Victor Stenger, atheism’s ‘fifth horseman,’ is dead

Print More
Victor J. Stenger, a physicist and prolific writer on atheism who wrote the 2007 New York Times bestseller “God: The Failed Hypothesis,” has died at the age of 79.

Photo courtesy of Vicstenger - Own work. Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 via Wikimedia Commons

Victor J. Stenger, a physicist and prolific writer on atheism who wrote the 2007 New York Times bestseller “God: The Failed Hypothesis,” has died at the age of 79.

Active RNS subscribers and members can view this content by logging-in here.

(RNS) Victor Stenger, the scientist and atheist who famously said "Science flies you to the moon. Religion flies you into buildings," has died.

  • “he’d give me more to think about in one hour than seven hours of anything else I could possibly do,”

    That is a great compliment. He was a modern Socrates who had the added benefit of modern science to support him.
    And he has inspired millions to think more clearly about the price of the primitive, dangerous idea of ‘faith’.

  • Doc Anthony

    And NOW, after all that hard work, all those atheist writings, all those atheist speaking engagements, all those atheist one-liner T-shirts…

    …Dr. Victor Stenger is no longer an atheist. (Hebrews 9:27)

  • @Doc,

    So god waits to give his most convincing message
    of his existence after one has lost the ability to do anything about it?

    If one’s free will and Faith are so important to god, why does God discard them when you are dead?

  • Frank

    And now he is crying “why didn’t I believe in God? What a fool I was!”

  • J.C. Samuelson

    A man dies and you can come up with nothing more insightful than baseless fearmongering? Says a lot about you, Doc.

  • Frank, he’s saying what you will be saying:

    “Oh, God! You were Zeus all along!”

  • J.C. Samuelson

    You and Doc are cut from the same cloth, I see. Assuming you aren’t just a troll, and that you’d consider Dr. Stenger “wicked” because of his beliefs, maybe the both of you ought to read Ezekiel 18:23.

  • May God have mercy on his soul.

    “Viva Cristo Rey!!”

  • Frank

    Thank you for the compliment. Doc is on of the only voices of reason here.

  • Lles Nats

    “Thr atheist community is mourning..” FALSE!

    Atheists are all knowing, all seeing. So one could assume they saw his death coming. Thus they would be prepared, and have no need for mourning as that activity is needless and counterproductive.

  • Lles Nats

    You’ll get over it.

    Assuming u r an atheist, logic is your tool to enlightenment. So embrace it. Doc is right. He is no longer an atheist, a man, or anything he could be traditionally labeled or categorized with in the living world.

    It might just mean Doc’s power of perception exceeds your own.

  • Shawnie5

    Perhaps not. After seeing a lot of people and things come and go, I believe that many, if not most, scoffers would willingly walk into eternal death rather than yield lordship to any god other than Self.

  • Frank

    I tend to think when faced with the power of God, atheists crumble.

  • @Shawnie:

    “….rather than yield lordship to any god other than Self.”

    1. Sure I would.
    2. Show me how to contact the god.
    3. Show me what the god will give me in return.
    4. May I ask the god some questions?
    5. Which Holy texts are the true ones? There are 78 religions with holy texts.

  • Dear Dave

    From Dr Victor’s own quote: “…and now threatens our very existence.”

    Seriously? One must be very careful with such aggressive, arrogant statements. Where’s the scientific evidence for that? Since when has any religion threatened the world’s existence?

    I thought it was science’s nuclear & chemical weapons that threatened (and threatens) our existence?

  • rob

    Amen to that.

    .its his own fault ..God was patient with him.

  • rob

    pretending there is no God is ultimate foolishness.

    There was a news story about a white lady in Georgia who pretended there was not a black cop telling her to open her car window and giving him her license ..he kept asking her
    and asking her she kept pretending he was not there … she did not last long when he opened her window with bullets.

    .The point of thIs story is pretend games can turn out deadly for the pretender..

