Pope Francis: ‘Isaiah was not a communist!’

Print More
Pope Francis gestures as he speaks during his weekly general audience in St. Peter's Square at the Vatican, on Feb. 24, 2016. Photo courtesy of REUTERS/Max Rossi
*Editors: This photo may only be republished with RNS-POPE-EMPLOYERS, originally transmitted on May 19, 2016.

Pope Francis gestures as he speaks during his weekly general audience in St. Peter's Square at the Vatican, on Feb. 24, 2016. Photo courtesy of REUTERS/Max Rossi *Editors: This photo may only be republished with RNS-POPE-EMPLOYERS, originally transmitted on May 19, 2016.

VATICAN CITY (RNS) Wading again into the fraught issue of economic inequality and biblical teachings, Pope Francis on Wednesday (Feb. 24) spoke passionately about Isaiah’s warning to the greedy and assured thousands who gathered in St. Peter’s Square that the prophet “wasn’t a communist!”

“Richness and power are realities that can be good and useful for the common good, if they are put to the service of the poor and all, with justice and charity,” Francis said during his weekly general audience in the Vatican.

“But when, as happens too often, they become lived as privilege, with egoism and presumption, they are transformed into instruments of corruption and death,” the pope explained.

Francis referred at one point to the famous reproaches to the greedy in the fifth chapter of Isaiah, and then in an impromptu addition said: “And the prophet Isaiah wasn’t a communist!”

The pontiff’s lines on the exploitation of the powerless drew wide applause and highlighted not only themes that he has often addressed but also the debates over whether the pope — and Catholic teaching — lean toward some form of Marxism.

The Prophet Isaiah, in fresco.

Photo courtesy of Raphael [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons

The prophet Isaiah, in fresco.

Francis’ critics among conservatives in the U.S. in particular have often accused him of being a “left-winger” or a communist.

Democratic presidential candidate Bernie Sanders, on the other hand, has praised Francis as a “socialist” like himself.

While Francis has eschewed ideological labels, he has continued to teach that Christians who do not act on the gospel commands to care for the poor are “fake” Christians, as he said earlier this week.

That’s a reprise of the argument that prompted a recent spat with the leading Republican presidential candidate, Donald Trump.

On Wednesday, Francis also referred to the story in the Hebrew Bible of Naboth, who was killed so a greedy king could take over his land.

Francis said this story was relevant today as well:

“It’s the story of human trafficking, of slave labor, of poor people that work ‘in black’ (‘under the table’) and with the minimum salary to enrich the powerful!

“It’s the story of corrupt politicians who want more and more and more!”


RELATED STORY: Pope Francis again blasts ‘fake’ Christians in Mass homily


Francis also recommended that his listeners read a short book on the lessons of the Naboth saga by the fourth-century saint and bishop, Ambrose — a text that is famous as one of the earliest and most enduring treatises on the Christian view of economic injustice.

Francis’ comments this week followed his recent criticism of Mexico’s powerful elite and inequality in the country. “That wealth which tastes of pain, bitterness and suffering. This is the bread that a corrupt family or society gives its own children,” he said during Mass in Ecatepec, a city that has been plagued by drug-related violence.

(Rosie Scammell covers the Vatican for RNS)

  • Pingback: Pope Francis: ‘Isaiah was not a communist!’ | Christian News Agency()

  • Betty Clermont

    This pope is all “do as I say, not as I do.” As revealed in Nuzzi’s and Fittipaldi’s books, only 20% of the 378,000,000 euro the pope received expressly for charity in 2013 was given to the poor. The pope indicted both reporters for revealing his secrets. Although Il Sole 24 Ore stated the Vatican’s assets – securities, non-ecclesial real estate and bank accounts – for all its departments and offices combined “by a conservative estimate” would be around 15,000,000,000 -17,000,000,000 euro, only two refugee families are being cared for.

  • Pingback: PopeWatch: Isaiah – The American Catholic()

  • Ann Malley

    ….His Holiness could perhaps make reference to Donald’ Trump’s assertions that, if he is POTUS, he wouldn’t allow the poor to die in our streets. This expression of Christian charity is something that had Trump publicly excoriated in last night’s, final GOP debate on CNN.

    Perhaps a public and more formal statement could be made about exploring the truth in its fullness of what true charity meas. Helping the poor while, at the same time, not neglecting one’s duty to protect one’s citizens.

  • Pingback: Isaiah was no Communist! | Oblates of St. Benedict()

  • Dr. Cajetan Coelho

    Christians are called to try to be Christ-like.