RNS Logo
Donate
Support our work
Our top donors
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Faiths
    • All Faiths
    • Christianity
      • All Christianity
      • Protestant
        • All Protestant
        • Black Protestants
        • Evangelical
        • Mainline
      • Catholic
      • Latter-Day Saints
      • Orthodox
    • Judaism
    • Islam
    • Unaffiliated/Atheism
    • Hinduism
    • Buddhism
    • Sikhism
    • Alternative Faiths
    • Other Faiths
  • Science & Tech
  • Arts & Culture
  • Health & Lifestyle
  • World
  • U.S.
  • Saved by the City
  • Coronavirus
  • Donate
  • Home
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Faiths
    • All Faiths
    • Christianity
      • All Christianity
      • Protestant
        • All Protestant
        • Black Protestants
        • Evangelical
        • Mainline
      • Catholic
      • Latter-Day Saints
      • Orthodox
    • Judaism
    • Islam
    • Unaffiliated/Atheism
    • Hinduism
    • Buddhism
    • Sikhism
    • Alternative Faiths
    • Other Faiths
  • Politics
  • Science & Tech
  • Arts & Culture
  • Health & Lifestyle
  • World
  • U.S.
  • People
  • Podcasts
    • All Podcasts
    • Beliefs
  • About
    • About Us
    • Staff
    • RNS Board
    • Advisory Council
  • Careers
  • Contact
  • Press Releases
  • Republication
  • Subscriptions
    • All Subscriptions
    • Photos of the Week Archive
    • RNS Morning Report Archive
  • Image Search
    • Image Search (Standard)
    • Image Search (Free)
  • Membership
    • Log In
    • Your Memberships / Subscriptions
    • Your Payment Information
    • Your Profile
  • Favorites
Donate to RNS
Support our work
Our top donors
Martini Judaism

How blackface became a “thing”

A forgotten aspect of American Jewish history -- and its puzzling implications.

February 6, 2019
By
Jeffrey Salkin
Share
Tweet
Share
Reddit
Flip
Email

Did you ever think that we would experience this sudden explosion of politicians exposed for once having appeared in blackface?

As my kids would say: What is up with this?

First, it was Governor Ralph Northam of Virginia. To quote the New Yorker: “Northam had featured, on his medical-school yearbook page, a photograph of a man in blackface and a man in a Ku Klux Klan hood. Northam immediately apologized for appearing in the photo, but he then changed his story and said that neither person in the photograph was him; he did, however, say that he had once put shoe polish on his face as part of a Michael Jackson costume.”

Then, it was Florida State Rep. Anthony Sabatini. As a teen, he appeared with darkened skin while wearing sunglasses, a New York Yankees cap, a do-rag and gold chains.

And then, just minutes ago, Virginia Attorney General Mark Herring (D) said that he dressed in blackface during college.

Let us bracket, for a moment, the question of whether it is “fair” to hold adults responsible for the stupid things that they did as teenagers. (Judaism’s answer? The age of thirteen is not only bar/bat mitzvah. It is the age when you should know the difference between right and wrong. And, when you should begin to understand the implications of your actions.)

Let us also bracket the question of whether chimney soot on the faces of the characters in the original “Mary Poppins” film constitutes blackface. (My answer? This seems off to me, though sensitivities are so raw that people see bigotry that doesn’t necessarily exist.)

We need to ask, as a society: What was going on in the collective mind that prompted people to think that deliberate, willful appearing in blackface would have been acceptable — at any moment in history, and at any stage of life?

Isn’t this just another form of white supremacy.

Usually.

But, then, there is a rather bizarre chapter in the history of American Jewry — Jews performing in minstrel shows — pretending to be black.

As Eric Goldstein of Emory University describes in The Price of Whiteness: Jews, Race, and American Identity, the tradition of Jews appearing in minstrel shows goes at least as far back as 1898.

It happened in Atlanta, under the auspices of the Hebrew Association. Such “Jewish” minstrel shows occurred in the North as well, as early as 1902. Sometimes, the minstrel shows coincided with Purim.

Goldstein reproduces a photo from 1925. It is a group of Jews at a minstrel show, sponsored by the Atlanta chapter of Hadassah, and held at the Progressive Club, one of Atlanta Jewry’s elite gathering places. The Jews are in black face.

The question is: Why did minstrel shows become a (very minor) Jewish “thing”?

Eric Goldstein might have figured it out.

The caption under the Jews in black face picture says, in part: “They [the Jews] frequently embraced black culture as a temporary escape from the pressures of conformity in white America.”

Hmnn. That gets me thinking.

For decades, there was an interesting and often uneasy relationship between Jews and black culture. Today, we might want to call it cultural appropriation, but it was there.

