The Rev. Gil Caldwell spoke at Duke Divinity School on Oct. 18, 2017, 60 years after he was denied admission on account of his race. RNS photo by Yonat Shimron

Denied admission because he’s black, civil rights leader urges Duke Divinity to confront its past

DURHAM, N.C. (RNS) — He walks with a cane and proudly acknowledges his age — 83.

But the Rev. Gil Caldwell, best known as “a foot soldier" in the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr.’s army, is not about to retire his lifelong fight for racial justice.

When Duke Divinity School invited him to speak Wednesday (Oct. 18) during morning chapel services, he saw an opportunity to ask whether Duke was willing to confront its past.

More than 60 years ago, the divinity school denied him admission because he is black. Speaking at a service in Goodson Chapel, he asked: “What is it that God would have Duke Divinity School do in light of that history? For if one is not honest about that history, one can’t be fully present.”

Divinity School Dean Elaine Heath acknowledged that history in introducing Caldwell, saying the school wanted to “reckon with its inglorious past.” Later, over lunch, she, Caldwell and a group of Duke Divinity School students talked about racial healing.

Caldwell recounted that in the early 1950s, he was studying as an undergraduate at North Carolina A&T State University in Greensboro, about 50 miles to the west, when he felt a call to ministry.

Duke, which is affiliated with the United Methodist Church, seemed like a good fit for Caldwell, who is Methodist. But back in 1955, he told the students, the rejection letter he received said the trustees had not changed their policies on racial segregation.

"They hoped that I would find a seminary that would meet my needs,” he said, recalling the letter.

[ad number=“1”]

Caldwell attended Boston University’s School of Theology instead and there met the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr., who led him to a life protesting racial injustice. Caldwell marched alongside King to protest school segregation in Boston, to rally for jobs on the steps of the Lincoln Memorial in Washington in 1963 and to register black voters in the Selma to Montgomery, Ala., march in 1965.

Left to right, the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr., the Rev. Virgil Wood and the Rev. Gil Caldwell at a school in the Roxbury section of Boston in April 1965. Photo courtesy of the Caldwell Family Collection

 This image is available for web publication. For questions, contact Sally Morrow.

More recently, Caldwell has taken up the call for LGBTQ rights, championing full inclusion in the United Methodist Church, where he is a retired elder.

RELATED: Rev. Gil Caldwell, a ‘foot soldier’ for civil rights, turns his eye to LGBT rights

Caldwell is executive producer of the documentary “From Selma to Stonewall: Are We There Yet?,” which was to be screened Wednesday at a different Duke venue. The film follows Caldwell and LGBTQ activist Marilyn Bennett, who directed the movie, in an exploration of the similarities and differences between the black civil rights and LGBTQ rights movements.

“For me, he reflects a generation of clergy who have their pulse on the need for social justice,” said the Rev. Carl Kenney, an African-American graduate of Duke Divinity School, speaking of Caldwell.

[ad number=“2”]

Today, five of the divinity school’s 42 faculty members are African-American and 95 of its 608 students reported that they were either African-American or black.

Caldwell urged the school to do more by offering classes that explore the psychology behind racial and sexual injustice.

He recalled the story of Jesus meeting an invalid at a healing pool. When Jesus asked the man if he wanted to be healed, the man gave an excuse: “I have no one to help me into the pool.” (John 5:7) Jesus told him to “pick up his bed and walk.”

“I guess I ask the divinity school at this point: Are you willing to pick up your bed and walk?”


  1. I’d like to put in a good word for the Methodist church, which started universities like Boston University and London University when universities were closed to people because of race or religion. I hope the church remembers this openess when considering LGBT applicants for the clergy.

  2. “Caldwell urged the school to do more by offering classes that explore the psychology behind racial and sexual injustice.” Amen to that.

  3. ” The film follows Caldwell and LGBTQ activist Marilyn Bennett, who directed the movie, in an exploration of the similarities and differences between the black civil rights and LGBTQ rights movements.” There is no similarity between skin colour – granted by God – and choosing immorality. There is no connection. I wonder how Mr. Caldwell’s black friends feel with his comparing their skin colour to sin.

  4. Attaway Gil – a man sharing the wisdom he earned with decades of experience, courage, and commitment. He is a great example of what the term “elder” really means.

  5. Time to treat Sandi’s disgraceful posts the same way posts from Jimmie Cooper Boswell are ignored.

    Bye Sandi !!

  6. Don’t worry. Gil Caldwell and other activists have made it abundantly clear that they will NEVER accept the Bible, and never accept the current Methodist Book Of Discipline, on this issue. Nor will they leave, nor will they stop their wide-open stuff.

    Which means that the much-heralded “Commission on a Way Forward” is actually in the process of backing down. The majority of them are either pro-gay or scared of a public split, hence they’re going to surrender.

    They will likely adopt a diplomatic word-salad in the next two years, that fully allows the gay marriages and practicing gay clergy to thrive and increase, despite the compelling words of their own Methodist Book and Christian Bible.

  7. You believe gay people choose to be ostracized and treated as less than a person? Treated like African-Americans were in Caldwell’s day? Does that make sense to you? They could have chosen to be straight and escaped all of the hatred and bigotry espoused by people like you? So why aren’t they straight? Maybe it’s because God made them that way.

  8. You should like someone who would have denied Caldwell entry in the divinity school too.

  9. Hardly. I couldn’t have gotten into Duke either, if you know what I mean.

    But honestly? It’s time for black Methodists and black Christians on general to openly speak out **against** Gil Caldwell and some of the black pro-gay bishops in the United Methodist Church.

    That’s not easy, because Caldwell does deserve much honor as a Christian civil rights leader who was out there with Dr. MLK Jr. Always want to acknowledge that.

    But he’s gone wrong. He’s doing wrong, he’s preaching wrong, he’s cashing in on his civil rights fame to openly promote wrong. A wrong that is mercilessly killing his own church as we speak, and sowing septic seeds into people’s minds & hearts.

    Black Christians gotta revoke Caldwell’s free pass and start opposing him NOW, even though he is still to be respected and honored for his civil rights work.

  10. They are not treated like African-Americans were. African Americans were kidnapped from their homeland, starved, lynched, placed in chains, beaten, raped, murdered with no respect for their being a person at all. African-Americans are a race.
    Homosexuals on the other hand, choose their sin and choose to wilfully defy the Lord and then whine that their rights to be immoral are not upheld. That does not constitute a legitimate minority.
    It is an insult to any African-American to equate their God given skin colour with someone’s choice to sin. (edited)

  11. I guess God’s love can’t pierce your blackened heart.

  12. Perhaps you should look to the reality of Christ

Leave a Comment