  • rob

    a max a real disbeliever that there is a God does not believe after death a fellow could say any thing.

    your just at war with god. as in said . unless you can prove your a total fool we wont believe your any thing but very angry at God for some reason.. that you wont tell us..

  • rob

    it says to me –Doc does not want you to end up where he is… I think that’s kind..

  • rob

    Doc and I may have many similar beliefs yet I would not assume we have every belief the same ..i will read that suggested verse in context. why not explain why you want us to read it ? were not happy if the fellows confessions were true about his beliefs where he is now..

  • rob

    just read the verses..

    God does want every one to come to faith in Jesus he is patient
    with us all ..

  • rob

    a max you don’t mean it yet i will give you what you ask any way..

    there is only one God that was God enough to win heaven for you all by himself.. all the other gods just show you what they think is the way ..Jesus he won your way.. its a no brainer which one is more God than the false ones ..

    got questions get Gods biblical answer’s ..

    the more you click on a topic the more there is..

  • @Dear Dave,

    Religion “… now threatens our very existence.”

    He is correct. Religion is the danger in the world.

    “We will conquer all people of the world and force the choice; believe or die in the Prophet (PBUH), Inshallah”
    – Abu Bakr Al-Baghdadi (leader of ISIS)

    He is talking to you.
    As Osama Bin Laden did and others before him.

    Only when religion is abandoned for the folly it is will the armies fold.

  • Fran

    The threat of nuclear destruction is out there from the world’s governments, but thankfully God will never allow that to occur to our home, earth, nor to the human family. God even promises to bring to ruin those ruining the earth, which includes man’s corrupt political systems (Revelation 11:17,18; Daniel 2:44).

  • Okay, I wasn’t going to write anything initially, but I just had to. To the above comments, by what appear to be from “religious” people: making comments about Dr. Stenger’s death and what happens to him in the afterlife is Not Appropriate Here. I am a Christian and I think it is best to let people reminisce over him if they want to, even you disagree. Nobody’s mind and heart will be convinced of the death & Resurrection of Jesus Christ in the comments section of a “tribute”. Please back off for now and show love and respect.

  • Pingback: September 4, 2014 - Science and Religion Today()

  • Otto

    That may be the dumbest thing ever written. Omniscience and prophesy are on the religion side of the aisle. Maybe you should read one of Dr. Stenger’s books and see if some of your irrational thinking can be corrected.

  • Jim

    Spot on.
    Here’s an old saying you may enjoy: An atheist in his casket is someone all dressed up with no place to go. That will be me one of these days.

  • @Fran,

    Your lack of knowledge about science is a blazing.
    It is so immoral to dismiss what you are promoting.


    A nuclear war will end all life on earth
    Perhaps even bacteria and viruses. It would not happen as in the movies with a big drama – but in the blink of an eye.

    You would hear on the news that some rockets had been launched
    and that would be the end of everybody in about 5 minutes.

    Not just the bad guys. There will be nothing else alive – evolution of life ends.

    The seas would be dead and rotting, filling the atmosphere
    with methane and unbreathable toxins for millions of years.

    Land would be large swaths of toxic sandy windblown deserts. No plants.
    Even the sky would look different for millions of years.
    The oxygen would be depleted from the nuclear fires.

    The air would be unbreathable for millions of years.
    Plutonium is the most dangerous element in science and it would be thrown into every corner of the world in a nuclear exchange – a world coated in plutonium would be dead for billions of years.

    Earth is halfway through its lifespan.
    It has about 6 billion years left before the sun explodes.

    But after an all-out nuclear exchange
    There would probably not be enough time left for earth to evolve intelligent life again – and no record of our civilization would exist for those creatures (they would not be people) to understand what lived before or how we destroyed it all.

    The nuclear fallout would render every place on earth radioactive for millions of years – nothing could survive the radioactivity.
    The food chain would be broken forever.

