Cardinal Law’s death prompts apologies – and anger

Barbara Blaine, left, president of the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, and Barbara Dorris protest in front of the diocesan authorities headquarter in Munich, southern Germany, on Monday, March 22, 2010. The members of a U.S.-based group arrived in Munich that day to encourage more victims in Germany to come forward. "We want to reach out to any others who have been hurt. We ask them to speak out," Blaine said. Poster at right reads: Defend Children Not the Evildoer. (AP Photo/Matthias Schrader) (Caption amended by RNS)

(RNS) — When a leading cardinal in the Catholic Church dies, his legacy of caring for priests and believers is usually the highlight of remembrances.

Not so with Cardinal Bernard Law, driven out in disgrace as archbishop of Boston in 2002. His priests and his people had demanded he step down after a year of painful revelations that the diocese had known about — and sheltered — scores of priests who sexually abused children and teens. 

After Law died Wednesday (Dec. 20), his successor, Cardinal Sean O’Malley, issued a statement that began with an apology to “ … all who experienced the trauma of sexual abuse by clergy, whose lives were so seriously impacted by those crimes, and their families and loved ones.”

O’Malley offered them his “sincere apologies” and continued prayer and support for healing, before turning again to the tragic legacy of Law, putting him in the context of a wider church failure.

“As Archbishop of Boston, Cardinal Law served at a time when the Church failed seriously in its responsibilities to provide pastoral care for her people, and with tragic outcomes failed to care for the children of our parish communities. I deeply regret that reality and its consequences. … ”

Cardinal Daniel DiNardo, president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, went directly to the same point, beginning his statement by urging any victims today to contact both their church and their local law enforcement.

“As we reflect on the legacy of Cardinal Law, it will likely bring back painful memories for survivors. The Church seeks to always respond as supportive pastors,” DiNardo said. Even as he offered “prayers and condolences to the family and friends of Cardinal Law,” he prayed for the survivors of abuse to find “strength and peace in the mercy of Christ.”

The dean of the college of cardinals, Cardinal Angelo Sodano, will celebrate Law’s funeral Mass on Thursday at the main altar of St. Peter’s Basilica. And Pope Francis is expected to preside over a final prayer, a blessing with incense and the sprinkling of holy water around Law’s coffin, according to The Associated Press.

On Wednesday, Francis sent a condolence telegram to Sodano, that never mentioned Law’s role in Boston. Instead, the pontiff cited Law’s final role as archpriest of the St. Mary Major Basilica in Rome.

Victims are largely unforgiving of Law and the church that gave Law that position of honor in Rome after the debacle in Boston.

Clergy sex abuse victims are expressing anger at disgraced former Archbishop
Cardinal Bernard Law, who has died at the age of 86. Law was archbishop of
Boston when it was revealed that he failed to stop priests who molested children.

Barbara Dorris, executive director for SNAP — Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests — told the Boston Herald that their anger has not subsided in the years since the scandal exploded.

Law, the first famous cardinal to be exposed for leading a cover-up, was not punished by the Vatican, she pointed out. Instead, he was given comfortable positions in Rome in the wake of his resignation.

That’s when a lot of survivors got to the point of understanding that church officials appear to feel that they’re above the law. That they’re accountable to no one,” Dorris told the paper. “So Cardinal Law is dead. All we’re doing is changing the names, but the game, if you will, remains the same.”

On SNAP’s website, Western regional leader Joelle Casteix said victims felt doubly betrayed — first by Law’s cover-up of abuse and then by his “promotion to Rome.”

When it comes time for Law’s funeral, Casteix said, “Every single Catholic should ask Pope Francis and the Vatican ‘why?’ Why Law’s life was so celebrated when Boston’s clergy sex abuse survivors suffered so greatly? Why was Law promoted when Boston’s Catholic children were sexually abused, ignored, and pushed aside time and time again?”

Alexa MacPherson, molested as a child by a Boston priest, told The Associated Press, “Cardinal Law was complicit in my hiding abuse.” To the news of his death, she said, “Good riddance to bad rubbish.”

While the headlines focus on Law’s final years in Boston, Rabbi James Rudin, senior interreligious affairs adviser at the American Jewish Committee, said in a statement that it is also important to recall Law’s early support for civil rights and his global leadership in “building human bridges of mutual understanding and reconciliation between Catholics and Jews.”

Rudin, who worked with Law when the cardinal led the USCCB’s Commission on Ecumenical and Interreligious Affairs, said the prelate “understood the historic significance of the Second Vatican Council’s call in 1965 for a positive change in the Church’s teachings about Jews and Judaism, and he took actions to implement that revolutionary reform.”

About the author

Cathy Lynn Grossman

Cathy Lynn Grossman specializes in stories drawn from research and statistics on religion, spirituality and ethics. She also writes frequently on biomedical ethics and end-of-life-issues


Click here to post a comment

  • Mark 9:24 – English Standard Version

    “Whoever causes one of these little ones who believe in me to sin, it would be better for him if a great millstone were hung around his neck and he were thrown into the sea.

  • For what he did to the people of Boston he will never be forgiven. To the family of Law………hide your shame. We are disgusted that Boston did not have the pleasure to send him to prison. Hopefully, God will take care of him and make him pay for his sins against the people he was serving.

  • Talk is cheap. What is the Catholic Tyranny gonna do to recompense the victims?

    What is the church *really* gonna do to prevent future abuses? It has already cried crockadile tears, even while continuing to cover up in recent years!

    Sandinwindsor, you made a fantastic point!

  • Cardinal Law was only the tip of a very large iceberg. The abuse scandal has gone on for generfations and is worldwide. Spanish journalist Pepe Rodriguez published two excellent books on the subject

  • Oops — to continue — one titled The Sex Life of the Clergy and the other on the whole abuse scandal — just in Spain! Too bad the books are available only in Spanish. (Es una lastima que los dos libros no se pueden comprar en ingles.) — Edd Doerr

  • Seems likely Alexa MacPherson said or meant to say that Law was complicit in “hiding my abuse,” not in “my hiding abuse,” which makes her seem like an abuser herself.

  • Why? He had something on the money-loving John Paul II and some Roman cardinals. They were all complicit in the rape of the young.

  • I take it to be a tradition of some kind, but this one seems quaint to the point of ridiculousness. The guy’s on Twitter.

  • SNAP has forced the hierarchy to own their part in the pedophile crisis for the last 15 or more years! The Academy Award movie SPOTLIGHT also contributed mightily to showing people how this happened and exposing corrupt members of the hierarchy who clearly obstructed justice for decades!