Beliefs Brian Pellot: On Freedom Culture Ethics Opinion

South African lesbians counter violence with visibility in ‘African Pride’

A march in KwaThema township east of Johannesburg on September 17, 2011. Photo by Melanie Hamman Doucakis courtesy of Laura Fletcher.

CAPE TOWN (RNS) In 1996, South Africa became the first country to approve a constitution explicitly prohibiting discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation. Though progressive, the law has done little to prevent homophobic violence in the country’s impoverished townships.

In the documentary ‘African Pride’, which made its South African debut in April, Irish filmmaker Laura Fletcher shows how black lesbians and allied activists are rallying for their rights and memorializing their murdered sisters.

Fletcher started filming ‘African Pride’ in 2011 after working with a Johannesburg-based media monitoring group to improve ethical reporting standards on local human rights issues, including gender-based violence.

“Having done that for a year, I decided to stop preaching, put my money where my mouth is, and create a documentary,” she said.

Fletcher’s film details the unique economic, racial, gender and faith-based challenges facing black lesbians in South Africa’s townships. Rather than emphasizing the women as victims, Fletcher highlights how they are fighting violence and discrimination with grassroots activism.

A march in KwaThema township east of Johannesburg on September 17, 2011.

A march in KwaThema township east of Johannesburg on September 17, 2011.

In a scene from KwaThema, activist Ntsupe Mohapi confronts a man who shouts, “What’s this LGB what what what?  No my friend, This is against the Bible. This is abomination.”

“Those are the kind of people we need to have dialogues with,” Mohapi says in the film. “He says he’s a believer, a Christian, which I am also, so I don’t see a problem.”

Mohapi sees no theological problem in being a lesbian, but her experience in KwaThema reveals other serious concerns.

“Its not good living in a township as a black lesbian. It’s dangerous. You still can’t hold hands with your partner. There are some places you can’t go… so you find that your freedom is a bit limited,” she said.

Several men, not identified by name in the film, lend credibility to Mohapi’s fears.

“We have straight women, not gays. A woman must respect the man, simple as that,” one said. Another took a more violent tone: “If my son came to me and said, ‘I’m gay,’ I’d kill him. Even my brother, even my father. I’d f—— kill him. Or my sister. I’d f—— kill her.”

A march in KwaThema township east of Johannesburg on September 17, 2011.

A march in KwaThema township east of Johannesburg on September 17, 2011.

‘African Pride’ documents the murders of several South African lesbians between 2006 and 2011, among them Zoliswa Nkonyana and Noxolo Nogwaza.

Nkonyana was stabbed and stoned to death in Khayelitsha, Cape Town’s largest township, in 2006. In 2012, four men received prison sentences for her murder, the first time a South African court acknowledged that a victim had been murdered because of her sexual orientation. Nogwaza was raped, stoned and stabbed to death in 2011 in the KwaThema township east of Johannesburg. Her murder remains unsolved.

More than 20 LGBT people have been murdered in South Africa because of their sexuality or gender identity since Nogwaza’s death.

In the face of such violent attacks, local community organizers and activists continue to challenge the notion that being LGBT is un-African, against the will of God, or some kind of colonial hangover.

Patrick Godana is the government and media manager at Sonke Gender Justice and an ordained Lutheran priest in Cape Town.

“All forms of violence we are against, but this one is extraordinary, because of the issue of hatred and ignorance,” Godana said.

Godana is just one of the many LGBT-affirming ministers Fletcher came across in producing her film. The vast majority of activists she met were also Christian, South Africa’s dominant faith.

“Despite the language used to target them, they haven’t let that interfere with their own set of personal beliefs, they just counter it,” Fletcher said of the LGBT activists she interviewed.

“This ‘un-African,’ ‘un-Christian’ language is pervasive, but often it’s American money that’s perpetuating the idea that homosexuality is against the will of God. That’s definitely un-African,” she added, referencing allegations that American missionaries in some parts of the continent bear some responsibility for inciting homophobic violence.


Funeka Soldaat, founder of the advocacy group Free Gender, outside the Khayelitsha Magistrate’s Court in 2011. Photo by Melanie Hamman Doucakis, courtesy of Laura Fletcher

Fletcher screened ‘African Pride’ in KwaThema on April 24, the four-year anniversary of Nogwaza’s murder. 200 people, including members of Nogwaza’s family, attended the viewing.

A scene near the end of the film shows a homemade sign bearing Zoliswa Nkonyana’s photo and the caption “your death sparked our fight against hate.”

“All these years she’s been helping us fight. I think now she just needs to rest in peace,” said Funeka Soldaat, founder of the Khayelitsha-based advocacy group Free Gender.

For Nogwaza, whose murder remains unsolved, the fight continues.

The next screening of ‘African Pride’ in South Africa will be on June 24 at the Open Dialogue on Racism, Racial Discrimination, Xenophobia and Related Intolerance at Constitution Hill in Johannesburg. Amnesty International will host a screening on June 25 in London.