    Except for a few footsteps on the moon, there would be no record of humanity and nobody to care.

    That is something to think about.

    Isn’t it at least reasonable – given all the thousands of religions in the world – to consider that any ABSOLUTE FAITH is too dangerous to pursue?

    If a god exists
    do you really think he would require
    such devastation such as this which would happen
    in the blink of an eye?

    For one human species to ‘worship’ him in death?
    These primitive notions make no sense.


    “I died for you” – JESUS
    And now we will all die for JESUS? or Allah? or Yahweh? or Ganesha?

    Come to your senses.

  • I keep giving you a chance to show me god
    and you keep showing me links to nothing better than an argument for leprechauns!

    I simply cannot fathom how you believe this gibberish.
    Can you make a coherent argument
    about the SOLEMN LIFE CHOICE OF FAITH IN JESUS which you have committed yourself to?
    OR NOT?

  • @rob,

    Your silly little racist story has nothing to do with ‘god’.
    It involves a physical manifestation of a real policeman tapping on the window.

    God – everyone keeps telling me – is not a physical manifestation.
    So you are back to square one.

    Where is this god of whom it is so foolish to NOT believe in?
    And tell me how you know there is only one god and not 20 or 50 or 2000.

    How did you discern its name if it didn’t manifest itself physically at least enough to make a sound and interact with your physical body?

    Or – are you just believing this nonsense because your grandmother told you to!?

  • Marius Potgieter

    Dear Atheist Max, you are certainly the most consistent blogger on any of the hundreds of Christian websites, on many different continents … don’t you have a job? Don’t you have a private life or friends? It seems to me that you have absolutely nothing to do, other than your incessant display of total ignorance of the Christian faith. Are you perhaps searching for something? I ask this, because you spend your entire life behind a PC screen.
    Just like Dawkins and all of his other ‘lapdogs’, you have not said a single original thing here either!

  • @Marius Potgieter,

    “Are you perhaps searching for something?”

    Yes. Many things:

    1. A damper on religion’s influence on politics.
    2. Promotion of Atheism.
    3. An increase in Secularism.
    4. News about the decline in religious orders.
    5. Better arguments to help the faithful abandon religion.
    6. Opportunities to defend Atheism.
    7. Opportunities to challenge claims about Jesus, Yahweh and Allah in particular.
    8. Opportunities to challenge death cults like Christianity.
    9. News about efforts to find justice for victims of pedophile priests.
    10. News about efforts to increase the Separation of Church and State.
    11. Opportunities to defend the Establishment Clause.
    12. Promotion of positive Atheism.

    How much more do you need?

    Religion: A set of immoral, divisive beliefs
    which cannot be treated as 100% true
    or the result would be mass murder:

    “Slay Them” (Surah) Q’uran
    “Execute them in front of me” – Jesus (Luke 19:27, Parable of the Minas)
    “Kill unbelievers” – Yahweh (Torah)

    If we already know any religion cannot be 100% true
    we should agree to abandon it more quickly.

  • RGD

    Atheist Max – you state “Only when religion is abandoned for the folly it is will the armies fold.” perhaps you need a history lesson – KArl Marx – probably one of the patron saints of atheistic came up with a system called communism which was devoid of God – that really put an end of armed conflict didn’t it. And that atheist Stalin – he is a real atheist hero as well. Or what about Saint Mao – he sure was a kind man who also put an end to any sort of armed hostility didn’t he. And what about that guy in North Korea – he is an up and coming Atheist saint. So before you get your panties in a wad about atrocities committed in the name of religion – perhaps you might want to look at some done in the name of the atheist state to – if you want to be objective – but God (or someone) forbid that you be objective and think.

  • opheliart

    Max, you write to Dave …

    @Dear Dave,

    Religion “… now threatens our very existence.”

    He is correct. Religion is the danger in the world.

