Three years on, Pope Francis leaves conservatives feeling marginalized

Print More
Pope Francis gestures as he speaks during his weekly general audience in St. Peter's Square at the Vatican, on Feb. 24, 2016. Photo courtesy of REUTERS/Max Rossi
*Editors: This photo may only be republished with RNS-POPE-EMPLOYERS, originally transmitted on May 19, 2016.

Pope Francis gestures as he speaks during his weekly general audience in St. Peter's Square at the Vatican, on Feb. 24, 2016. Photo courtesy of REUTERS/Max Rossi *Editors: This photo may only be republished with RNS-POPE-EMPLOYERS, originally transmitted on May 19, 2016.

VATICAN CITY (Reuters) Three years after the election of Pope Francis, Roman Catholic conservatives are growing increasingly worried that he is quietly unraveling the legacy of his predecessors.

Francis’ popularity with most Catholics, and legions of non-Catholics, has given him the image of a grandfatherly parish priest who understands how difficult it sometimes is to follow Church teachings, particularly those on sexual morality.

Conservatives worry that behind the gentle facade lies a dangerous reformer who is diluting Catholic teaching on moral issues like homosexuality and divorce while focusing on social problems such as climate change and economic inequality.

Interviews with four Vatican officials, including two cardinals and an archbishop, as well as theologians and commentators, highlighted conservative fears that Francis’ words and deeds may eventually rupture the 1.2 billion member Church.

Chatter on conservative blogs regularly accuses the Argentine pontiff of spreading doctrinal confusion and isolating those who see themselves as guardians of the faith.

“Going to bed. Wake me up when this pontificate is over,” Damien Thompson, associate editor of the British weekly “The Spectator” and a conservative Catholic commentator tweeted last month. Thompson was among conservatives stung by a freewheeling news conference Francis gave on a flight home from Mexico.

In it, he stirred up the U.S. presidential debate by criticizing Republican candidate Donald Trump’s immigration stance and made comments that were interpreted as an opening to use contraceptives to stop the spread of the Zika virus.

They were the latest in a line of unscripted utterances that have left many conservatives feeling nostalgic for the days of Francis’s two predecessors, Benedict and John Paul, who regularly thundered against contraception, homosexuality and abortion.

“Every time this happens I wonder if he realizes how much confusion he is causing,” said a conservative Rome-based cardinal who took part in the conclave that elected Francis three years ago and spoke on the condition of anonymity. He would not say if he voted for Francis because participants in conclaves are sworn to secrecy.

The pope and the pews

Another senior official, an archbishop in an important Vatican ministry, said: “These comments alarm not only tradition-minded priests but even liberal priests who have complained to me that people are challenging them on issues that are very straight-forward, saying ‘the pope would let me do this’ why don’t you?'”

Francis first shocked conservatives just months after his election on March 13, 2013, when he said “Who am I to judge?” about Catholic homosexuals who were at least trying to live by Church rules that they should be chaste.

He caused further upset when he changed Church rules to allow women to take part in a male-only Lenten service, ruled out any campaigns to convert Jews and approved a “common prayer” with Lutherans for joint commemorations for next year’s 500th anniversary of the start of the Protestant Reformation.

RELATED STORY: Who is Pope Francis? Insights on the remarkable life of a historic pontiff

An important crossroads in the conservative-progressive showdown is looming and might come as early as mid-March. It could reveal how far this politically astute pontiff wants to transform his Church.

Francis is due to issue a document called an Apostolic Exhortation after two years of debate and two major meetings of bishops to discuss the family — the Vatican’s way of referring to its policies concerning sex.

The exercise, which began with an unprecedented poll of Catholics around the world, boiled down in the end to one hot-button issue – whether divorced Catholics who remarry outside the Church can receive communion at the central rite of Mass.

Conservatives say any change would undermine the principle of the indissolubility of marriage that Jesus established.

At the end of the synod last year, Francis excoriated immovable Church leaders who he said “bury their heads in the sand” and hide behind rigid doctrine while families suffer.

The gathering’s final document spoke of a so-called “internal forum” in which a priest or a bishop may work with a Catholic who has divorced and remarried to decide privately and on a case-by-case basis if he or she can be fully re-integrated.

That crack in the doctrinal door annoyed many conservatives, who fear Francis’ upcoming document may open the flood gates.

Whose church is it anyway?

It is difficult to quantify Catholic conservatives. Liberals say they are a minority and reject conservative assertions that they are the real “base” of the Church.

“The overwhelming majority of Catholics understand what the pope wants to do, and that is to reach out to everyone,” said another cardinal close to Francis.

Regardless of what their actual numbers might be, conservatives have big megaphones in social media.

“It really has gotten more shrill and intense since Francis took over because he seems to get only positive feedback from the mainstream media. Therefore in the strange logic of (conservative) groups, he is someone who is immediately suspect if only for that,” said the Catholic blogger Arthur Rosman.

RELATED STORY: 7 top issues Pope Francis has staked out for his papacy

One of the leading conservative standard bearers, Ross Douthat, the Catholic author and New York Times op-ed columnist, has expressed deep worry about the long-term repercussions of the issue of communion for the divorced and remarried.

“It may be that this conflict has only just begun,” Douthat said in a lecture to American conservatives in January. “And it may be that as with previous conflicts in church history, it will eventually be serious enough to end in real schism, a permanent parting of the ways.”

Previous rupture

The last internal rupture in the Church was in 1988 when French Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre consecrated bishops without Vatican approval in order to guarantee succession in his ultra-traditionalist group, the Society of St. Pius X (SSPX).

