March 18, 2016

Mormon church denounces ‘abusive’ LGBT therapy (COMMENTARY)

Print More
Alex Cooper. Photo courtesy Harper One

Alex Cooper. Photo courtesy Harper One

(RNS) A Salt Lake City TV station aired a segment recently about Alex Cooper, a young woman subjected to months of “conversion therapy” in an attempt to change her sexual orientation.

It was great to see Alex on screen, confidently talking about her experiences before the camera and to a live audience.


READ: Gay Mormon teen chronicles nightmare of conversion therapy in “Saving Alex” 


But what was also great was this unexpected tidbit at the end of the story. The KUTV news crew asked the church about its stance on conversion therapy.

“The Church denounces any therapy that subjects an individual to abusive practices,” said LDS spokesman Eric Hawkins.

“We hope those who experience the complex realities of same-sex attraction find compassion and understanding from family members, professional counselors and church members.”

The church’s public affairs department confirmed the two-sentence statement on Thursday.

Well, hallelujah. This is quite a turnaround from what we’ve seen in the past, even the recent past, in Mormon culture.

Recall that just a few months ago, a student ward, or congregation, at BYU-Idaho was planning to sponsor an event to encourage members who were “confused about same-gender attraction” to overcome it through “an evening of discussion with a professional counselor who has helped many overcome same-gender attraction.”

Obviously there’s a huge difference between a public lecture like that and the kind of physical and emotional abuse that Cooper was subjected to, in which she was essentially held captive; you can read about her experiences in her new memoir, “Saving Alex.”

But people were right to cry foul about the BYU-I church event. Because of the uproar, the lecture was canceled.


READ: Does a new study show a link between teen suicide and Mormon populations? (COMMENTARY)


Let’s hope this planned church event is the last of its kind, and that we are waking up to what psychologists have known for some time: that any course of action that seeks to change something as fundamental as sexual orientation is damaging.

As the American Psychological Association put it in 2009 after studying the results of psychologists’ past efforts, “mental health professionals should avoid telling clients that they can change their sexual orientation through therapy or other treatments.”

The APA report went on to say that:

Contrary to claims of sexual orientation change advocates and practitioners, there is insufficient evidence to support the use of psychological interventions to change sexual orientation. … Scientifically rigorous older studies in this area found that sexual orientation was unlikely to change due to efforts designed for this purpose. Contrary to the claims of SOCE (sexual orientation change efforts) practitioners and advocates, recent research studies do not provide evidence of sexual orientation change as the research methods are inadequate to determine the effectiveness of these interventions.

It may have taken a dramatic case like the abuse that Cooper suffered to bring this issue to the church’s attention, but the reality is that it’s not just reparative therapy programs utilizing “abusive practices” that need to go; it’s all of them.

I recently caught up with Joanna Brooks, Alex’s co-author and an advocate for LGBT persons within and outside of the LDS church. I’ll close with her eloquent response:

I am so grateful that the church has spoken out to definitively reject conversion therapy.  I hope it will bring relief to LGBT+ people and their families and put an end to conversion therapy in our communities.

Many generations of gay LDS people have been subjected to cruel, harmful physical, emotional, and religious “treatments” that purported to “change” them from gay to straight and bring them closer to God. Some have undergone extreme “treatments” including electroshock therapy at Church-owned Brigham Young University.  Others have been told by their local Church leaders that extreme self-deprivation, prayer, and scripture study would “fix” them.  Generations of gay LDS people deserve our apology.

But it is not enough to reject abusive “conversion therapy.”  We must also reject any suggestion that LGBT+ people are not created in the image of God as an expression of the beauty and diversity of God’s creation. As long as Mormons believe that being gay disqualifies anyone from enjoying all the blessings God has to offer, the foundational, harmful logic of “conversion therapy” remains at work amongst us.

(Senior columnist Jana Riess is the author of “The Twible: All the Chapters of the Bible in 140 Characters or Less . . Now with 68% More Humor!” She writes the Flunking Sainthood blog for RNS)