    “We will conquer all people of the world and force the choice; believe or die in the Prophet (PBUH), Inshallah”
    – Abu Bakr Al-Baghdadi (leader of ISIS)

    He is talking to you.
    As Osama Bin Laden did and others before him.

    Only when religion is abandoned for the folly it is will the armies fold.

    You mention Osama bin Laden, so I thought I would share a dream I had three days after his death. He was laid out on a stone slab in the basement of a building that was being used as a tourist attraction—people were coming to see his dead body. I found myself in the upstairs and had no intentions of visiting the body, but I was shown that I was to go down and see it. Reluctantly, I went down a set of stone steps to the basement where I saw a figure dressed in a lower garment covering his privates and keffiyeh (of some sort), but that was it. There were people in line walking up to the figure, and these were not of any particular religious for he was “the tourist attraction.” I went to the stone slab on his right side and walked around the figure moving head to left side then back to where I started. When I reached this spot, and while I was looking down at his ashen face, and what appeared to be marked skin from battle (although no blood), he opened his eyes. When he SAW ME, he immediately got up to go after me. It was scary as hell—that look he gave, as if he saw something and wanted to capture or destroy it. I raced up the stone steps and looked back only once to see him staggering because his knees were buckling. He had no lower strength. That was the last I saw of him, but I entered another place and …
    There was more to the dream but this is all I will share. Pretty weird, huh?

    You also write …

    @Marius Potgieter,

    “Are you perhaps searching for something?”

    Yes. Many things:

    1. A damper on religion’s influence on politics.

    Max, this is just part of your post to Marius (interesting name). You have every right to weigh in on the advent of religious underpinning, regardless of what you claim to be, or wish yourself to be know as. Religion of specific dogma and doctrine is profuse in politics, and I find it disheartening that so many claiming the Christ abuse this to influence and gain votes. It was not so long ago that Protestants and Roman Catholics battled, and history has demonstrated the ills of religion RULING the masses. Too many deny this obvious part of historical evidence. They think in terms of a short life span—their own, without REALIZING the greater scope in Prophesy. The truth, however, can be gleaned in the Book of Revelation, Chapter 11, where the Angel speaks to John of the Holy City (Temple) … “outside the temple is given to the Gentiles to tread the Holy City underfoot for forty-two months.”
    Man either did not read this and come into some understanding of it, or he thinks his religious rules and its leadership are this Holy City, having no knowledge of what are months in God Time.

    As I have shared before, the Church spoken of in Matthew is not “the church” of religious venue and practice that you see in the World, for it is OF the World … one has only to watch it play out on the political stage. Now, do not call it CHURCH and STATE; call it RELIGION WITHIN STATE, as this is now more to the norm, unfortunately.

    Seems those claiming Spiritual Advocate on Truth have forgotten this:

    And be not conformed to this world: but be ye transformed by the renewing of your mind, that ye may prove what is that good, and acceptable, and perfect, will of God. Roman 12.2

    Peace AND Love

  • Larry

    The fact that you could call Marx, Kim and Mao “Saints of Communism” shows they had more in common with religious belief and methods than atheism. They rejected organized religion to create their own versions of it. Same irrational nonsense, different flavor.

    It takes a certain level of ignorance (and dishonesty) to keep trotting out Communists as examples of atheism. It doesn’t matter how many times you guys get corrected on this, it gets repeated ad nauseum. Religious belief avoids honest discussion whenever possible in favor of repeating nonsense to a new audience who may not have heard it the first time.

  • Larry

    Something about being a Christian which gives people the idea that one has a duty to say vile, dishonest, malicious things about the beliefs of a dead person because his ideas differed from your own.

    The comments from some of the usual posters here lack any sense of propriety or respect which would be accorded to the deceased. But that is consistent with the attitude that many Christians have that any ideas but their own must be degraded, insulted and attacked.

