Beliefs Culture Ethics Institutions

ANALYSIS: The surprising afterlife of Pope Benedict XVI

Retired Pope Benedict XVI greets Pope Francis at the conclusion of a consistory at which Pope Francis created 19 new cardinals in St. Peter's Basilica at the Vatican Feb. 22. Pope Benedict's presence at the ceremony marked the first time he had joined Pope Francis for a public liturgy. Photo by Paul Haring, courtesy of Catholic News Service

VATICAN CITY (RNS) When Pope Benedict XVI officially left the Vatican in a helicopter a year ago this week (Feb. 28), becoming the first pontiff in 600 years to resign, many in his conservative fan base were aghast, even angry.

Retired Pope Benedict XVI greets Pope Francis at the conclusion of a consistory at which Pope Francis created 19 new cardinals in St. Peter's Basilica at the Vatican Feb. 22. Pope Benedict's presence at the ceremony marked the first time he had joined Pope Francis for a public liturgy. Photo by Paul Haring, courtesy of Catholic News Service

Retired Pope Benedict XVI greets Pope Francis at the conclusion of a consistory at which Pope Francis created 19 new cardinals in St. Peter’s Basilica at the Vatican Feb. 22. Pope Benedict’s presence at the ceremony marked the first time he had joined Pope Francis for a public liturgy. Photo by Paul Haring, courtesy of Catholic News Service

He has betrayed us, said those who thought Benedict’s papacy would be the final triumph of old-school Catholicism. He has undermined the papacy itself, they worried. Lightning even struck the cupola of St. Peter’s Basilica hours after Benedict departed, surely a bad omen.

Rumors that he was suffering from a terminal illness were taken as gospel truth. After all, what else could explain Benedict’s unorthodox decision to abandon the Throne of St. Peter?

Well, it turns out the emeritus pope is doing just fine, thank you. Yes, he is nearly 87, slightly stooped and walking with a cane. But his overall health is pretty good and his spirits — and his wit, say friends who see him — are as strong as ever.

“His memory is fresh and his eyes are very bright and joyous,” the Rev. Stephan Otto Horn, head of a close-knit circle of Benedict’s former theology students, said after meeting Benedict in June.

Indeed, Benedict receives a regular stream of visitors in a retrofitted Vatican monastery where he passes the days praying but also reading, playing the piano, and corresponding with old friends and intellectual foes, like the Swiss theologian Hans Kung.

Despite initially vowing to remain “hidden from the world,” Benedict made a surprise appearance on Saturday at St. Peter’s Basilica as Pope Francis installed his first batch of cardinals — the first time Benedict has appeared at a Vatican liturgy in a year. “When I saw him, I was startled,” said one of the new cardinals, Leopoldo Brenes Solorzano of Nicaragua.

Vatican officials say Benedict is likely to attend the dual canonizations of Pope John Paul II and Pope John XXIII in April. He was seen dedicating a statue with Francis in the Vatican gardens, visiting his older brother in a Rome hospital, and enjoying a piano concert in his honor by Fox News religion correspondent Lauren Green.

Benedict also made headlines last fall when he wrote a lengthy response to an Italian atheist who had critiqued his work, and allowed the letter to be published in a leading newspaper.

All told, it adds up to a gradual, if limited, re-emergence that may augur an unexpected second act for Benedict, though one whose ending is still being written — and maybe rewritten.

The drama is actually not that his greater visibility will renew concerns about diluting Francis’ standing or authority; that fear, often voiced in the days after Benedict stepped down, was a bit of a stretch. Francis himself is clearly not worried, and he periodically consults with his predecessor. “It’s like having a grandfather at home,” as Francis says.

Pope Benedict XVI leaves Christmas Eve Mass in St. Peter's Basilica at the Vatican Dec. 24. RNS photo by Paul Haring/Catholic News Service

Pope Benedict XVI leaves Christmas Eve Mass in St. Peter’s Basilica at the Vatican Dec. 24, 2012. RNS photo by Paul Haring/Catholic News Service

Rather, it is the impact of Benedict’s intellectual legacy that is in play, and how, and whether, it will influence a church undergoing a transformative moment under Francis.

That legacy is embodied in the dozens of pieces that Benedict, formerly known as Joseph Ratzinger, wrote over a remarkable, and controversial, career — first as an expert advising German bishops at the Second Vatican Council in the 1960s, then as a cardinal who served for 23 years as the Vatican’s top doctrinal officer under John Paul; and finally as pope for eight years.

“His works will survive the centuries like those of Augustine and St. Thomas Aquinas,” Cardinal Christoph Schonborn of Vienna, another theology student of Ratzinger’s, said last year.

To advance that cause, Benedict’s writings are currently being compiled and edited into a multivolume set, and some speculate that one day there may be more to add. “I can’t imagine him being alive and not writing,” said the Rev. Joseph Fessio of Ignatius Press, the primary English language publisher of Benedict’s works.

Fessio, also a member of the “Ratzinger Schulerkreis,” or school circle, of former theology students that meets every year to discuss and promote Benedict’s ideas, said he was convinced Benedict would never publish anything while he is alive out of respect for Francis and the papal office. “But I suspect that when he dies there will be some posthumous works,” he said.

At this point, however, the struggle to shape Benedict’s legacy may be out of his hands and part of a larger tug of war over the direction of the current pontificate.

