N.C. Catholic dioceses quit church council over same-sex marriage amendment

A crucifix at St. Mark Catholic Church's chapel in Wilmington, N.C. Photo by Amanda Greene/Wilmington FAVS
A crucifix at St. Mark Catholic Church's chapel in Wilmington, N.C. Photo by Amanda Greene/Wilmington FAVS

A crucifix at St. Mark Catholic Church’s chapel in Wilmington, N.C. Photo by Amanda Greene/Wilmington FAVS

WILMINGTON, N.C. (RNS) At a time when Pope Francis is calling for the church to give up its obsession with homosexuality and abortion, North Carolina’s Roman Catholic dioceses are severing a long-held ecumenical bond over those issues.

Unable to resolve their differences, the dioceses of Raleigh and Charlotte have decided to withdraw their membership from the North Carolina Council of Churches effective at the end of the year.

For more than 30 years, North Carolina enjoyed a unique ecumenical alliance between Protestant and Catholics. The state council’s members advocated as one on issues such as economic justice, equality and peace. Recently, they pressed the U.S. Senate for transparency on torture of detainees held after 9/11, for example.

But in a joint statement, Bishop Michael Burbidge of Raleigh and Bishop Peter Jugis of Charlotte, said the alliance has resulted in religious leaders being associated with positions “that are at times in contradiction with their practice and the teaching of their faith.”

Bishop Peter Jugis of Charlotte photo courtesy Diocese of Charlotte

Bishop Peter Jugis of Charlotte photo courtesy Diocese of Charlotte

Specifically, the more liberal state council opposed a state constitutional amendment prohibiting same-sex marriage. The amendment passed in 2012 with the enthusiastic support of the two Catholic dioceses. And while the council has no position on abortion, the Catholic Church views it as an evil that must be opposed.

“We just were not able to resolve those issues, and they felt they could not continue as members,” said George Reed, the council’s executive director.

In an interview recently, the Roman Catholic pontiff said the church can’t be “obsessed” with abortion and homosexuality. Francis also said gays cannot be marginalized.

George Reed,  N.C. Council of Churches executive director photo courtesy N.C. Council of Churches

George Reed, North Carolina Council of Churches executive director. Photo courtesy North Carolina Council of Churches

The North Carolina Council of Churches was founded in 1935 and today includes members of 18 Christian denominations and eight individual congregations.

The Raleigh diocese joined in 1977. Over the years, the council staff included a prominent Catholic nun who helped the group craft its farmworker, immigration and peace initiatives, said Aleta Payne, the council’s press director.

The loss of the membership of the two dioceses will cost the council 10 percent of its yearly budget or about $12,000.

The Catholic Church is not a member body of the National Council of Churches, but regional councils sometimes include Catholics, said National Council of Churches press liaison Philip E. Jenks.

The North Carolina bishops said they hoped to continue working with the council on issues they agree on such as immigration reform, just wages, poverty and ending the death penalty.

“Half of the purpose of the Council of Churches was to promote a model of Christian unity across denominations that have divided us,” Reed said.

Lifelong Catholic Alberta Hairston, the council’s board president, said the move “has been personally difficult.”

“I understand where the bishops are coming from,” she said. “But there’s not that many vehicles for people of varying faith traditions to come together and discuss issues that promote the common good.”

About the author

Amanda Greene

Amanda Greene is the editor and community manager of Wilmington Faith & Values.


Click here to post a comment

  • I think you should refrain from using Pope Francis in rebuking the Bishops. The Pope did not say the church can’t make a stand against core moral issues – just not to be dragged into that conversation all the time. Besides, with the reform he is currently charting at the Vatican with collegiality & synodality, a lot of issues like this will be decided more on the local level with no imprimatur needed from the Vatican.

  • While I have seen several articles where the authors are quoting Pope Francise and then saying these Bishops are going against what he is saying but these authors are jumping to those conclusions. Bishop Burbidge has only said there were times where the Council and the Catholic faith were in contradiction with each other and felt it better to not be part of the council anymore. He has not stated anywhere what those contradictions were and has said he wants to continue working with the council on efforts they both agree on. Sounds like a man standing up for what he believes and supporting what his Pope says by not talking about these issues are all the time.

  • It’s telling in that, merely by quoting Pope Francis, anti-gay Roman Catholics (whom polls tell us are a minority of RCs, FWIW) feel these anti-gay bishops are being “rebuked”. Well, if the shoe fits…