Black Jesus version of Michelangelo’s Pietà divides Catholics on race and politics

The conservative Catholic news website Church Militant used the image, which it said ‘profanes the Pieta’ to criticize the head of the agency that posted it, Archbishop Vincenzo Paglia.

VATICAN CITY (RNS) — An interpretation of Michelangelo’s iconic pietà featuring a Black Jesus has unexpectedly caused a debate about Black Lives Matter, the sanctity of art and the evangelization of Africa after the Pontifical Academy of Life, an official Vatican think tank, tweeted out a photo of the reimagined statue last Saturday (Sept. 12). 

The tweet, posted by the academy with the caption, “An image that is worth a speech,” was liked more than 1,000 times and received numerous retweets, with many commenters praising its message against racism. But others on Twitter criticized the photo for politicizing the figure of Jesus.

“Jesus died for all, and this is racist to say the least,” wrote Philip Murrell, who calls himself a conservative and a Roman Catholic in his bio. He said the image was posted “to appease marxist communists and the arsonist terrorist (Black Lives Matter).”

The conservative Catholic news website Church Militant used the image, which it said “profanes the Pieta” to criticize the head of the academy, Archbishop Vincenzo Paglia, saying the agency has been in a “downward spiral” since Pope Francis tapped Paglia to lead it in 2016.

In an email to Religion News Service, Archbishop Paglia explained that the image the academy issued was inspired by the work of Italian sculptor Fabio Viale, whose version of Michelangelo’s pietà, which is in St. Peter’s Basilica in the Vatican, was exhibited in 2015 in Milan at the height of Europe’s immigration crisis. His statue, called “Lucky Ehi,” portrayed a 22-year-old Nigerian who fled his country to avoid persecution due to his Christian faith.

RELATED: Vatican prelate calls fences around White House ‘unacceptable’ at vigil for George Floyd

At the time, the artwork was praised for its support of immigrants and condemnation of the ongoing persecution of Christians all over the world.

The archbishops said that while the post didn’t refer to any specific case of racism, “If there is an reference, it’s to every unfair discrimination due to the color of one’s skin,” he said.

But the post clearly resonated with the Black Lives Matter protests that followed the death of George Floyd, a black man who died in police custody in Minneapolis, Minnesota, May 25. It wouldn’t be the first time the Vatican expressed a position against racism and prejudice in the aftermath of Floyd’s death. On June 3, Pope Francis decried “the sin of racism,” and five days later high-ranking Vatican prelates, including Paglia, took part in a vigil Mass for Floyd, organized by the Catholic St. Egidio organization.

RELATED: Pope Francis condemns ‘sin of racism’ while promoting nonviolence as protests mount in US

The post also appeared the day after the funeral service for Monteiro Duarte, a 21-year-old immigrant from Cape Verde who was beaten to death Sept. 5 by five racist and neofascist men in Italy.

“I realize that in a different context it was possible to interpret the image in relation to current social and political battles,” Paglia said.

Answering those who said that it misrepresented the historical Jesus, Paglia said Christians can’t “pretend that the real body of Christ, his human flesh, like Mary’s, are exactly the same as the white of the marble from Carrara,” referring to the quarry where Michaelangelo is likely to have sourced his marble.

“The speed of communication has led to a misunderstanding,” Paglia said.