Catholic progressives, who had long seen Ratzinger as a foe of a more open and less conservative church, have highlighted Benedict’s powerful writings on social justice and the environment, noting how much they prefigured and bolster similar statements by Francis. Others lauded him for the radical step of resigning, in part because it served to downsize a papacy that they felt had grown too authoritarian under John Paul and then Benedict.

Conservatives, on the other hand, quickly recovered from the shock of Benedict’s surprising resignation to confront the shock of Francis’ enormous popularity. That popularity, they fear, is rooted in a view of Francis as a harbinger of change and comes at the expense of Benedict and the conservative tradition.

So they are making several counterarguments aimed at elevating Benedict’s reputation while at the same time tempering the acclaim for Francis:

  • Francis, they say, is not the liberal messiah that some believe;
  • The only real difference between Benedict and Francis is a media-generated perception;
  • Benedict is the true reformer because without his pontificate and his decision to retire there would have been no Francis.

“We are all seeing the impact of Pope Francis on the world, not only on the faithful in the church, but on the world; it is a huge impact, and this impact was also facilitated by Pope Benedict in his resignation,” Archbishop Georg Gaenswein, Benedict’s closest aide and a leading promoter of his boss’ legacy, said this month. “He opened up a possibility that until then was not there.”

In this view, Francis is really building Benedict’s church, as one commentator wrote, and Benedict in fact deserved Time magazine’s “Person of the Year” every bit as much as Francis, said another.

So what does Benedict himself make of all the maneuvering?

(RNS) The Vatican and Pope Benedict XVI, seen here at St. Patrick's Cathedral in New York in 2008, have instructed dioceses worldwide to prepare "guidelines" for handling sex abuse by May 2012. Religion News Service file photo by Jin Lee/Staten Island Advance.

Pope Benedict XVI at St. Patrick’s Cathedral in New York in 2008. Religion News Service file photo by Jin Lee/Staten Island Advance.

He is probably rather amused. Those who know him say that his penchant for sarcasm is as sharp as ever, and if he doesn’t agree with everything Francis is doing — Gaenswein himself admitted to some exasperation with the new pope’s populist ways — Benedict has told friends that “theologically he is very much in the same line with Pope Francis.”

Besides, Benedict seems as focused, as he always was, on the larger cultural and spiritual struggle to defend the faith. That’s what an Italian bishop who visited Benedict in early February found, as the retired pope spoke with keen interest about world events and what Benedict saw as “the increasingly virulent attacks” on the church.

“If there is no battle,” Benedict told his visitor, “there is no Christianity.”


About the author

David Gibson

David Gibson is a national reporter for RNS and an award-winning religion journalist, author and filmmaker. He has written several books on Catholic topics. His latest book is on biblical artifacts: "Finding Jesus: Faith. Fact. Forgery," which was also the basis of a popular CNN series.


Click here to post a comment

  • “Conservative fan base” – no bias here, eh.

    God bless Pope Benedict, and may God encourage the writer of this piece to grow up.

  • As an orthodox/conservative Catholic theology teacher who runs in such circles, the alleged “anger” or “aghast” response is a pure media fabrication.

    And the drive to try and create a conflict or “clash of popes” is sensationalist drivel.

    Pope Benedict and Pope Francis are/were both gifts from God to His Church. Amen!

  • God bless pope em Benedictus and pope Francis!
    Yes, I can very well imagine that the pope em is “amused” by the wild speculations around his resignation, his legacy etc. We already know that he will go down to history as a great, great pope.
    I have never met any catholic who expressed “anger” about his resignation a year ago. Everybody instead seem to understand and respect his decision to resign, as a sign of deepest humility and love for the Church.
    Pope em has already in an article recently dismissed any ideas of his resignation having to do with sth else than what the pope em himself has declared, already a year ago, as pure speculations, Conspiracy ideas.
    Pope em Benedict is wonderful. As is his successor pope Francis.
    Pray for them every day!

  • And of course pope em Benedict is absolutely right when he says that there are “increasingly virulent attacks on the Church”. We witness this every day; above all in many countries where Christians are cruelly slaughtered every day but also in the West; in the US and in Europé, which is on the way to “loose its soul”. Still, I trust in God and His plan for us and am convinced that our great popes; JPII, Benedict XVI and Francis, will have a beautiful impact on the World.

  • As far as the Pope Emeritus goes he is doing what he said he wanted to do when he retired and that was to live like a monk and that is what he is doing. He was only at the Consistory on Saturday because it was the feast of the Chair of Peter. I do not believe he is going to the canonization in two months because his older brother George who turned ninety a month ago said he was not going. I believe he knows Benedict better than Vatican Watchers.

  • I MUST admit your article lost me after the words “conservative fanbase.” I don’t like hanging “tags” on anyone–guess I’m just a nonconservative!

  • Perhaps a good way to assess the similarity or difference in outlook of Francis and Benedict is to analyse the sources and references used by Francis in his recent Apostolic exhortation. Of the 211 references some 45 referred to the letters and writings of John Paul II. The next largest number were from the writings of Benedict, followed by Paul VI. The most frequently cited theologian was St Thomas Aquinas. The only ‘recent’ theologians cited were Henri de’Lubac and Romana Guardini. No mention of people like Hans Kung nor any ‘liberation theologians’. The difference between Francis and Benedict is one of personality and style not one of substance.

  • 111. Gloria olivae. Benedict XVI
    112. In psecutione.extrema S.R.E. sedebit. Francis
    113. Petrus Romanus, qui pascet oves in multis tribulationibus: quibus transactis civitas septicollis diruetur, & Iudex tremedus iudicabit populum suum. Finis.