Demonstrators picket against the possible arrivals of undocumented migrants who may be processed at the Murrieta Border Patrol Station in Murrieta, California July 1, 2014. REUTERS/Sam Hodgson

Americans fret about Islam, immigrants, the future -- and each other

Americans are anxious about Islam, bothered by immigrants and mistrustful across racial lines, finds a new survey by the Public Religion Research Institute.

Americans are anxious about Islam, bothered by immigrants and mistrustful across racial lines, finds a new survey by the Public Religion Research Institute. Black Lives Matter photo courtesy of Unitarian Universalist Fellowship of Northern Nevada; immigragion protest photo courtesy of Reuters; ISIL photo public domain, courtesy of Wikipedia

 This image is available for web and print publication. For questions, contact Sally Morrow.

(RNS) Americans of all faiths and viewpoints are gloomy about the economy, anxious about Islam, bothered by immigrants and mistrustful across racial lines, a new survey finds.

The Public Religion Research Institute’s annual American Values Survey, released Tuesday (Nov. 17), documents discontent among all major religious groups, races and political views.

“I am struck by the high level of anxiety and worry on all fronts," said PRRI CEO Robert Jones, though he underscored that white evangelical Protestants express it most sharply.

For the first time in six years of the survey, Americans are split -- 49 percent to 49 percent -- on whether “America’s best days are ahead of us or behind us.”

The survey of 2,695 U.S. adults was conducted between Sept. 11 and Oct. 4, 2015 -- weeks before the latest horrific attacks in Paris.

However, public opinion polls measure perceptions, which can be worse than what is actually happening.

The 2015 headlines likely influenced views, said Jones. He cited the January attack on Charlie Hebdo magazine; months of videotaped beheadings of Christians in Libya; waves of Syrian immigrants, chiefly Muslim, fleeing escalating violence at home; the 2016 presidential election campaign; and the #blacklivesmatter movement that has emerged after police shootings of black Americans.

READ: Jesus would welcome Syrian refugees

A majority of Americans (56 percent, including majorities in all the major Christian traditions) say the values of Islam are at odds with American values. That’s a significant rise since 2011 when Americans were split, with 47 percent saying the values were incompatible while 48 percent disagreed.

This includes:

  • 73 of white evangelical Protestants (up from 59 percent in 2011)
  • 63 percent of white mainline Protestants (47 percent)
  • 61 percent of Catholics (41 percent)

Only two groups did not reflect significant change.

  • 55 percent of black Protestants said values were incompatible (51 percent)
  • 41 percent of “nones,” people who claim no religious label (42 percent).

The responses of Muslims, Jews and Hindus on that subject are not broken out because their numbers are too small to be statistically compared on individual questions. The overall survey, conducted online and by phone, has a margin of error of plus or minus 2.6 percentage points.

The survey also finds significant unease across racial lines.

READ: Packers’ Aaron Rodgers denounces anti-Islamic fan who ruined moment of silence

According to the PRRI report, the number of Americans who say that racial tensions are a major concern in their community more than doubled, going from 17 percent in 2012 to 35 percent now. Concern about crime as a major problem has risen from 33 percent to 48 percent in the same period.

One question in particular -- regarding police killings of black men -- found that whites and blacks operate in parallel universes of perception.

Overall, 53 percent of U.S. adults say the killings of unarmed black men by police are “isolated incidents.”

But this includes 65 percent of whites, while only 15 percent of blacks say the same.

Black Americans overwhelmingly (81 percent) say the killings are part of “a broader pattern of how police treat African-Americans.”

“On this issue, there is no daylight statistically between white evangelicals (72 percent), white mainline Protestants (73 percent) and white Catholics (71 percent),” said Jones.

This divide is glaring despite the mobilization of religious leaders from all sides to address police violence, discrimination and racial inequality, said Jones.

Their efforts have had “little measurable impact,” he said, because “white Christians in the pews just see a different set of social problems than their fellow black Christians do. Any conversations about racial reconciliation need to back up. They need to find out first if they even see the same problems before they can address solutions."