  • Pingback: Saturday Ramblings: Sentences Edition — September 6, 2014 |

  • This may be a shock to many Christians…but here is a terrific sermon (by a Christian pastor) who says he believes that he cannot believe:

    Give it 3 min. to get past some religious language.

  • RGD

    So anyone who in the NAME of Christianity (or perhaps falsely claiming to be Christian) does evil and vile things is vilified – but anyone claiming to be atheist who does vile and terrible things in the name of atheism gets a pass – wow – how convenient.

  • Larry

    Nice try, but what makes you the arbiter of what is “truly Christian” and what isn’t? It appears the vast majority of Christians ignore such distinctions except when they want to weasel away from their own history and actions.

  • crizzo

    Let me explain the dichotomy of yeilding to Jesus to be your Lord, giving up leadership of you own life: ” He who has found his life will lose it, and he who has lost his life for My sake will find it.” – Jesus, Matthew, 10:39 … I’ve followed for 50 years now, married to my best friend, 41 years, both virgins when we met! God does what He promised! I’ve really ‘found’ my Lifein Him it is good in Him.

  • crizzo

    How can there be no sense of loss of one of your champions? That is heartless. Oh yes, heartlessness is a logical outcome if there is no God to emulate. I get it!

  • Steve Willy

    God gave him convincing messages all his life. He and others like him chose to ignore those messages in the of worshipping their own intellects.

  • Steve Willy

    The lack of scientific rigor in your analysis is ‘a blazing.’ Your assumptions fail to account for yeilds, targets, type of materials used (uraniam, plutonium, cobalt?). You seem to leap to the conclusion that a single suit case nuke detonated by a jihadist would summarily end all life on earth. To the extend you worship Science, you have committed a heresy. Oh, by the way, the atheistic Soviet Union came far closer to nuking the world, and detonated far more megatons in testing, than any ‘theocracy’ or religiously motivated terrorist.

  • Steve, that is nonsense.
    Otherwise, why are you ignoring the pleadings of Zeus?

  • Nonsense.

    Credulous populations believing in the Czar God is not ATHEISM.
    Lysenko’s miracles are not Atheism.

    As for Armageddon – it is an entirely religious work of garbage. We need to abandon the entirety of religious nonsense.
    Humanity will not survive religion and its absolutist claims.

  • nobody ever killed people because they refused to declare their atheism!

  • “bring to me those enemies of mine…execute them in front of me.” – JESUS (Luke 19:27)

  • Steve Willy

    Where are the Five Ways for the existence of Zeus? Is Zeus’ existence supported by the modal ontological argument? Zeus was though of as a really powerful guy, a thing in the universe among many, not the metaphysical predicate for existence itself – Yahweh, i.e. “I am,” i.e. pure acting being. Also, no one ever considered Zeus to be the font of morality. Zeus never said ‘be ye holy for I am holy.’ The difference is in kind, not degree. It is a classic equivocation falacy – to pretend that the word ‘gods’ (lower case plural) is the same as God (upper case singular). You know they don’t mean the same thing and you should be ashamed.

  • Steve Willy

    Thanks for this steaming pile of regurgitated, pseudo-intellectual, GNU-Reditt inspired blather, you Hitchens-Dawkins parroting, basement dwelling, faux-analytical, neck bearded assclown!

  • Steve Willy

    It takes a pretty thick neck beard to believe that steaming pile of regurgitated, pseudo-intellectual blather. How exactly has this ever been ‘corrected’ by atheists. Your position is a bit like trying to dissasociate the Holocaust from National Socialism. The fact of the matter is that every society that has shed religion the way you want us to has turned genocidal. Christopher Hitchens contrived the specious response that, well, those regimes really were inherently religious. How this can be determined us anyone’s guess but Hitchens was far more interested in hyperbole than fact, and you seem to have mindlessly internalized his lies

  • Steve Willy

    It was called the ussr neck beard boy, try reading a book and follow the evidence where it leads….