After the simmering verbal and physical violence of this past weekend in relation to Donald Trump’s campaign, I have a question for you:
Will God save us from Donald Trump?
By this I mean: given Trump’s increasingly manifest moral-psychological problems, and the increasing danger he poses to the Republic, both intensifying in proportion to the positive and negative attention he is receiving, how long will it be until divine justice prevails and he is finally brought low?
Such a question will make no sense to those who do not agree with my description of who Donald Trump is and what he is currently doing to our country. If you don’t agree, I will not here attempt to persuade you. I refer you to the video from the last year, and the last weekend.
But if you do agree, and if you are a person of faith, I invite you to consider further questions that extend deep into the roots of biblical faith.
Has God created the kind of world in which tyrants are usually defeated?
Is there a divinely-given structure to the universe in which tyranny, just of its own nature, burns itself out?
Does the good and just God of the universe intervene in human history to bring tyrants down?
These kinds of questions arise in every context in which tyranny arises and God is believed in. It could be a setting as simple as a family, school, or workplace, or as complex as a city, state, or nation.
Whatever the context, a tyrant arises. Driven by any particular number or combination of inner demons, this person dominates, bullies, and harms those he is supposed to serve. The greater his power, the greater the harm he does. For a time, no one seems able to stop him, despite many prayers and profound suffering.
But so often, in the end, tyrants are destroyed.
The Bible speaks often of tyrants being brought low. Isaiah 13:11 is a representative verse:
I [God] will punish the world for its evil, and the wicked for their iniquity;
I will put an end to the pride of the arrogant, and I will lay low the insolence of tyrants.
This is a comforting promise to anyone under the heel of a tyrant. And very often history’s most brash and arrogant tyrants, the conquerors and emperors of the world, have indeed been brought low. They thought their reign would last forever, but it was over in the blink of an eye.
How did it happen? Did God look down from heaven and say, “Enough!”
Or are tyrants brought down as a built-in consequence of their own actions? Might the downfall of tyrants look more like these lines from Psalm 1?
Happy are those who do not follow the advice of the wicked, or take the path that sinners tread, or sit in the seat of scoffers;
but their delight is in the law of the Lord, and on his law they meditate day and night.
They are like trees planted by streams of water, which yield their fruit in its season, and their leaves do not wither.
In all that they do, they prosper.
The wicked are not so, but are like chaff that the wind drives away…
For the Lord watches over the way of the righteous, but the way of the wicked will perish.
This wisdom psalm assumes that God has created the kind of world in which the lives of godly people, rooted in divine law and seeking moral virtue, yield good fruit. The wicked, however, self-destruct. The residue of their lives is like chaff that blows away in the wind.
There are logical reasons why tyrants are brought low, no miracles required. One reason is that their actions inevitably evoke opposition. Those who are denigrated, harmed, or threatened form the first circle of opposition. Those who are morally offended but not directly threatened often join them, if they are brave enough. Those tempted to remain bystanders find it increasingly difficult to sit on the sidelines, their self-interest giving way to the higher claim of conscience.
It is of the nature of the tyrant to respond to such opposition with more denigration, harm, and threat. This widens the resistance all the further, so clashes and suffering deepen. The tyranny then intensifies in response, leading to greater and more costly resistance. And so it goes, until the spiral reaches some kind of terrible climax.
I am NOT claiming either that God can be counted on to intervene when human communities are threatened by tyrants, or that a tyrant’s self-destruction will always occur before he does great damage. Many tyrants have been brought low only after they had time to do a great deal of harm.
I have no doubt that Donald Trump is becoming a kind of tyrant-in-waiting (a shocking development, really) and that one day he will be brought low. But I do not know whether he will be brought low on Tuesday; or at the GOP Convention this summer; or in the November election; or sometime after we Americans foolishly, tragically, unforgivably, make him president. I do not know whether he will be given time and power to do the kinds of harm that his behavior and that of some of his followers suggest might be possible.
That, really, is up to us. Because we still live in a democracy. At least for now.