas()

  • Stephen

    James, you are a courageous person. Thank you for speaking the truth.

  • gilhcan

    Almost every other bishop in the world has done the same! Why aren’t the others punished both by their church and by civil justice authorities? In the United States, only one has even been charged, also found guilty, and his punishment was only the proverbial slap on the wrist.

    Shame on any such organization that claims to be a proponent of Jesus of the gospels! The Catholic Church has been guilty of its own proclaimed sins, and also of hideous public crimes.

    The lay people are fools for allowing their bishops to trash their precious dollars to pay the legal cost of cover-up. What about the morality of any lawyers who would defend such sins and crimes and the organizations that promote them?

    Such evils are as sufficient as the Crusades, indulgences, false relics, and the Inquisitions to turn anyone away from religion and churches. These are the very hypocrisies against which Jesus fought in his own Jewish religion–and for which he was nailed to a cross.

    For the majority of diocesan administrators, it is nothing but filthy politics, and that goes all the way to the Vatican that is being so silent again about the sex scandal while its celibates spend their time and the lay people’s money trying to control other people’s sex habits and child bearing.

    President Obama has again given into religionists by expanding permission for them to dictate the sex lives of everyone else, even when they can’t control their own. Is the president also our legislative branch of government? Do his monarchical decisions match those of the Catholic monarch in the Vatican?

  • Pingback: My Friday Take – Is It A Catholic Thing? « My Takes()

  • gilhccan

    Is this only the result of appointing a social worker as ordinary of a diocese, or is it the long tradition of cover-up of the sins and crimes of the officialdom of the Catholic Church? After all, when we study that church’s history, both before and after the Reformation, we see these practices have always been at work since Constantine, a non-Christian till his death bed, by the way, politicized that religion for his own imperial advantage by calling the Council of Nicaea in 325?

    That is when bishops became members of the royalty, and the papacy remains the last surviving monarchy with any real power in the western world. The pointed miters of bishops are crowns. The extreme evangelicals in this country have joined in that behavior, trying to replace what should be our constitutional system with their selective biblical law.

    Just consider how civil justice systems of other nations, including the United States, have been afraid to move against the clerical sex scandal of the Vatican City State. We have sacrificed children to the sinful crimes of that church’s clergy. Only one bishop has received a slap on the wrist in this country for managing cover-up. They continue to parade in pompous ceremony, pretending to be other than they are.

    Finally, Bishop Gomez took more slap-on-the-wrist action against Mahony, but it appears he had no choice in order to save face after court orders for disclosure. You can be sure that he did not act without first consulting his bosses in the Vatican. It has become very obvious that is the way of the hierarchical system of the Catholic Church. That’s the way of politics. That’s the way of royalty. It is not the way of Jesus. Sadly, it is also too much the way of what we continue to proclaim as democracy in this country. Has a single Wall St. criminal been prosecuted?

  • tina

    Am thankful to see Mahoney and Curry get caught. now for the Jesuits and franciscans and other reliigious orders and their leaders who did the same and thru their cover ups and stone walling and retaliation against victims and victims families put millions of catholic and other children at risk..Put the American public and International children and public at risk of sexual assault by their predators who they allowed to be free ..

  • Pingback: Blogging Blue | Nuns Are In And Priests Are Out()

  • Pingback: 'West Wing' for a cynical time | Faith Fix()

  • Pingback: Did anything really change for Cardinal Mahony? | Columbia Faith & Values()