Donate to RNS

For dying congregations, a ‘replant’ can offer new life

As congregations become smaller and smaller, some are being ‘replanted’ by applying the lessons from start-up congregations to older, dying churches.

Pastor Min Lee, right, leads a young group of LA City Baptist Church congregants on a walk through the community to pray for church neighbors. Photo courtesy of LA City Baptist Church

(RNS) — From the time he was a teenager, Min Lee wanted to be a missionary.

Lee, who grew up in a Korean American Christian family, said he gave his life to Jesus during a retreat where a missionary from Costa Rica was the guest speaker — which inspired him to think about missionary work as well.

He studied Spanish and ended up spending six months doing missions in Mexico, along with about two years living in a mostly Muslim neighborhood in Toronto. Lee eventually landed in Los Angeles, not far from where he grew up, doing an internship to become a church planter.

Then he ended up at LA City Baptist Church, a small but historic Hispanic congregation floundering after the death of its longtime pastor. Lee started out as a visitor, then was invited first to lead singing, then a Bible study and then eventually became pastor. When he arrived in 2018, the church was down to about a dozen members, most of them elderly. Today the church has closer to 50 people, from a diverse range of backgrounds.

“I thought God was going to call me to be a missionary but instead he sent me to a multiracial church in LA,” Lee said.

LA City Baptist Church is what’s known as a “replant,” an attempt to restore an older, dying congregation to health using some of the lessons gleaned from startup congregations known as church plants. Replanting often involves adding a new pastor who has been trained in how to do outreach, as well as funding and sometimes an influx of volunteers. The idea is to provide resources and new energy to an old congregation, rather than shutting the church down and starting over.  

LA City Baptist Church worships together outdoors during the pandemic. Photo courtesy of LA City Baptist Church

LA City Baptist Church worships together outdoors during the pandemic. Photo courtesy of LA City Baptist Church

Although not widespread, church replanting is growing in popularity and the approach has been adopted by denominations such as the Southern Baptist Convention, whose North American Mission Board is supporting Lee’s work to replant LA City Baptist. In 2020, NAMB helped fund 50 such replants, according to the latest data available. The agency hopes to work eventually with about 200 replants a year, said Mike Ebert, a spokesman for NAMB.

According to data from the Faith Communities Today 2020 survey, there are lots of churches in the same boat as LA City. The median worship attendance for congregations is 65, down from twice that number in 2000 — leaving many congregations wondering what their future will look like.

For Lee, who is in his mid-30s, the process of replanting has meant a lot of slow but steady work. His biggest task at first was building trust with older congregation members, who came from a different cultural background than he did, and sometimes spoke a different language.

He also had to slowly change the church’s approach to ministry.

“In the beginning, it was really showing that we genuinely care,” he said.

LA City Baptist Church has a vision to inspire young people from various backgrounds to serve their city together, meeting needs and changing lives, said pastor Min Lee. Photo courtesy of LA City Baptist Church

LA City Baptist Church has a vision to inspire young people from various backgrounds to serve their city together, meeting needs and changing lives, said pastor Min Lee. Photo courtesy of LA City Baptist Church


RELATED: Women church planters hope to give Christianity a fresh start


A pastor who replants a congregation needs to be part entrepreneur and part chaplain, said Mark Hallock, pastor of Calvary Church in Englewood, Colorado, and author of “Replant Roadmap,” a guide to the process of rebooting an older church. The pastor needs what he calls “tactical patience” in knowing how to care for people while moving things forward.

Trust and love are the most important factors, he added.

“What we find across the board is that you need a leader who loves people,” Hallock said. “We call it a visionary shepherd, someone who wants to shepherd God’s people and love them well.”

Hallock speaks from experience. When he arrived at Calvary in 2009, the nearly 60-year-old congregation was on its last legs. There were about 30 people in the congregation, and most were worn out, he said. They needed someone who believed in them and someone who could show them a way forward.

With patience, hard work and buy-in from the older members of Calvary, the church turned around and within a few years of Hallock’s arrival, weekend services were drawing about 300 people. The church has gone on to help start 13 new churches and replant 14 older churches.

