Why the first Jesuit pope is a big deal

Print More
Cardinal Jorge M. Bergoglio, now Pope Francis, celebrating mass at the XX Exposición del Libro Católico (20th Catholic Book Fair) in Buenos Aires, Argentina.  (2008).

Photo courtesy of Aibdescalzo via Wikimedia Commons

Cardinal Jorge M. Bergoglio, now Pope Francis, celebrating mass at the XX Exposición del Libro Católico (20th Catholic Book Fair) in Buenos Aires, Argentina. (2008).

(RNS) Jesuits are bound by oath not to seek higher office in the Roman Catholic Church, and now one of them has been elected to its highest office: Bishop of Rome, Vicar of Christ, Pontifex Maximus.

Cardinal Jorge M. Bergoglio, now Pope Francis, celebrating mass at the XX Exposición del Libro Católico (20th Catholic Book Fair) in Buenos Aires, Argentina.  (2008)  Photo courtesy Aibdescalzo via Wikimedia Commons (http://bit.ly/10Of6ve)

Photo courtesy of Aibdescalzo via Wikimedia Commons

Cardinal Jorge M. Bergoglio, now Pope Francis, celebrating mass at the XX Exposición del Libro Católico (20th Catholic Book Fair) in Buenos Aires, Argentina. (2008) Photo courtesy Aibdescalzo via Wikimedia Commons (http://bit.ly/10Of6ve)

Pope Francis, the first Jesuit to become pope, not only represents a paradox for the papacy, but also the larger history of the Society of Jesus, as the Jesuits are formally known.

“On the one hand, Jesuits aren’t supposed to be in positions of authority,” said the Rev. Joseph Fessio, a Jesuit and founder of Ignatius Press. “On the other hand, they’re supposed to be obedient to the church.”

The Jesuits have played a key role in the history of the church. For centuries, they have served as its leading missionaries, founded its most prestigious universities and committed themselves to alleviating the deepest poverty.

St. Ignatius Loyola, a Spanish soldier, founded the order in 1540 after being wounded in battle and having a religious conversion during his convalescence. Jesuits are sometimes known as “God’s Marines,” after Loyola’s military history, and their missions worldwide.

Yet despite their prominence — at 18,000 members, they are the church’s largest religious order — Jesuits have had a complicated history with the institutional church and the hierarchy in Rome. With the first Jesuit pope, things just got a bit more complicated.

With their emphasis on missions work and intellectual pursuits, Jesuits often work on the margins of the church, sometimes overstepping boundaries set by Rome. It’s a point of pride among some Jesuits that they frequently challenge authority and seem to have a predisposition for coloring outside the lines.

“Since their founding, Jesuits have consistently offended people … But if there’s a barricade in the street, there’s going to be a Jesuit on both sides of that barricade,” said David Collins, a history professor at Georgetown University.

The left-leaning liberation theology movement that swept across Latin America in the 1970s and 1980s — including Francis’ native Argentina, where he headed the Jesuit order from 1973 to 1979 — is just one example. Bergoglio opposed it; many of his priests openly supported it.

Here in the United States, the New York-based Jesuit magazine America frequently challenges the hierarchy, so much so that one of Pope Benedict XVI’s first acts after his election was to order the removal of the Rev. Thomas Reese as editor.

“This is all new ground,” Reese said Thursday in Rome, where he’s working as an analyst on the papal transition for National Catholic Reporter.

“We never had a Jesuit pope, so I think we are all trying to figure out how this works, and it was a total surprise to everybody: surprise to the Jesuits, surprise to the media, probably a surprise to Pope Francis. This is something we’ll just work out as time goes on.”

Jesuits have also been accused of wielding too much influence, a concern that led Pope Clement XIV  to suppress the order in the 1700s. (Pope Pius VII restored the society in 1814.) The Superior General of the Jesuits is informally known as “the Black Pope” because of the power the position has held in the past.

In the early 1980s, when the Jesuit Superior General was sidelined by a stroke, Pope John Paul II stepped in with his own appointee, rather than allow the Jesuits to elect their own leader.

“That was his right as pope, but it still discouraged many Jesuits at the time, wrote the Rev. James Martin, an editor at America and the author of “The Jesuit Guide to (Almost) Everything,” in a piece for CNN. “With a Jesuit pope, that cloud has been, if not removed, then lifted much higher.”

Patrick Hornbeck, a theology professor at Jesuit-run Fordham University in New York, said Jesuits are accustomed to the tensions.

“Jesuits are on the frontiers and in the heart of the Catholic church,” he said. “And when you’re doing work on the margins, there’s going to be some natural friction with what’s happening in the center.”

Normally, if a Jesuit is appointed a bishop, he must first seek permission from his Jesuit superiors before he can accept the job. So what happens when a Jesuit is tapped to be pope?

