Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton speaks at Foundry United Methodist Church's bicentennial service in Washington on Sept. 13, 2015. Photo courtesy of Reuters/Yuri Gripas

United Methodist devotions supported Clinton during the 2016 campaign

NEW YORK (UMNS) When a small group of young clergywomen joined an effort to provide a daily devotion to Hillary Clinton during the recent U.S. presidential campaign, they were looking to support a fellow United Methodist.

But they also created the #wepraywithher project as a way to acknowledge the work of Clinton and other women who have broken both glass ceilings and stained-glass ceilings.

Eventually, 116 women under 40 — elders, deacons, licensed local pastors — participated in the campaign, which started Sept. 1 and continued through the end of 2016, the organizers said.

“We wanted to do something that says thank you to the women who came before us because we know we are standing on their shoulders,” explained the Rev. Emily Peck-McClain, 36, an assistant professor at the seminary of Eastern Mennonite University in Harrisonburg, Va., and one of the organizers.

Peck-McClain and three others on the “wepraywithher” editorial team — the fifth was on a mission trip to Cambodia — attended a Jan. 31 lunch at the Interchurch Center in New York where Clinton greeted some of those who had written devotions for her.

The Rev. Bill Shillady, director of the United Methodist City Society and a pastoral friend of the Clinton family, arranged for the lunch and is in negotiations with Abingdon Press to publish a collection of the devotions for broader use.

He first started sending the daily missives to Clinton on his own but later turned to colleagues from the New York Conference for assistance, eventually recruiting “the rainbow of Methodism,” along with a few of other faith traditions. “I think it gave her the opportunity to hear different voices,” he said.

The young clergywomen became aware of the project after the Democratic National Convention in Philadelphia, where Shillady gave the closing prayer.

The Rev. J. Paige Boyer, 35, a United Methodist pastor serving two churches in the Cleveland area, said she was struck by the religious tone at the convention and the role that faith had played in Clinton’s life. She shared her impressions in a post to a Facebook group of clergywomen under 40. “This amazing group of women” heard the call and stepped up to respond, she said.

“For me, it was about praying for, being in relationship and supporting someone who was United Methodist, whose faith clearly influenced her politics as she ran for the highest office in the country,” Boyer said.

Peck-McClain, who knew Shillady, reached out to him and learned about the daily devotions project, which seemed like a good avenue for spiritual support. “We all have people we are praying for and with and preaching to every week,” she pointed out. “This was an extension to that call we already have.”

The Rev. Danyelle Ditmer, 34, pastor of Wall Street United Methodist Church in Jeffersonville, Ind., signed on, creating a website and Google forms for those who wanted to participate.

“One of the things that draws me to her (Clinton) as a leader is how much she talks about her faith and how real that is to her,” she said.

Rounding out the #wepraywithher editorial team were the Rev. Shannon Sullivan, 29, pastor of Presbury United Methodist Church in Edgewater, Md., and the Rev. Jen Tyler, 32, pastor of Evergreen United Methodist Church in Wahpeton, N.D.

Sullivan is the daughter of a clergywoman, the Rev. Melissa McDade, and is well aware of both the accomplishments of her mother and her colleagues and the challenges they have faced. Her mother handled blatant sexism “with such grace,” Sullivan said. “I feel like Hillary Clinton did that as well.”

Young women still get “pushback” over their personal and career choices, Tyler added. To have a woman, regardless of politics, as a nominee for president, she believes, “was a huge moment” for the country.

“This wasn’t a partisan thing," Peck-McClain said. “We made it very clear that participating in the project was not about who you were voting for.”

The devotions — edited by the team before being sent to Shillady — focused on women in the Scriptures, women such as Queen Esther, who stepped forward on behalf of her people after a decree was made for the Jews to be killed.

In fact, Esther 4:14 was the most popular passage used by the #weprayforher devotion writers: “For if you keep silence at such a time as this, relief and deliverance will rise for the Jews from another quarter, but you and your father’s family will perish. Who knows? Perhaps you have come to royal dignity for just such a time as this.”

Each writer offered their own frame of reference on that and other biblical passages, Sullivan said, which they also shared among themselves, providing “another way to build community” among the group of young clergywomen.

“It became a part of my daily devotional to read and pray through those (messages),” Tyler said. “While they were written specifically for Secretary Clinton, they were timely for all of us.” Clinton was secretary of state during the Obama administration.