The SSPX rejects the modernizing reforms of the 1962-1965 Second Vatican Council, including the historic opening to dialog with other religions. While it remains a small group, its dissent continues to undermine papal authority.

The conservative standard bearer in Rome is Cardinal Raymond Leo Burke, a 67-year-old American who in 2014 told an interviewer that the Church under Francis was like “a ship without a rudder.”

Francis was not pleased. That same year, he removed Burke as head of the Vatican’s highest court and demoted him to the largely ceremonial post of chaplain of a charity group.

Conservatives are also worried about Francis’ drive to devolve decision-making power on several issues from the Vatican to regional, national or diocesan levels, what the pope has called “a healthy decentralization.”

This is an anathema to conservatives, who say rules should be applied identically around the world. They warn that a devolution of power would leave the Vatican vulnerable to the splits seen in the Anglican and Orthodox Churches.

“If you look at these two big Churches, they are not in very good shape,” said Massimo Faggioli, a Church historian and associate professor of theology at the University of St. Thomas in Minnesota. “That’s why conservatives are nervous. They think Francis does not understand the danger.”


  • Pingback: Three years on, Pope Francis leaves Catholic conservatives feeling marginalized -IKTHUS.NET()

  • Daniel Berry

    Liberals aren’t too happy with him either, so he must be doing something right if both groups are unsatisfied.

  • Pingback: Three years on, Pope Francis leaves conservatives feeling marginalized - mosaicversemosaicverse()

  • DavidPun

    It is the Catholic Conservatives who are damaging the Church. They are trying to define the Church by “what” it believes rather than how you live your beliefs. The last time that happened in a religion the offender was nailed to a cross for his defiance of the conservative wisdom.

  • Lydia

    1Cor 10:23 All things are lawful, but not all things are helpful. Also, don’t forget Philippians 2:3 …humbly think of others as being better than yourselves. If everybldy’s better than me, who am I to judge?

  • Pingback: Three years on the job, Pope Francis leaves conservatives feeling marginalized – Courtesy Universal One Church Newsfeed – Universal One Church – Universal Church()

  • Doc Anthony

    Things are getting worse. Conservatives must learn to stand on their own two feet and fight, even if it means standing against Francis.

  • Betty Clermont

    Conservatives should read what the pope says instead of the rubbish published by RNS and the rest of the media. On the flight from Mexico back to Rome, the pope said abortions to save the life of the mother is “what the Mafia does.” Politicians who vote for same-sex marriage do not have “well formed consciences.” He gave a definite NO to communion for the divorced and remarried and said that bishops who move pedophile priests around should resign – thereby telling the global espiscopate to expect no action on his part.


    excellent point

  • Reid E. Pagliaccio

    It all went off the tracks when they got rid of the big fans, the papal riding chair, and the triple tiara. Bring those back and all will be swell.

  • Shawnie5

    Except that the “conservative wisdom” of the time was to set aside the commands of God for the teaching of men.” (Matt.15).

    Without the “what” you can never get to the “how.”

  • Pingback: Three years on, Pope Francis leaves conservatives feeling marginalized – The Muslim Times()

  • Thomas Didymus

    Francis is a conservative. Liberals have nothing to hope for from this guy.

    The difference between liberals and conservatives isn’t niceness vs. nastiness or pastoral compassion vs. dogmatism: it is doctrine. And doctrinally, however nice, he is, Francis is a conservative. End of story.

    Wake up! This guy is not our friend

  • JGN

    Was not the pope elected as representing God, and was not the election done under the influence of the Holy Spirit? So the protesters are blaming God for this election!

  • patrick

    @ Care E.

    ” Problem there is, there is no god. ”

    Oh ye of little faith !

    Of course there is a God –

    I am HE….

  • Mark Rich

    “Conservatives say any change would undermine the principle of the indissolubility of marriage that Jesus established.”
    Jesus established that marriage is a covenant, a promise which cannot be broken, in which men and women are equal, rather than a fungible contract between two men for the services of a woman.
    He did not establish that marriage is a sacrament. He did not put any clergy in charge of other peoples’ marriages. He did not make ‘the Church’ a third partner in marriages. He did not link marriage to the eucharist. He simply established a particular teaching concerning the nature of marriage.
    It would give me pleasure to read a conservative thinker who could actually write clearly about this matter, instead of mashing together several things which don’t belong together, and then slinging mud at anyone who doesn’t muddy things as they do.

  • Garson Abuita

    You have it exactly backwards DavidPun. The Jews of Jesus’s time were focused on how they lived their beliefs, whether they were part of the Temple cult or part of the evolving rabbinic tradition that you call the Pharisees. A focus on what you believe sounds pretty Christian to me.

  • Pingback: Pope Francis creating “confusion” and “upset,” say conservative Catholic clergy | Episcopal Cafe()

  • Debbo

    Good comment Mr. Rich. Didn’t Jesus also acknowledge that divorce is a reality? He didn’t feel that it was the best outcome of a marriage, but it happens. I think Jesus didn’t condemn divorced people or deem them less worthy or beloved than those who did not divorce.

    (I’m on a break at work and don’t have a bible with me to add citations. Sorry.)

  • Tom

    Maybe the Cardinals got their smoke signals confused on this one?

  • L

    One should live his believes according to what one believes!

  • Shawnie5

    No, He didn’t acknowledge it as a reality. He said that remarriage following it is adultery because man can not truly separate what God joins.