Forget Republican or Democrat: Americans divide by their values

Print More
Americans divide more along value than political ideology lines, according to a new Pew Research Center report.

Photo by Ivelin Radkov, via

Americans divide more along value than political ideology lines, according to a new Pew Research Center report.

(RNS) Toss out the party and ideology labels: Republican, Democrat, conservative, liberal.

The Pew Research Center’s new survey, “Beyond Red vs. Blue: The Political Typology,” finds no sharp lines dividing people by their views on politics, faith, family, and the role and limits of government.

“It’s a spectrum,” said Michael Dimock, vice president for research for Pew Research Center.

Looking at questions relating to faith and family, he observed, “the caricature that all religious people are Republican is just not true.”

A new Pew Research Center report highlights the stark divide between political orientation and belief in god and morality.

RNS image courtesy Bill Webster/Pew Research Center

A new Pew Research Center report highlights the stark divide between political orientation and belief in god and morality.

Black and Hispanic political liberals who attend church and hold conservative views on issues such as gay marriage hew red on social issues.

To find where people align by values, the typology survey, based on 10,000 U.S. adults, divvies up the public into color zones.

Shading toward red:

  • 12 percent: Steadfast Conservatives — older and white, socially and politically conservative.
  • 10 percent: Business Conservatives — also largely white but more pro Wall Street, pro-immigrant.
  • 14 percent: Young Outsiders, —  conservative on government, not social issues.

Blue or shading that way:

  • 15 percent: Solid liberals — this group parts company with other “blues” on religion and social issues.
  • 15 percent: Faith and Family Left — largely black or Hispanic, highly religious.
  • 12 percent: Next Generation Left — roughly half are under age 40, liberal on social issues but less keen on the social safety net.
  • 13 percent: Hard-Pressed Skeptics — financially stressed and pessimistic.

And outside the zones altogether are the Bystanders (10 percent), often young, who take no part in politics.

“What you see is an anchor on the left of fairly secular people, balanced by the Faith and Family Left with a strong Democratic orientation but very religious personal lives. They’re more conservative about how they think people should be living their lives,” said Dimock.

Looking to the right, he sees divisions between Steadfast Conservatives and Business Conservatives.

“Both are very religious personally, but the Business Conservatives don’t translate that into a social conservative stance. They are not as moralistic on how they see the scope of issues.”

That turned up when Pew asked whether it was necessary to believe in God to be moral.

Yes, said an overwhelming number of the Faith and Family Left (91 percent) and more than two in three of Steadfast Conservatives (69 percent).

But the seesaw balanced with Business Conservatives (66 percent) and Next Generation Left (91 percent) saying belief in God was not essential to morality.

There are similar splits on views toward the Bible and human evolution.

Where Steadfast Conservatives and their Business brethren stood closest was on views of Islam. They were the only two types in which majorities agree on the the statement: “Islamic religion is more likely than others to encourage violence.”

However, on questions about homosexuality and gay marriage, Steadfast Conservatives are much more likely to take the strongest stands in opposition.

Nearly three in four (74 percent) say society should discourage homosexuality rather than accept it — markedly higher than the Faith and Family Left (48 percent) who agree with them.

Similarly, on gay marriage, 84 percent of Steadfast Conservatives and 55 percent of the Faith and Family left oppose it.

But gay marriage gets strong support from the right-leaning Young Outsiders (68 percent) and their counterpoint, the Next Generation Left (78 percent).

Both of those youthful “types” join the Solid Liberals in strong support for abortion to remain legal in all or most cases.

When Pew asked whether society is better off if people make marriage and children a priority, the same alignment emerged.

Most Young Outsiders (65 percent), Next Generation Left (72 percent) and Solid Liberals (77 percent) say society will do just as well if people have different priorities.

As Democrats and Republicans look ahead to elections, those generational divides are going to matter.

“The Democrats’ side is already aligning with generational change,” said Dimock,  “so the future isn’t as much of a challenge to the Democrats as it is to the Republicans.”


  • Steven Clark

    Your survey rated me as “solid liberal”. I have many views that some might consider “liberal”. I am, however, deeply Traditional. I am very uncomfortable with many of the views held by “solid liberals”. Traditional values (going back thousands of years) are what make me take up the cause of the afflicted in our society. I am an Orthodox Christian Clergyman. While I cannot accept homosexuality as “normal” it is an even greater sin to discriminate against homosexuality. But just because it is a sin to discriminate against homosexuals does not make homosexuality not sinful. Abortion is the killing of the Image of God and the ones doing the killing wound their soul. I do not see criminalizing of this sin to be a good thing.
    I eshew the cultural wars of the right wing, even though I agree with about a good third of it, because there is a disconnect in the right wing culture wars with that we are created in God’s Image. (Indeed, I don’t understand how they can justify their positions theologically without understanding that we are created in God’s Image. However, if they did that, they could not hold the 2/3rd of views that they claim are “conservative” but, in truth, are radical departures of tradition.

  • Kontos

    You get the governance you deserve and want.
    Stop complaining. It’s bad form.

  • Pingback: Rise of the Christian left: Why the religious right’s moment may be ending | Freethought()