“Most people think when the College of Cardinals comes and asks you to take on a job, that’s the voice of God telling you this is your new mission in life,” Reese said. “It’s pretty hard to say no to that.”

Collins said he hopes that new pope will bring some of his Jesuit training and tradition to bear during his papacy.

“Jesuits work hard to cultivate spiritual depth, and pragmatism. We get a glimpse of a little bit of that in (Bergoglio’s) time as bishop. He has a vision of simplicity and connection with the poor and marginalized,” Collins said. “I hope another part of what shapes his papacy is that pragmatic, let’s-get-it-done attitude.”

(Alessandro Speciale contributed to this report from Vatican City)


  • Pingback: Why the first Jesuit pope is a big deal | THINKING PRESBYTERIAN | Scoop.it()

  • Daniel Hoffman

    Some of us were inspired by Liberation Theology. They believed on Basic Christian Communities as a means of alleviating poverty through teamwork and coalition building. It made poor people harder to prey upon and got their leaders killed. There was so much hope before John Pail II. He helped crush it because he failed to distinguish Communism and originary Christianity.

  • Jacqueleen

    Liberal order, liberal pope? I am praying for this Pope and for the faithful remnant.

  • Jacqueleen

    When I hear the term, “Social Justice,” I think of communism/socialism….In today’s world, One world Order/Government/Baning System/Religion….God help us and the church!

  • Diana

    Good article…what it left out is the time one of the popes disbanded them, the occurrence of Teilhard deChardin within the order, and the fact that many Jesuits today have been seduced into the modernist ideology. Their stand on social justice is worldly-oriented and very political. The Jesuit order has had in its ranks many holy,saintly men in the past. I hope our Pope is in their ranks. Fr. Malachi Martin,wherever you are, pray for us.

  • Greetings in Christ
    I urge the New Pope Francis the First to go to Israel and stop the Jerusalem to be divided and given to Palestinians. We are at the Passover/Easter ,does it means anything to world ??????????????.The intention is to give away Judea as well Judea was given to Israel FOR EVER AND EVER.,yet it is in plan to be given to Palestinians.

  • Patrick

    You are exactly right. The Jesuits believe that no one should be rich. They believe a person has a right to be “comfortable” and no more. The Jesuits were/are also big supporters of the Communist Sandinistas in Nicaragua.

  • Daniel Hoffman

    Did you ever hear of the saying, “united we stand; divided we fall.”? The powerful have armies of lawyers, accounts, lobbyists, media personalities, and politicians at their beck and call. They are telling you to go it alone and be the tough cowboy. They are collectivists and they crush anyone who tries to go it alone without remorse. Of course they tell you to stand up for yourself and that unions and community organizers are your enemy. They will laugh in your face when they turn your children into beggars.

  • Patrick

    Sorry to burst your bubble, Reverend, but most of the Jews now living in the Middle East are Sephardic and Ashkenazi Jews who originated in Eastern Europe. They have no original connection to Palestine. Also, the Balfour Declaration, upon which the “nation” of “Israel” was based stipulated a dual state to be shared with the Palestinians. Now the Jews, not only don’t want to abide by the original agreement, but they also want to kick the Palestinians out completely when they are the only people living their that are truly Semitic.

  • Daniel Hoffman

    What do you call a Catholic whose family has lived in the Holy Land for over a thousand years?

    The Jews call him a “Palestinian”.

  • Daniel Hoffman

    Some people think of Jesus when they think of social justice. The theory that God punishes those whom He dislikes by making them poor and and rewards those He loves by making them wealthy gets a lot of clerics paid well. Unfortunately, it is upside down Christianity.

  • Brandon

    Normally I do not learn article on blogs, but I would like
    to say that this write-up very compelled me to take a look at
    and do it! Your writing taste has been amazed me.
    Thanks, very nice post.

  • Pingback: Why the first Jesuit pope is a big deal | Wilmington Faith & Values()

  • Jon Bar

    U’re full of it!

  • Henry

    What we need is God’s Law and then we would see if you are right. God never intended for what you just said.

  • Henry

    Ha. Ha. Good one.

  • rechill

    Sorry to burst YOUR bubble Patrick but DNA tests trace both Sephardim and Ashkenasi Jews to The Levant. It’s called a Reconquista and they should be allowed as much as Spain and The Balkans to take back their lands.


    God is love which means being kind to others.Speak chosen gentle words while upon the land.Help the poor,guide the children.Believe in the common good of man.It starts with love.No knowledge of History will surpass human kindness .We must treat each other with respect and get things done to preserve the Earth.

  • Pingback: Tekopyhyyden huippu: Jesuiitta Paavi ”il Papa” Francis | Uber Uutiset()