Former KKK member, now a Catholic priest, went public after journalist’s inquiry

The Rev. William Aitcheson is temporarily stepping away from public ministry after writing in an op-ed that he was a member of the Ku Klux Klan decades ago. Photo courtesy of Catholic Diocese of Arlington

(RNS) — It was not images from the white nationalist rally in Charlottesville, Va., that spurred a Virginia priest to come forward this month and confess he was a Ku Klux Klan member charged in several cross-burnings in Maryland and other offenses 40 years ago.

Rather, it was a journalist who had contacted the Diocese of Arlington and said she learned that the Rev. William Aitcheson’s legal name matched that of a man arrested in the 1970s.

Diocesan officials then confronted the priest.

“Aitcheson was approached about this, he acknowledged his past and saw the opportunity to tell his story in the hopes that others would see the possibility of conversion and repentance,” the diocese said in a statement.

Until earlier this week, Aitcheson served as parochial vicar at St. Leo the Great in Fairfax, Va. He has since been granted a leave of absence.

In a personal essay published in The Arlington Catholic Herald, the priest appears to be motivated by the national news to acknowledge his past: “The images from Charlottesville brought back memories of a bleak period in my life that I would have preferred to forget.”

He is referring to an Aug. 12 rally by white nationalists against the removal of a statue of Confederate Gen. Robert E Lee. Authorities canceled the rally after violent skirmishes erupted, and the day ended in tragedy when a man rammed a car into anti-racist protesters, killing a woman. Two law enforcement officers also died when their helicopter crashed as they were monitoring the day’s events. 

Citing his own white supremacist views as a young man, the 62-year-old priest wrote: “My actions were despicable. When I think back on burning crosses, a threatening letter, and so on, I feel as though I am speaking of somebody else. It’s hard to believe that was me.”

In his 20s, while a student at the University of Maryland, Aitcheson was charged with making bomb threats, manufacturing pipe bombs and threatening to kill Coretta Scott King in a letter.

Aitcheson pleaded guilty to several cross burnings, including one in the front yard of an African-American couple in 1977. He was convicted, sentenced to 90 days and ordered to pay a judgment of about $20,000, according to The Washington Post.

In 1982, he was also ordered to pay civil damages to the couple, Phillip and Barbara Butler. The diocese acknowledged he did not pay those damages.

“Father Aitcheson fully understands this is his obligation and that he must do what is possible to make this situation right,” the diocesan news release said.

A spokesman for Arlington Bishop Michael F. Burbidge said the bishop was not available for an interview.

Aitcheson attended seminary in Rome and in 1988 was ordained a priest for the Diocese of Reno-Las Vegas, Nev. He transferred to the Arlington Diocese in 1993.

It’s not clear when the Arlington Diocese first learned of Aitcheson’s past.

About the author

Yonat Shimron

Yonat Shimron is an RNS National Reporter and Senior Editor.


Click here to post a comment

  • For the good of his testimony as a Christian and a priest, Father Aitcheson is obligated to meet the civil judgment entered against him by the court, with perhaps a reasonable penalty for avoiding that obligation 35 years.

  • It appears that Father Aitcheson has been a priest in good standing for more than 30 years, quite a change from the horrid and indefensible things he did when younger. So, do we believe in redemption or not? He certainly owes a direct apology to the Butlers and now that his background is public perhaps it will be easier to follow up with them. As to the $23,000 in restitution, I’m unclear if a priest who takes a vow of poverty can ever repay such a debt. Then again, maybe his congregation can help out…. All in all, isn’t it better that Aitcheson has changed rather than continue as a cross-burning bigot? How many of us have not done dumb things when younger (although what he did was at the far, far right end of the dumb spectrum)?

  • Diocesan priests do not take a vow of poverty. Aitcheson should pay the Butlers and the Jewish groups the $23,000 he owes them — PLUS INTEREST — and personally apologize to them.

  • I believe in redemption and repentance too, but that can’t happen without the restitution and the direct apology. Otherwise he has not truly repented. He’s still running away from his past crimes.
    One question I had is when/if/how he converted to Catholicism. The Klan was originally nativist and anti-Catholic, although this may have waned as white Catholics are not longer directly associated with the immigrants the Klan hated 100 years ago. Apparently David Duke allowed white Catholics in his organization.
    ETA: Looking at the priest’s statement, he indicates that as a “young adult” he “was Catholic, but in no way practicing my faith.” So it would seem that he was born into the faith or at least was baptized as a child, but fell away from it by the time he got to college.

  • It’s hard to know if the KKK hated Catholics because they were immigrants or immigrants because they were Catholics. The bottom line is that they hated.

  • This man is a Coward hiding in the Catholic Priesthood. No apology to his victims 30+ years later. He is a Phony!

  • Other articles indicate that he both served the civil penalties and after his personal conversion, the diocese was aware of his story and background. It shouldn’t be left dangling like that in the report when it’s been reported elsewhere.