“How many of you have reported on church-state issues? How many have reported on church-state issues in Texas?”
Journalists from across the U.S. and some from abroad nodded affirmatively as Kathy Miller, President of the Texas Freedom Network, posed both questions at the Religion Newswriters Association’s pre-conference in Austin, Texas. She called her state a petri dish, consistently pushing the boundaries of what church-state separation means.
Eric Teetsel, executive director of the Manhattan Declaration, defined religious freedom as the right to ask questions of ultimate significance and to live according to those answers. He said that despite the ubiquity of religious experience in the U.S. today, religious freedom is still all too uncommon.
Teetsel, from Manhattan Declaration, says he hopes for an era where the gov doesn't tolerate #religion, but promotes it equally #rna2013
— FāVS News (@SpokaneFAVS) September 26, 2013
https://twitter.com/kelliekotraba/status/383296099915542528
Teetsel asserts that the #contraception mandate forces employers to provide abortifacient drugs. (Me: The science is not settled.) #RNA2013
— Grant Gallicho (@gallicho) September 26, 2013
Teetsel cited the “mainstreaming of alternative sexualities” as an issue at the front line of impending religious liberty conflicts. Elaborating on this point, he mentioned the case of a New Mexico photographer who was sued for refusing to photograph a same-sex couple’s commitment ceremony on religious grounds and the ongoing case to determine whether Hobby Lobby and other companies must provide birth control to employees under the federal health care law.
In a later session, the president of Hobby Lobby Steve Green said, “We didn’t pick the fight. We had no intentions of suing our own government…But as has been mentioned, because the mandate requires us in essence to become abortion providers, our conscience doesn’t allow us to do that. We had no other option, we saw, than to sue.”
Matt Dillahunty, host of The Atheist Experience TV show, emphasized that debates on religious freedom should focus on church-state separation rather than on notions of offense. He believes the case of cheerleaders in Kountze, Texas holding up Biblical banners at football games is not a matter of free speech, as some have framed it, but rather a blatant breach of church-state separation.
Matt Dillahunty: "There's a clear bias against atheists and a bias toward Christianity in this country." #RNA2013
— Amanda Greene Irwin (@civilitytweeter) September 26, 2013
Boy Scouts have right to discriminate against an atheists and gays but not to get federal funds to do so #RNA2013
— Ann Rodgers (@annrodgerspgh) September 26, 2013
Dillahunty — "I find myself defending Westboro Baptist Church all the time because they are exercising their free speech." #RNA2013
— WilmFAVS (@WilmFAVS) September 26, 2013
Jeff Mateer, general counsel of Liberty Institute, is defending the Texas cheerleaders in an ongoing court case. He says the case “shows there is an effort to purge religion from our schools and public lives.”
#RNA2013 Mateer: "FFRF creates more trouble than they should." Asked Kuntze cheerleaders to remove Bible verses from banners
— kjwinston11 (@kjwinston11) September 26, 2013
Jeff Mateer, Liberty Institute, counsel Kountze cheerleaders, "students do not lose constitutional rights at school house doors." #RNA2013
— Jennifer Mathlouthi (@JenMathlouthi) September 26, 2013
https://twitter.com/kelliekotraba/status/383302158600253440
Miller from the Texas Freedom Network brought the room back to a secular perspective. With only 10 minutes to speak, she skipped over birth control, LGBT rights and the cheerleader case to focus on the intersection of religion and curricula in public schools.
How teachers present sex, scripture, evolution and history all bring up questions of church-state separation in Texas and across the country. She says that a lack of guidance around how to teach these subjects is concerning and problematic. According to a Texas Freedom Network study she cited, only 3.6 percent of Texas school districts teach anything beyond abstinence-only sex education.
Sex ed classes in TX had overtly religious materials in the classroom including True Love Waits, virginity pledges. #RNA2013
— Amanda Greene Irwin (@civilitytweeter) September 26, 2013
#RNA2013 Miller: Teaching *about* the Bible in public schools is appropriate. Teaching the *Bible* in P.S. is not.
— Jeff Sheler (@jeffsheler) September 26, 2013
#RNA2013 Miler: Now 50 Bible courses in Tex public schools and "only handful" in nonsectarian way.
— kjwinston11 (@kjwinston11) September 26, 2013
A room full of journalists meant a steady stream of probing questions and lively debate. Some choice quotes from Tweeting journos in the room:
"if we allow everyone to do [make religious/atheist memorials], there won't be any grass left," says @Matt_Dillahunty #RNA2013
— Menachem Wecker (@mwecker) September 26, 2013
#RNA2013 Mateer: "Our job is to educate and inform the public about religious freedom issues…I don't see an end to the debate."
— Jeff Sheler (@jeffsheler) September 26, 2013
Dillahunty, Atheist: in regards to cross memorials, says #Christians unable to recognize privilege living under #RNA2013
— FāVS News (@SpokaneFAVS) September 26, 2013
@JeffMateer bemoans students not being allowed to write papers about God being their idol. but wouldn't that paper be idolatry? 😉 #RNA2013
— Menachem Wecker (@mwecker) September 26, 2013
If faith is killed by cross being taken down frm government space, that faith not very strong. Kathy Miller, Texas Freedom Network #RNA2013
— Kay Campbell (@KayTimes) September 26, 2013
#RNA2013 Beth Richardson, Tx p.s. cheerleading sponsor: Girls make banners with Bible verses. If it's student initiated, it's ok.
— Jeff Sheler (@jeffsheler) September 26, 2013