Cardinal Gerhard Mueller, then-bishop of the Regensburg, Germany, looks on during a religious conference at the Vatican on March 11, 2010. Photo courtesy of Reuters/Tony Gentile

Top Vatican cardinal rejects abuse victim's critique, denies opposing Pope Francis

VATICAN CITY (RNS) The Vatican's top doctrinal official, Cardinal Gerhard Mueller, has rejected suggestions from a clergy abuse victim that Pope Francis is facing critical internal resistance from foes of his efforts to overhaul the church's central administration.

Mueller, head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, a key department of the Roman Curia, made his remarks in an interview with an Italian daily on Sunday (March 5) after Irish sex abuse survivor Marie Collins cited opposition from Mueller's office as the main reason for her resignation last week from the pope’s commission to protect minors.

The interview in Corriere Della Sera was published as the pope joined members of the curia on a Lenten spiritual retreat in the town of Ariccia outside Rome.

“I think you should put an end to this cliché’, the idea that there is on the one hand the Pope who wants reform and on the other a group of resistors who would like to block it,” the conservative German cardinal said.

“It is part of our Catholic faith and the work ethos of the Roman Curia to support the Pope's universal mission, entrusted to him by Jesus Christ. "

Yet later in the interview Mueller appeared to admit that the pope’s 2015 proposal for a specific tribunal to judge the culpability of bishops in clerical abuse had not been implemented.

“There was a proposal but after intense discussion between various departments involved in the fight against clerical pedophilia it was decided that we already have the jurisdiction of the bishops’ dicastery (department), the tools and the legal means to address any criminal negligence by bishops,” he said.

“In addition the Holy Father can always entrust a special case to the congregation.”

Collins last week accused the Vatican of “shameful” resistance to fighting clerical sex abuse in the Catholic Church as she quit a key panel set up by Pope Francis.

READ: Irish abuse victim rips Vatican bureaucracy as she quits panel

She said the pope’s decision to create the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors was a “sincere move” but there had been “constant setbacks” from officials within the Vatican.

Marie Collins, a member of the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors, speaks during its briefing at the Holy See press office at the Vatican on May 3, 2014. Photo courtesy of Reuters/Alessandro Bianchi

 This image is available for web and print publication. For questions, contact Sally Morrow.

“There are people in the Vatican who do not want to change or understand the need to change,” Collins told RNS.

“I find it shameful,” Collins said. “The work we want to do is to make children and young adults now and in future safer in the church environment from the horror of abuse.”

Collins said her decision to resign had been provoked by one Vatican office's refusal to comply with a request from the commission, approved by the pope, that all letters sent to the Vatican by abuse survivors receive a response.

But in his interview Mueller said that “personal contact” with victims was best conducted by local pastors.

“This act of pastoral care is a task of the bishops in their own particular churches and the general superiors of religious institutes that are closer,” said Muller. “If there is a decision by the pope or a specific task, there is no resistance.”

(Josephine McKenna covers the Vatican for RNS)


  1. Collins and the media do not acknowledge that the boss (the pope) can order everyone in the curia to do whatever he says. The one sex abuse commission member, Peter Saunders of Britain, who stated, “Of course Pope Francis has established he is part of the problem,” and “The pope could do so much more and he is doing next to nothing,” was booted off the commission a year ago. Saunders also said the commission was “smoke and mirrors” and “a public relations exercise. The protection of our children is much more important than that.”

Leave a Comment