• Farooq

    what is this nonsense? A true Muslim would not write an article praising a ritually impure animal like the dog. This is the work of an Uncle Tom Muslim who is trying to ingratiate himself to Western standards of loving Dogs, rather than avoiding them as taught to us by our beloved Shaykhs and Teachers. Wake up Br. Omid! Stop trying to please the Western Zionists.

  • Jonathan

    Dear Farooq, are dogs loved by westerners because they are westerners? Dogs are a “symbol” of impurity in Islam. That is, an impurity that is in humans. Humans that bark like dogs at each others, or make people afraid of being bit, that is the true impurity dogs “symbolize.” The Prophet (SAW) says in a Hadith that the man who descends to the level of an animal becomes worse than an animal. Dogs are a creation of God and they manifest in their own way the Mercy of God. And a dog who is a dog is a good creature. But a human that barks angrily, threatens, bites (or backbites) like a dog, is worse than a dog. And that is the impurity which Islam commands us to stay away from. It is a reminder of the dog-like traits we carry in our heart.

  • Pingback: Learning from dogs - Christian Forums()

  • Pingback: The faith of dogs – Religion News Service | Dogs Deals Today()

  • Pingback: The faith of dogs – Religion News Service | Ez Dogs Blog()

  • Pingback: The faith of dogs – Religion News Service | Dogs Today Shop()

  • Pingback: The faith of dogs – Religion News Service | Ez Dogs Online()

  • Peter

    Professor Safi gives us hope that Islam can produce a more reasoned, rational and compassionate approach to treatment of animals. But Farooq in the comments section reminds us of what happens when some Muslims take a narrow and shallow, literalist approach to the Hadith accounts, which are full of anti-dog rhetoric. It’s time to revise the Hadith collections, guys.

  • Peter

    Professor Safi gives us hope that Islam can produce a reasoned and compassionate approach to dogs (which are among God’s creatures). But Farooq in the Comments section demonstrates the result when some Muslims take a narrow and shallow, literalist approach to the Hadith accounts, which are full of anti-dog rhetoric (e.g. consider the bizarre comments about dogs in Bukhari 4.3322ff where we are told, for example, that angels don’t enter houses which contain a dog or a picture!!). It’s time to revise the Hadith collections, guys, or perhaps sideline them in shaping an Islam for the 21st century.

  • Pingback: The faith of dogs – Religion News Service | dog1dog2()

  • Zainab Raza

    Very well said. Look around the world, how humans are beheading each other. Compare to these type of humans every animal is much better. Specially Dogs are gifted creation of God with love and faith.

  • Nuriddin

    Brother Farooq, you are not perceiving with depth what Omid Safi is saying. If mercy is one of Allah’s qualities, and a dog manifests mercy, than a dog is manifesting an aspect of Allah. There is nothing wrong with this. What makes humans better than animals is capacity. If a human being does not use their capacity for mercy or compassion, it is like they had no capacity at all. So under certain circumstances a dog might display more of God’s qualities than a human being. Hopefully we will come out ahead in this race.

  • Dawud

    Salaam bro Farooq,

    A “real” Muslim would know the difference between ritually impure(najis) and evil. Dogs are not evil. He would also know the ahadith that praise sinful people for showing kindnesses to animals, including dogs, and the Mercy Allah shows them for the mercy they showed for animals. There is one specifically about a prostitute giving water to a thirsty stray dog and our beloved Rasulullah(sal) telling his companions(ra) that she would recieve mercy and forgiveness from God for that act.

    Before you attempt to reprimand someone, make sure you aren’t deficient in knowledge.

  • Dawud

    Here’s a nice primer for you akhi.

    http://islam.about.com/od/islamsays/a/animalwelfare.htm

  • Pingback: SuperStar Pets Services Las Vegas: The Faith Of Dogs” « Superstar Pet Services()

  • Pingback: Loyal dog regularly attends Mass even after owner passes away | God Discussion()

  • Pingback: Returning | LAUREN LIVINGSTON()

  • I actually tend to agree with every little thing that
    is written throughout “The faith of dogs | What Would Muhammad Do?
    ”. Thanks a lot for all the information.I appreciate it-Sherrill