Among the replants was First Baptist Church of Nampa, Idaho, which was down to 30 people “on a good day” before being replanted, said Butch Schierman, a longtime member. Schierman, an IT professional, had served as interim pastor at First Baptist after the longtime pastor retired.

Things were not going well.

“Whatever we were doing was not working,” he said.

Jessica Snyder, center, believes that a church that teaches the gospel affects lives and changes people. She and her husband, Anders, who are 2021 Annie Armstrong Easter Offering missionaries, have seen that truth play out in Calvary Church Nampa in Idaho. They have seen a dwindling congregation grow to more than 100 people after the church had nearly closed its doors. NAMB photo by Ben Rollins Photography

Jessica Snyder, center, believes that a church that teaches the gospel affects lives and changes people. She and her husband, Anders, who are 2021 Annie Armstrong Easter Offering missionaries, have seen that truth play out in Calvary Church Nampa in Idaho. They have seen a dwindling congregation grow to more than 100 people after the church had nearly closed its doors. NAMB photo by Ben Rollins Photography

Schierman and a handful of other church members approached Calvary about replanting their church. They eventually decided to team up and so far, it’s been a success, he said. The church, now known as Calvary Nampa, remains small, with just over 100 people showing up for services, he said, but the church feels healthy and sustainable.

The process of replanting has its perils. In 2020, a church replant in Minnesota made national headlines after older members felt they were discarded when their church was rebooted. And there are some top-down models of replanting, where a larger church comes in and takes over an older church, rebranding it as a satellite campus.

Hallock prefers an approach that relies on getting buy-in from existing church members.

“This is not a takeover situation,” he said. “This is a situation where we’re coming in and loving those who are there and inviting them to be part of something together that God could do moving forward.”

Along with buy-in, the replanting process requires a willingness to try something new.

At The Table United Methodist Church, which grew out of Central United Church in Sacramento, California, a historic congregation founded in 1850, this meant essentially running two parallel churches at the same time — one for older, more traditional members, and one that could appeal to new people.

By 2009, the church was down to fewer than 50 people, most of them older, with little hope for a long-term future. That year, a pair of new pastors named Linda Dew-Hiersoux and Matthew Smith came to the church to essentially serve as chaplains to the aging congregation, while at the same time starting a new church in the same location, said Smith, co-pastor of The Table.

The Table United Methodist Church in Sacramento, California. Photo courtesy of The Table UMC

The Table United Methodist Church in Sacramento, California. Photo courtesy of The Table UMC

That approach gave the new church time to get off the ground while giving older members a sense of continuity. Eventually, the two churches merged, with some older members staying and others moving to a more traditional congregation nearby.

Community life at The Table is built around a series of small group meetings, known as “Kitchen Tables,” where people meet for an hour and a half every week to talk about their faith and how they are living it out, using questions from John Wesley, the founder of Methodism, who started meetings out by asking, “How is it with your soul?”

Newcomers to the church go through a six-week class called “Growing Your Faith,” which introduces people to the ideas behind the Kitchen Tables and helps them focus on their spiritual journey. Most of the people who come to The Table have often felt out of place at other churches, in part because of their more liberal social values, said Smith, or have grown up outside the church and are looking for some kind of spiritual connection. The largest demographic in the church is young families, which has made meeting together challenging during COVID-19. Before the pandemic, worship services drew just under 300 people each weekend, with about 100 people meeting in small groups.

These days, attendance at services is closer to 150 people each week, with about the same number of people taking part in the Kitchen Tables. Sunday services, which feature a mix of blues, gospel, hip-hop and jazz music, are also streamed online. The small groups take a hybrid approach, meeting most of the time online, with in-person meetings every few weeks. The church is also now starting a spiritual community around an urban micro-farm and bakery called Table Farm & Table Bread.

Smith worries that Methodists — who have been feuding for years over issues of sexuality and LGBT inclusion — have forgotten how to build community and draw people to the faith. Smith is unapologetic about his support for inclusion, but he also believes helping people grow spiritually matters. It’s a lot easier, he said, to be mad at people you disagree with from a distance than to love your neighbors or create an authentic community.

“It turns out that’s a lot harder than just feeling self-righteous about my political opinions,” Smith said.


RELATED: Minnesota Methodists say rebooting churches can be helpful but comes with peril


Donate to Support Independent Journalism!

Donate Now!