He Survived Conversion Therapy. The Supreme Court Just Made It Legal Again

— Tim Schrader Rodriguez spent eight years trying to “pray out the gay.” He modulated his voice. He stopped listening to music with female lead singers. He sat weekly with a therapist who watched him come apart — and said nothing.

Last week, the Supreme Court ruled 8–1 that therapists have a First Amendment right to pursue conversion therapy with their patients, upending a Colorado ban on the practice.

This isn’t history, nor is it a Colorado-only case. Bans that advocates spent years winning in state after state will unravel.

The number of LGBTQ+ youth being engaged in conversion practices nearly doubled in the last year alone — from 10 to 20 percent.

What Tim’s story makes clear is how ordinary this harm looks from the outside. It’s not electroshock. It’s not boot camps. It’s a weekly therapy appointment. It’s a trusted relationship. It’s the promise that if you pray hard enough and want it badly enough, God will change you.

And when it doesn’t work, the program tells you that’s your fault, too.

Amanda Henderson talks with Tim this week about what eight years inside that world actually felt like — and what it means that the one protected space survivors thought they still had is now gone.