READ‘Black Lives Matter’ signs at churches vandalized

Adding to the gloomy mood, more than 7 in 10 (72 percent) believe that the country is still in a recession, unchanged from 2014 despite rising employment.

Another grim perception, held by 65 percent of Americans: “One of the big problems in this country is that we don’t give everyone an equal chance in life.” That reflects a jump of about 12 percentage points since 2010.

American unease seems to come from all directions. Another example from the survey: Nearly half (48 percent) of Americans say they are “bothered when they come into contact with immigrants who speak little or no English,” compared with 40 percent in 2012.

Dan Cox, research director of PRRI, said the full picture shows a nation “increasingly uncertain” about the future, “while nostalgia for the 1950s is widely felt,” particularly among white evangelical Protestants.

In presenting the American Values Survey at the Brookings Institute Tuesday, PRRI also released a supplemental political survey of 1,010 U.S. adults, conducted Nov. 6-10.  It looked at the how the current top five 2016 Republican presidential contenders stack up with the white evangelical vote.

READ: Evangelicals’ event to hear Trump and Carson — no Jeb!

Ben Carson leads the pack with a 55 percent favorable rating with this influential voting block and 26 percent unfavorable. Still, many people (10 percent) say they have not of him. That matters since these are the people any candidate might turn toward to grow support, said Jones.

Behind Carson:

  • Jeb Bush has a 41 percent favorable rating but a 47 percent unfavorable rating. Only 3 percent said they had not heard of Bush.
  • Donald Trump has the highest unfavorable rating with white evangelicals (52 percent) and a 39 percent favorable rating. And everyone said they have heard of him.
  • Marco Rubio has more favorable (36 percent) than unfavorable (29 percent) ratings and significant maneuvering room to introduce himself to people who haven’t heard of him (20 percent)
  • Ted Cruz is the least known of the top five with 23 percent saying didn’t know him. Among those who do, however, his favorable and unfavorable ratings are about equal – 31 percent to 32 percent.

Cruz and Rubio also shared the distinction of the highest declined-to-answer number -- 14 percent for each -- while the leading three had less than 10 percent of people who said they didn't know or refused to answer.



  1. Anyone who fails to see that America’s best days are behind her hasn’t been paying attention.

  2. Author

    Religion News Service welcomes thoughtful comments from all viewpoints.
    Rules are simple:
    — One comment per person.
    — Direct comments to the article, not other commenters.
    — Be civil. Do not denigrate individuals or groups for their ideas or opinions. 
    Posts that violate these rules will be removed.

  3. And yes, the OT is the basis of said koran but said strict OT followers are basically limited to the crazies of Israel.

  4. It seems that Americans have always been a rather suspicious lot. We also tend to be proud, arrogant and sometimes self centered. Seems that there is always somebody to be dis-trustful of. These are trends that our politicians have capitalized on, and we seem be be more divided as each day passes. We have not had top down leadership for far too long.

  5. Your unsupported claim to know the future with certitude is noted.

  6. Here’s the situation, folks: If you are worried about America’s future, that’s probably because you SHOULD be. This nation is in real trouble, and it is time to have an honest conversation about it. (While there is still time.)

    Ben Franklin and Abe Lincoln tried to warn us about “forgetting God.” Harsh war-time realities had utterly convinced both men that, (whatever else they may have believed), the United States of America could not and would not survive, if it crossed the line of forgetting God.

    “And have we now forgotten that powerful Friend?
    “Or do we imagine that we no longer need His assistance?”
    — Ben Franklin, 1787

    Unfortunately, we all know the national answer to Franklin’s questions — a great big “YES and we don’t care.”

    On top of all of America’s previous sins (racism, greed, etc), we have now utterly spat in God’s face and legalized gay marriage. Right in His face..

    So let’s have that honest conversation. While there’s still time.

  7. If you think marriage equality and secular government are worthy of divine wrath upon a nation, it speaks badly of your God and what you would consider an ideal society. Seriously, your ideal nation is repulsive.

Leave a Comment