Institutions Mark Silk: Spiritual Politics Opinion

Where is the “tainted money” of yesteryear?

In the last gilded age, some of the malefactors of great wealth, as Teddy Roosevelt called them, turned to philanthropy. This did not sit well with everybody.

When Baptist John D. Rockefeller got all ecumenical and gave $100,000 to the Congregational Board of Missions in 1905, Washington Gladden, the nation’s foremost Congregational preacher and longtime scourge of the Standard Oil Trust, called the money “tainted” and demanded that it be returned. A few years later, cries of “tainted money” again rang out when, in the midst of government’s antitrust suit against Standard Oil, Rockefeller sought a national charter to establish the Rockefeller Foundation as a Great Charitable Trust to manage his good works.

After the 1914 Ludlow Massacre, when hired militiamen gunned down dozens of coal miners striking a Rockefeller-owned mine in Colorado, strike leader and United Mine Workers official John Lawson testified to Congress that in addition to indifference to the conditions of workers, there was another cause of industrial discontent that “also flows from a Rockefeller source.”

This is the skillful attempt that is being made to substitute philanthropy for justice. There is not one of these foundations now spreading their millions over the world in showy generosity that does not draw those millions from some form of industrial injustice. It is not their money that these lords of commercialized virtue are spending, but the withheld wages of the American working class.

Frank Walsh, the fiery lawyer who headed the congressional investigation into the Massacre, declared that the setting up of scientific or social work foundations would lead to a condition of “loyalty and subservience” to men of wealth and to their interests “from the whole profession of scientists, social workers and economists.” Already, he said, there were “thousands of men in these professions receiving subsidies, either directly or indirectly, from the Rockefeller Estate.” No sensible person could believe, said Walsh, “that research workers, publicists, and teachers can be subsidized with money obtained from the exploitation of workers without being profoundly influenced in their points of view and in the energy and enthusiasm with which they might otherwise attack economic abuses.”

Not only did the Rockefeller Foundation fail to get its national charter (it ended up incorporating in New York State), but, more importantly, it learned the importance of engaging high-level professional staff and giving grants to organizations independent of foundation control. As Rockefeller adviser Raymond Fosdick (brother of the liberal minister Harry Emerson Fosdick), wrote, “In no other way could the objectivity of research be established beyond cavil and the projects freed from suspicion of ulterior interest.”

In the current gilded age, such concerns and lessons seem to have all but disappeared. Yesterday’s New York Times ran “Goldman, Buying Redemption,” an article by Susanne Craig on the philanthropic activities of Goldman, Sachs suggesting that the purchase has been successful. Yes, as the subhead declared, the firm’s “big splash of philanthropy prompts critics to ask: How much is too much?” But the criticism merely had to do with the $2 million salary of Dina Powell, head of the Goldman Sachs Foundation, and Warren Buffett’s objection to doing good works with investors’ money. That there might be something problematic in a misbehaving $1 trillion financial giant restoring its image through philanthropy did not seem to occur even to Barney Frank, who told the Times, “I am glad they are doing it.”

Goldman, it should be emphasized, is merely following a pattern increasingly common since the 1980s, when former Treasury Secretary Bill Simon and other leading conservatives began foundations and think tanks for not advancing the economic and political agendas of their founders. What was needed were foundations and think tanks that did exactly that — and voila! Simon and his pals created them. But as Frank Walsh recognized, philanthropic work with an overt ideological agenda may be the least of it. Consider the medical institutions funded by the Koch Brothers and how such finding may affect the points of view and the energy and enthusiasm with which the beneficiaries the problems with health care in America.

Tainted money? These days, it’s take the money and run.

About the author

Mark Silk

Mark Silk is Professor of Religion in Public Life at Trinity College and director of the college's Leonard E. Greenberg Center for the Study of Religion in Public Life. He is a Contributing Editor of the Religion News Service


Click here to post a comment

  • Another type of a a bad credit score loan may be acquired from some banks and purchaser loan firms.
    The auto industry has suffered the most in the existing economic crisis.
    On approval, the rest from the process is going to be finished around the following day.

  • But what perhaps unites them all is that a home is actually
    one of the few places where you belong, a place that you can call it your own.
    Changes can be made to the home or to the landscaping without
    obtaining a landlord’s approval or permission. MISTAKE 6:
    Neglecting loose tiles and gaps in grout.

