Who belongs in America? Five faith leaders on immigration, identity and America's 250th

(RNS) A new five-part video series by RNS asks prominent faith leaders and thinkers to weigh in on the questions at the heart of the American experiment.

Immigrants on a ferry boat near Ellis Island, circa 1920. (Photo courtesy of NARA/CreativeCommons)

Pam Kruger

June 24, 2026 at 5:15 p.m. ET

(RNS) — As the United States marks its 250th anniversary, debates over national identity, religion and immigration have intensified. Was America founded as a Christian nation? A pluralistic democracy? A nation of immigrants? Who belongs, and who gets to decide?

In 2026, these questions are not abstractions as America grapples with an immigration crisis. Immigrant and faith communities have been on the front lines, navigating the federal enforcement system, shaping public opinion and wrestling with questions of responsibility and morality.

Religion News Service asked five prominent faith leaders and thinkers to weigh in. Their answers, in a new five-part video series beginning Thursday (June 25), are not uniform. Their perspectives reflect their different religious traditions, immigration experiences and personal visions of what America is and should be.

The series features Georgia pastor and U.S. Sen. Raphael Warnock; Rabbi Sharon Brous of IKAR in Los Angeles; historian John Fea of Messiah University; Tony Suarez, pastor and COO of the National Hispanic Christian Leadership Conference; and Eboo Patel, founder and president of Interfaith America.

In the opening episode (below), Patel argues “melting pot” is the wrong metaphor for America. Drawing on his experience as a Muslim immigrant from India, he proposes a different one: the United States as a “potluck nation” — a place where the expectation is not assimilation but contribution. Everyone brings something, and everyone is accountable to the table.

New episodes will be added each week to RNS’ YouTube channel and this page.

“What Does It Mean to Belong in America?” is a video project for the Atlas of American Belonging, Religion News Service’s multimedia initiative examining how belonging has been claimed, granted, challenged and denied at the intersection of faith and immigration. The Atlas is a project supported by the Henry Luce Foundation.

No paywalls here. Thanks to you.

As an independent nonprofit, RNS believes everyone should have access to coverage of religion that is fair, thoughtful and inclusive. That's why you will never hit a paywall on our site; you can read all the stories and columns you want, free of charge (and we hope you read a lot of them!)

But, of course, producing this journalism carries a high cost, to support the reporters, editors, columnists, and the behind-the-scenes staff that keep this site up and running. That's why we ask that if you can, you consider becoming one of our donors. Any amount helps, and because we're a nonprofit, all of it goes to support our mission: To produce thoughtful, factual coverage of religion that helps you better understand the world. Thank you for reading and supporting RNS.

Deborah Caldwell, CEO and Publisher

Donate today