Donate to RNS

Growing the religious left by confessing our sins against nature to plants

For these progressive Christians, the language of social justice is a way of translating the gospel message of a kingdom of heaven on earth into a contemporary world.

A service at Union Theological Seminary involving plants. Photo via @UnionSeminary/Twitter

(RNS) — It might have been a scene out of “Little Shop of Horrors”: A group of people of all ages and races sat on the floor of a church, apologizing toa group of plants. According to a tweet by the host of the event, New York’s Union Theological Seminary, however, it was part of a spiritual experience.

“Today in chapel,” the seminary’s official Twitter account revealed, “we confessed to plants. Together, we held our grief, joy, regret, hope, guilt and sorrow in prayer; offering them to the beings who sustain us but whose gift we too often fail to honor.”

In a follow-up tweet, Union added: “Theologies that encourage humans to dominate and master the Earth have played a deplorable role in degrading God’s creation. We must birth new theology, new liturgy to heal and sow, replacing ones that reap and destroy.”

Such a gathering might seem, well, unorthodox. But it’s indicative of the ways in which the Christian left in America has sought with varying degrees of success to reestablish itself as a dominant cultural force capable of going toe-to-toe with Trumpian evangelicalism.

Indeed, Union’s environmental reform liturgy is part of a wider trend: the marriage of the concerns of contemporary social justice activism with an attempt to revive a robust progressive Christianity. 

Since its heyday in mid-20th-century America, progressive Christianity’s force has gradually been eroded as mainline Protestant churches have gone into decline. A third of all Democrats call themselves religiously unaffiliated — compared with just 13% of Republicans. Meanwhile, alternative, more explicitly progressive spiritual practices, such as contemporary witchcraft, are attracting those disillusioned with what they see as the sexism or entrenched racism of Christianity.

For some mainline Protestant churches and institutions, such as the historically progressive Union, the way forward has been to ally with the social justice movement — perhaps the closest thing the American left has to a civil religion.

“We live out the love of God justly by publicly saying #BlackLivesMatter,” wrote the United Church of Christ, in announcing its advocacy for the #BlackLivesMatter movement on its website, adding, “By insisting on the intrinsic worth of all human beings, Jesus models for us how God loves justly, and how his disciples can love publicly in a world of inequality.”

Prominent progressive Christians such as the Rev. William Barber II, a Union faculty member; former Riverside Church senior minister the Rev. Amy Butler; and Lutheran pastor the Rev. Nadia Bolz-Weber have all made issues of sexual and racial injustice integral to their ministry. Last year, Barber, along with another Union-affiliated pastor, the Rev. Liz Theoharis, led an interfaith revival of Martin Luther King Jr.’s 1968 Poor People’s Campaign, advocating for the poor through rallies, protests and teach-ins.

The Rev. William Barber II, left, co-chair of the Poor People’s Campaign: A National Call for Moral Revival, speaks at the event on the National Mall on June 23, 2018. The Rev. Liz Theoharis, co-chair, is at right. RNS photo by Adelle M. Banks

For these progressive Christians, addressing earthly inequality isn’t just necessary to reaching an increasingly secular America; it is part and parcel of the Christian mission. 

While challenging the secular world with their Christianity, progressives also criticize what they see as insufficiently enlightened elements of Christian tradition, no matter how deeply ingrained. Writing on gender and sexuality in her latest book, Bolz-Weber said St. Augustine, the fourth-century author of a strict sexual ethic, “took a dump and the Church encased it in amber.”

When it comes to questions of gender and sexuality, progressive Christianity is often forced to balance values such as those seemingly espoused in its traditional texts (like Augustine) with far more inclusive contemporary principles.

For these progressive Christians, the language of social justice is a way of translating the gospel message of a kingdom of heaven on earth into a contemporary world, but they also are adamant that Christianity must adapt to stay relevant.

Union in particular has led the forefront of this charge. Its Episcopal Divinity School, for example,“intentionally engages disparities in society based on gender, race, class, sexuality and other marginalizing forces,” mandating specific courses in racial and sexual injustice (and Spanish-language liturgy) as part of its curriculum.

As early as 2015, it established a Center for Earth Ethics, devoted to addressing the environmental crisis from a theological perspective. “At the root of global climate change is human greed, and gross and violent power inequities,” Union President Serene Jones said in a statement at the time. “To address this social justice issue, we need wise, inclusive, justice-driven and well-informed leaders.”

For Union’s progressives, a world in which plants, animals and human beings live in harmony is held up as a corrective to a world spoiled by the original sins of structural inequality and conquest. In this view, the same ethos of violence underpinning patriarchy, racism, capitalist exploitation and colonialism also underpins human exploitation of the natural world.
This critique is not restricted to progressive mainliners. In 2014, Pope Francis called the exploitation of the Earth “our sin” and demanded that Christians “convert ourselves to a type of development that knows how to respect creation.”
By contrast, conservative Christians tend to celebrate the idea of dominion expounded in the Old Testament Book of Genesis, in which God gave control over Earth to humans. At a 2012 energy summit, Catholic politician Rick Santorum dismissed concerns about climate change, arguing, “We were put on this Earth as creatures of God to have dominion over the Earth, to use it wisely and steward it wisely, but for our benefit, not for the Earth’s benefit.”
Santorum’s vision and Union’s plant-based confession reveal the degree to which American Christianity has cleaved, with each side allying with their respective political camps. Even as white evangelicalism has moved further and further to the right in the past few years in its embrace of the GOP and Donald Trump, becoming a political entity in its own right, so too is progressive Christianity learning to sing, well, from a similar contemporary hymn sheet.