  •  Al Jolson in black face in “The Jazz Singer.” You know the story. Jakie Rabinowitz, the cantor’s son, leaves his provincial Jewish world, and becomes Jack Robin. It is a double assimilation — changing his name, and “changing” his race. As Goldstein writes: “While Jolson’s blackface scenes employ the racist stereotypes of the day, they also suggest the powerful emotional identification of acculturating Jews with African Americans.”
  •  George Gershwin, who used black musical modes and created an African American story in “Porgy and Bess.” (Did Gershwin base “It Ain’t Necessarily So” on the melody of the Torah blessing, which is a blues riff?)
  • The presence of Jews in blues music, as in the late Mike Bloomfield, Al Kooper, and others.

Apparently, for a time, Jews subtly understood that while the majority of them were “white,” that was not how the gentile white majority viewed them.

Jews, along with southern and eastern Europeans, occupied a racial netherworld — not quite white, and not quite black. Goldstein suggests that this realization might have been part of the minor Jewish interest in blackface.

For their part, blacks sometimes reciprocated the gesture — not identifying urban Jews as “truly” white, which meant that they expected Jews to be more sympathetic to their plight. Which, as history records, they often were.
That being said, the sudden explosion of long-ago blackface appearances remind us that America’s racial problems show no signs of abating. It is hard to imagine that white people appearing in blackface is anything other than racism.

I close with the following story.Judge Jerome Katz (1907-1998) served in West Virginia’s Mercer County Circuit Court for thirty years. He taught himself to play drums, and he formed a group called Katz and His Kittens.

One day, he got a call from the grand wizard of the local Ku Klux Klan. They had scheduled a parade, but the regular drummer was sick. Could Katz fill in?

Katz replied that everyone in town knew that he was Jewish.

“That’s OK,” the grand wizard said. “No one will know who you are. You’ll have a sheet over your head.”

To which Judge Katz replied: “The answer is still ‘no.’ I don’t read sheet music.”

The sad, tragic, maddening truth is: There are still many people in American who are playing “sheet music.”

 

 

Share
Tweet
Share
Reddit
Flip
Email
Posted in
Columns Martini Judaism Opinion
Jeffrey Salkin
Martini Judaism
Most Popular
Flunking Sainthood
Tish Harrison Warren, a rising star in Christian spiritual writing
Stephen Colbert, left, interviews the Rev. James Martin, Feb. 3, 2021, on “A Late Show with Stephen Colbert” on CBS. Video screengrab via CBS
News
On late-night TV and bestseller lists, new books on prayer resonating with readers
Celebrate Recovery co-founder John Baker speaks at Saddleback Church in Lake Forest, California, on Aug. 13, 2013. Photo by Robert Hawkins, courtesy of Saddleback Church
News
Rick Warren pays tribute to Celebrate Recovery co-founder John Baker
Photo by Daniel James/Unsplash/Creative Commons
News
What’s in store for the Equality Act, and why do some religions want a revision?
No guessing who in this 1864 depiction may have been compensated after slavery ended. (Image by API/Gamma-Rapho via Getty Images)
Opinion
There was a time reparations were actually paid out – just not to formerly enslaved people

Related Stories

Martin Gugino is shoved by two Buffalo police officers June 4, 2020, in Buffalo, New York. Video screengrab via WBFO
News
Martin Gugino sues city of Buffalo, mayor and police after fracturing skull
Southern Baptist Convention President J.D. Greear addresses the denomination’s Executive Committee on Feb. 22, 2021, in Nashville, Tennessee. Photo courtesy of Baptist Press
News
SBC President J.D. Greear: ‘God did not call Southern Baptists to save America’
Lessie Carmichael-Dew of Arlington, Va., displays an elegant black straw hat at a “hat tea'' sponsored by the Smithsonian Institution's Anacostia Museum and Center for African American History and Culture in early February. The Baptist woman said her hat's ample width is a symbol of the depth of praise for her many blessings. Photo by Steven Cummings, courtesy Anacostia Museum
News
Can I get an amen? Black Americans’ faith, religious practice detailed in Pew study
Adam Greenway during the annual meeting of the Southern Baptist Convention at the Birmingham-Jefferson Convention Complex on June 12, 2019, in Birmingham, Alabama.  RNS photo by Butch Dill
News
SBC seminary president: Recent race statement not about ‘preserving whiteness’
Opinion
Does anyone ‘own’ the Holocaust? An Orlando controversy inflames the issue
RNS Logo
News
  • Home
  • Faith
  • Politics
  • Science & Tech
  • Arts & Culture
  • Health & Lifestyle
  • World
  • U.S.
  • People
Faiths
  • Christianity
  • Judaism
  • Islam
  • Unaffiliated/Atheism
  • Hinduism
  • Buddhism
  • Sikhism
  • Alternative Faiths
  • Other Faiths
Opinion
  • Columnists
Podcasts
  • Beliefs Podcast
  • Re-Sight Islam
Membership
  • Log In
Everything RNS
  • About
  • RNS Board
  • Advisory Council
  • Staff
  • Careers
  • Donate
  • Press Releases
  • Republication
  • Newsletters
  • Photos of the Week Archive
  • Events
  • Commenting Policy
© Copyright 2020, Religion News Service. All rights reserved. Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy, Privacy Statement and Cookie Notice. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Religion News Service.