Shillady said the devotions, which focused on Advent and Christmas after the election, “helped center her (Clinton), helped her to have a start that was based in faith each day.”

Clinton spoke briefly during the Jan. 31 lunch about the impact the daily devotions had on her. “It was the first thing I would read in the morning,” she told the group.

In addition to the young clergywomen, the lunch participants included pastors from the New York Conference; the Rev. Frederick Davie, executive vice president of Union Seminary; the Rev. Amy Butler, senior minister of Riverside Church; and the Rev. Ginger Gaines-Cirelli, senior pastor of Foundry United Methodist Church, where the Clintons were members during Bill Clinton’s presidency.

“You kept me going,” Clinton said. “You gave me a lot of strength.”

(Linda Bloom is the assistant news editor for United Methodist News Service and is based in New York. Follow her at @umcscribe)

(This UMNS story is being made available to RNS subscribers)


  1. One thing this shows is that being a person of faith doesn’t have to result in political Conservatism. In fact, political Conservatism in many ways is opposed to basic Christian values, such as justice and equality for all.

  2. So the Methodists integrated Hilliary Clinton into their devotions back during the campaign, and she went down in defeat! Seems God is trying to tell the Methodists something about mixing politics with spirituality!

  3. I liked that they considered this to be non-partisan and simply intended to provide her with support.

  4. that’s only because you don’t understand Justice and equality, Daniel. Justice is, we get what we deserve, not what we expect the Lord to give us. Equality is that we are equal to each other and don’t expect the Lord to wink at our sin.

  5. Here is a good article about Justice or mishpat. A huge part of justice is the defense of the vulnerable and the downtrodden. Conservative political thought often favors the rich and the powerful. Another aspect of justice is paying workers fair wages. Republicans are often opposed to unions as well as any minimum wage. Justice often favors the powerless.

  6. The point of devotionals is not to move the heart of God but rather to move the hearts of people, and not enough of them were sufficiently moved to put Hilliary in the White House! These Methodist devotionals were ineffective in the political realm, so they may as well have been written from a purely spiritual motive!

  7. I sincerely doubt there was ever any intention to change voting behavior by this project. It is no difference from Mike Pence’s “PRAYER WARRIORS.” They pray for him and these people prayed for HRC. That’s it.

  8. Then the writer of this article should have stated that, rather than implying that the Methodist were praying for HRC to win! Otherwise why bother?
    It would be more impressive and valuable to one’s readers to write–in a more interesting fashion, about HRC’s stretch for spiritual growth after losing the election, and what a tremendous example she could be now that she’s out of politics and has the money and time for lots of spiritual growth and servant leadership in the non-profit field?

  9. I don’t believe it was implied this particular group of Methodists were praying for an HRC win. That’s not part of the Methodist playbook. HRC has always been one of the more “religious” people to run for President. One could say Jimmy Carter was more so, and Benjamin Harrison, even though the latter’s understanding of his faith justified the massacre of Native Americans. Among others who did not win, of course, William Jennings Bryan and George and Mitt Romney come to mind. Bill Clinton, too, has a close relationship with a congregation of Pentecostals in Alexandria, Louisiana, who were his “prayer warriors.” One also generally thinks of the two Adamses as pious, and James Garfield, even though he was like Bill Clinton, known to be particularly prone to the sin of lust. Garfield could serve as a great example that there is never such a thing as a pious man who is entirely free from sin.

    As for the rest there have been most who’ve paid lip service to “American Civil Religion.” There we would include Washington, Lincoln, both Roosevelts, and most others. Two in particular, Ronald Reagan and George W. Bush, used religion to exploit opportunities for them.

    But perhaps the most interesting comment on religion was made by George H.W. Bush, who as a World War II military pilot survived a plane crash via parachute. An interviewer asked him many years later when he was running for President what he thought of during that parachute jump. He said he thought of what America meant to him including “the separation of church and state.” Now, both Bushes had erratic speech but that revealed his good heart as well as the genius of America. Without separation of church and state America could never strive for greatness of any sort. I pray the guy who said he likes Two Corinthians knows that.

  10. This big flood of words reaffirms the fact that your contributions here are more about trying to impress us with your vast knowledge and highly informed opinions that have nothing to do with the article we’re all discussing here. Plus it reaffirms your HUGE need to be right! There’s nothing in this devotional topic that’s a part of the Methodist playbook! Get a life!

Leave a Comment