  • This might create a property tax readjustment for those who are clever.
    The thing all these tax decline owners have in common by the time the sale rolls around is this: they are ready
    to sell to you, quickly, and for much, much less than you’ll pay bidding at
    the sale. At The Roofing Company, we only use the highest quality manufactured products on
    every project.

  • Depending on the severity of the damage, they
    can also be extremely inconvenient. The thing all these tax
    decline owners have in common by the time the sale rolls around
    is this: they are ready to sell to you, quickly, and for much,
    much less than you’ll pay bidding at the sale. If you leave it unsealed, moisture will seep in, and mildew and mold can result.

  • The versatile and durable feature of Loctite GO2 Glue will make it resistant to impact, shock, vibration, temperature extremes and water.
    It can be very difficult to find the right matching
    material in order o make the necessary repairs.
    Handymen charge either on hourly basis or on piece-rate basis, determined
    before the work starts.

  • The cost of chimney repair on a one story house can
    start at around $1500 and run up into the $2000 range.
    These grants are free financial aids and you do not
    have to pay them off too. People from any walk of life have the opportunity for success.

  • Now, if you are seeking a solution to the dreaded problem
    then you have a few options at your disposal:. The
    pneumatic tools are essentially the newer adaptation of hand tools that need highly compressed
    air and much more potent than manual tools. Handymen
    charge either on hourly basis or on piece-rate basis,
    determined before the work starts.

  • One area that is easy to neglect is the attic, but a poorly
    insulated attic will lose an awful lot of heat,
    and in addition will let a lot of heat in during a
    hot summer. This results in a natural, stylish looking exterior.
    In fact, fear of unknown and undisclosed defects is probably the biggest fear of any buyer, and these are why it is important to have home inspections and pest inspections.

  • John reviews the need for the group members to share about those situations that each
    face in school each day during their interactions with students,
    teachers, and other school personnel. If your Bosch appliance is older than 12 months there is a
    good chance that it might be out of the warranty. Fasten the splice sleeve and
    the post above to the interior sliding piece using stainless steel

  • There are many home maintenance things you can do to spruce
    up your home. If you don’t take the steps to taking good care of your investment then you
    could wind up paying more money than you wish to.

    Manually collecting fallen leaves is the first step and may
    be one of those tasks you prefer to keep avoiding, but putting
    it off will only cause bigger problems later on.

  • The cost of chimney repair on a one story house can start at around $1500 and run up into
    the $2000 range. One of the hotly contested concern when it comes to sink
    hole homes would be the decreasing value of properties soon after being repaired.
    This usually isn’t the case and you can plan on doing more
    home repairs in the future.

  • The CMI offers the most extensive mold testing when it comes to air, walls, floors and appliances.
    You will possibly not hold the time to accomplish such small work or else
    you might not know how to fix them. Doing plumbing correctly will avoid
    creating havoc in your machine.

  • Yet, some systems are made to be more appealing by incorporating giant housings that display lots of extra controls and gauges
    that you don. Make several passes to vacuum up all the water that you can.
    Second, you will need to remove the cover panel, which is
    not very hard to do.

  • You will get a great amount of pride when the job is done looking at these photos.
    With these few tricks of the trade and professional quality supplies, you will be.
    They will minimize any digging of the landscaping and replace the grass or plants so that your garden
    continues to shine and your flowers and plants continue to thrive.

  • If you don’t feel comfortable doing that, have a separate
    solution container on your cleaner or are using the hand scrub method just apply the mixture directly to the stain with
    a spray bottle or by pouring on. If you have limited time and the budget for it
    I highly suggest Hoover. Dry vapor output can melt the dirt and dust in concrete joints too.

  • Consumer Contact: For additional information, contact Conair at (800) 687-6916 between 8:30 a.
    But they provide the same high level of cleaning efficiency.
    On the other hand, people spend very little time thinking about the best cleaning machines for their hard floors.

  • Members of the family come out of their work zones and do collaborative
    work over the dining table and discuss ideas in the area.
    Experts can tell where and why a piece was created just by looking at the kinds of patterns carved into the wood.
    The most powerful way to achieve success today
    is to ensure that a business or individuals do have an online

  • Amazing things right here. Now i’m pretty contented to visit your write-up. Many thanks a whole lot with this particular awaiting make contact with an individual. Will you please drop us a e-mail?