Is Pope Francis’ choice of Cupich for Chicago good news for liberals?

Print More
Banner on website of the Archdiocese of Chicago

Fair Use

Banner on website of the Archdiocese of Chicago

Banner on website of the Archdiocese of Chicago

Banner on website of the Archdiocese of Chicago

The American Papist’s Thomas Peters refuses to believe it. While Spokane Bishop Blase Cupich wouldn’t have been his numero uno to succeed Cardinal Francis George as archbishop of Chicago, Peters disputes the (RNS) story line that conservatives have been given a bitter pill to swallow.

For Peters, Cupich merely “talks in a way that makes liberals feel comfortable.” The substance of what  he has to say is “almost always sound and orthodox.”

Not by conservative standards. Take same-sex marriage. When Washington State held a referendum on it in 2012, Cupich (as Peters notes) spoke up in opposition. Here’s how he began an op-ed in the Spokane Spokesman-Review as follows:

The strongly held positions on both sides of the effort to redefine marriage at issue in Referendum 74 are a testament to the common desire to build a society that promotes human growth and advancement…My hope is that by focusing on the shared aspiration of promoting human progress, we can discuss our differing viewpoints, as passionately as they are held, with both civility and clarity.

But it wasn’t just that, in contrast to other bishops writing on the subject, Cupich rhetorically acknowledged the high moral purpose of those on the other side. He went so far as to support Washington’s existing State Registered Domestic Partnerships law. “Current state law already provides same sex couples with those rights and freedoms,” he wrote. “Nothing should be done to diminish them for the coming generations.”

In other words, it’s not just that Cupich won’t be following in the culture warrior footsteps of Cardinal George, who just this month portrayed acceptance of same-sex relationships as “worship of a false God.” The next occupant of the See of Chicago does not support the position of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops that “legal approval” of civil unions or domestic partnerships “contributes to the erosion of the authentic meaning of marriage. As such, they are never acceptable.”

It’s also worth bearing in mind that, in Catholicism as in life, style can also be substance. At a time when prelates like Cardinal George have been concerned to enforce episcopal control over Catholic higher education, Cupich takes a different tack. While in Spokane, he has made it a practice to join the religious studies faculty at Gonzaga University annually for a free-wheeling seminar.

“He likes to participate in theological discussion,” said one faculty member. “He understands that Catholic universities have a responsibility to engage with thinkers and to discuss issues quite broadly; that they play a role related to but distinct from that of faith formation and teaching as carried out by parishes or dioceses.” He will, said the faculty member “be missed.”

  • Mary Carney

    I don’t understand why Cardinal Levada who also supported domestic partnership solutions is labelled a conservative and Cupich who also does is somehow different?

  • Hilary Boone

    First of all, did Cardinal Lavada support domestic partnership? Somehow I missed that one. Second, I am from Louisville, KY. a lot of us thought our Archbishop Joseph Kurtz, would have been a candidate the Church usually likes to elevates to Cardinal, to Chicago. Archbishop Kurtz been since, being named Archbishop of Louisville in 2007, Vice President of the USCCB, and now is the current “President” of the USCCB. Recently Pope Francis assigned Archbishop Kurtz as a member of the “Sacred Congregation for the Oriental Churches”, one of the head offices, so to speak, that assist the Pope on matters worldwide in regards to the Catholic Churches of the Eastern Rite, which are quite a few in number throughout the world but not so much here in the United States. However, while a lot of us in Louisville would not want to lose our Archbishop to Chicago, he sure had the credentials and the support of his fellow bishops as vice president, and now president of the USCCB, and even Pope Francis appointing him to the Cogregation for the Oriental Churches.

  • Lover Fashion

    www lover-fashion com