Donate to RNS

Thousands sign petition in support of five charged in Junipero Serra statue toppling

Five people charged with the toppling of a Junipero Serra statue at a California church in October are scheduled to appear in court this week.

People deface and tear down a statue of Junipero Serra in San Rafael, California, on Oct. 12, 2020. Video screengrab via KTVU

(RNS) — As a court date nears for five people charged with the toppling of a Junipero Serra statue at a California church in October, thousands have signed a petition calling for the Marin County district attorney to drop felony charges filed against them.

The defendants — Melissa Aguilar, Mayorgi Nadieska Delgadillo, Victoria Eva Montano Pena, Moira Van De Walker and Andrew Lester Mendle — are each facing one count of felony vandalism for leveling the statue at Mission San Rafael Arcángel in San Rafael, north of San Francisco, according to a complaint filed Nov. 12 and provided to Religion News Service by the Marin County District Attorney’s Office.

Arraignment is scheduled Friday (Dec. 11). 

The incident occurred during a demonstration on Indigenous People’s Day to protest the colonization of Native Americans, according to The Mercury News. Images show the statue was knocked down and sprayed with red paint.


RELATED: Who is Junipero Serra and why are California protesters toppling statues of the saint?


A change.org petition started by Decolonizers Defense is urging District Attorney Lori Frugoli to drop the charges against the group referred to as the “Indigenous Peoples 5.” More than 5,800 had signed the petition as of Wednesday morning.

“While monuments to racism and violence are being removed by city and state officials, schools, parks and activists across the state, the city of San Rafael is refusing to recognize the harms perpetrated against Indigenous people and has decided to file felony charges against five of the fifty demonstrators,” the petition reads.

San Francisco Archbishop Salvatore J. Cordileone. Photo courtesy of the Archdiocese of San Francisco

Of those five, four are Indigenous women and two were baptized in the Catholic Church, according to the petition.

Meanwhile, San Francisco Archbishop Salvatore J. Cordileone has applauded the charges as a “breakthrough moment for Catholics.”

Cordileone, in a statement on Nov. 13, said the charges will be the first time any of the protesters who have toppled Serra statues across California “will be held accountable for their actions in a court of law.”

In an Oct. 26 letter, Cordileone had asked the district attorney to “press charges to the full extent of the law” and urged they should also be charged with a hate crime.


RELATED: We have a story to tell: Indigenous scholars, activists speak up amid toppling of Serra statues


To Morning Star Gali, a member of the Ajumawi band of Pit River Tribe, it’s unfortunate the church is taking this stance. Taking down the statue was an act of healing, said Gali, who has been advocating for the group.

“This is an opportunity for them to help rectify issues of the past and the violence that the church is responsible,” said Gali, project director for Restoring Justice for Indigenous Peoples.

“For the church to take such a hard stance is extremely disappointing,” Gali added.

While Serra, an 18th-century Franciscan priest and Catholic saint, is credited with spreading the Catholic faith in what is now California, critics say he was part of an imperial conquest that enslaved Native Americans.

Across California this year, protesters have toppled Serra statues in San Francisco, Los Angeles and Sacramento. Some Catholic parishes in Orange, Monterey and Los Angeles counties have removed statues of Serra in fear of potential vandalism.

This public scrutiny of Serra has reemerged in the wake of Black Lives Matter protests denouncing institutional racism and police brutality and led to the toppling of monuments honoring Confederate leaders.

Cordileone and Los Angeles Archbishop José Gomez have issued letters staunchly defending the image and history of Serra and criticizing those who defaced the statues.

These responses have galvanized Indigenous scholars who want the Catholic Church to fully admit to a history of colonialism that led to the loss of culture and land among the Native community.