Culture Ethics

Is updated Band Aid charity song demeaning to Africans?

“Seeking help for some of the bigger challenges in Africa has often sparked off all types of stereotypes,” said Dr. Daniel Gobgab, the head of the Christian Health Association of Nigeria, pictured here. Photo by Fredrick Nzwili

NAIROBI, Kenya (RNS) Some church leaders are criticizing a British musicians’ charity group raising funds for the West African Ebola crisis, saying its new single reinforces negative stereotypes of Africa.

Band Aid, which was started 30 years ago by Bob Geldof, has re-recorded the charity title, “Do They Know It’s Christmas?”

The song was first recorded in 1984 to raise money to help victims of of the Ethiopia famine.

Where the original lyrics said: “Where the only water flowing is the bitter sting of tears,” the reworked lyrics have it: “Where a kiss of love can kill you and there’s death in every tear.”

Critics say the lyrics are patronizing and demeaning to Muslims in Liberia, Sierra Leone and Guinea who do not celebrate Christmas.

“I feel a whole new song is required,” Emeli Sande, a British singer-songwriter said in a tweet.

The general feeling here is that 30 years after the Ethiopian famine, Africa has surged forward. In fact, Nigeria was able to stem the Ebola crisis without much external help.

“Seeking help for some of the bigger challenges in Africa has often sparked off all types of stereotypes,” said Daniel Gobgab, the head of Christian Health Association of Nigeria, pictured here. Photo by Fredrick Nzwili

“Seeking help for some of the bigger challenges in Africa has often sparked off all types of stereotypes,” said Dr. Daniel Gobgab, the head of the Christian Health Association of Nigeria, pictured here. Photo by Fredrick Nzwili

“Seeking help for some of the bigger challenges in Africa has often sparked off all types of stereotypes,” said Dr. Daniel Gobgab, the head of the Christian Health Association of Nigeria. “This tends to overshadow the good that happen here.”

Not everyone agreed with the critique. The Rev. Kwabena Opuni-Frimpong, general secretary of the Christian Council of Ghana, said the continent still needs people who can help mobilize resources to help fight Ebola and the willingness to help is appreciated.

“They do that not because Africans are a bunch of helpless, hopeless people, but to remind the world of our common humanity and our common responsibility,” said Opuni-Frimpong.

In Sierra Leone, one of the countries bearing the brunt of the crisis, Ebun James–Dekam, general secretary of the Council of Churches, said Band Aid was raising funds for people who are suffering.

“I bet when the monies are sent to us we will not say we do not want it,” she said.

She blames some problems facing the continent on Africa itself.

West Africa’s most famous musicians recently released their own Ebola appeal song, which urges the people to trust doctors.

YS/AMB END NZWILI

About the author

Fredrick Nzwili

Fredrick Nzwili is a journalist based in Nairobi, Kenya. For more than 15 years, he has written about religion, politics, peace and conflict, development, security, environment and wildlife. His articles have appeared in international media organizations among others; The Tablet, The Christian Science Monitor, The National Geographic and Kenyan local newspapers; The Standard and the People Daily.

2 Comments

Click here to post a comment

  • Correction:

    “The song was first recorded in 1984 to raise money to help victims of of the Ethiopia famine.”

    The song definitely has some cringeworthy lyrics. The only reason it still gets any airplay is because it now joins the rotation of gawd-awful Christmas songs played on the classic rock format.

2019 NewsMatch Campaign: This Story Can't Wait! Donate.

ADVERTISEMENTs