Andover Newton to partner with Yale, shutter Mass. campus

Yale Divinity School. Photo courtesy of Yale

(RNS) The nation’s oldest graduate school of theology is planning to relocate from Newton, Mass., to New Haven, Conn., where a small remnant of the faculty will teach on the campus of Yale Divinity School.

On Monday (May 2), Martin Copenhaver, president of Andover Newton Theological School, said he and the dean of the Yale Divinity School have forged a partnership that, if finalized, will phase out the Massachusetts campus and phase in a presence at Yale with a 2018 launch date.

In its new location, Andover Newton will function as a school within a school, to be known as “Andover Newton at Yale.” The school will shrink to a fraction of its current size as students take most of their courses with Yale professors.

The planned affiliation comes as mainline Protestant seminaries, squeezed by the economics of denominational decline, seek new lifelines in partnerships. Over the past 10 years, more than 10 independent theological schools have sought financial stability by teaming up with larger educational institutions, according to Daniel Aleshire, executive director of the Association of Theological Schools.

As part of the partnership, 29 of Andover Newton’s 32 teaching positions, including tenured and short-term faculty, visiting professors and adjuncts, will be phased out. Andover Newton at Yale expects to employ four administrators, two professors and one temporary faculty member whose appointment will expire within four years.

“We would be getting smaller in any case because frankly, the demand is less,” Copenhaver said. “We have to be more focused … not just because of the finances, but more focused in order to fulfill our founding mission.”

The move to Yale clears a path for Andover Newton to complete the sale of its coveted hilltop campus, which is assessed at $43 million. The school is selling the campus for an undisclosed amount that will retire its debt and allow Andover Newton at Yale to operate on endowment income, Copenhaver said.

Money from the sale will also help Yale Divinity School reach a 2022 goal of offering tuition-free education to all students who qualify, which is more than 90 percent of the student body, according to Dean Gregory Sterling. Yale aims to raise $40 million in endowment funds to create the tuition-support program.

The seminaries are responding to changes in the U.S. religious scene in which fewer Americans attend mainline churches. As congregations shrink, they can no longer afford to hire full-time pastors. That means prospective seminarians don’t dare take on debt by enrolling, according to Aleshire. Enrollments have dropped nearly 24 percent over the past decade at mainline seminaries, and lower tuition revenue can’t cover rising costs for building maintenance and personnel.

Founded in 1807 by Congregationalists who feared a theologically liberal drift in ministerial training at Harvard, Andover Theological Seminary has occupied campuses in Andover, Cambridge and Newton over its 209-year history. Over the centuries, it evolved away from its conservative theological roots. Both Andover Newton and Yale are known today for embracing social justice causes while preparing students for ministry and activism, among other vocations.

“The ethos and the culture is much the same” at the two schools, Sterling said.

For Yale, the Andover Newton deal builds on a similar partnership with Berkeley Divinity School at Yale, a training ground for Episcopal priests since 1971.

With a mission to train students for ministry in congregational church traditions, such as the United Church of Christ, American Baptist Churches USA and Unitarian Universalism, Andover Newton will deliver what Sterling calls “an ecumenical complement” to Berkeley’s formation of Episcopal priests.

Andover Newton is expected to bring resources to enhance specialized programming at Yale. Meanwhile, Sterling hopes more cash-strapped, freestanding seminaries will explore the prospects of joining with universities.

“One of the things I hope this can do is be a model for others to think about,” Sterling said. “How could they affiliate with another institution to make themselves stronger?”

(G. Jeffrey MacDonald is an RNS correspondent based in Boston)

About the author

G. Jeffrey MacDonald

G. Jeffrey MacDonald is an award-winning reporter and an ordained minister in the United Church of Christ.


Click here to post a comment

  • Thank you for a fair and level story on this move, Jeff. After seeing a story from a best-selling author earlier this year that erroneously said Andover Newton was already closed — a story that wasn’t corrected for a long time, if ever — I as a former student and freelance communications consultant working with Andover Newton tend to have a little lump of dread in my throat whenever the school’s name comes up in the news, but you did us right.

  • While your story is a good summary of the current situation at Andover Newton Theological School, as a Baptist (ABC) alum I need to correct your history of the institution. The problem is that you neglected to mention that the “Newton” part of the Andover Newton name comes from the Baptist Newton Theological Institute, which was established in 1825. Andover co-located with Newton on the Newton campus in 1931 and the two schools merged in 1965. More about the combined history of Andover and Newton can be found at

  • While I understand the need and commend the creativity involved in the Andover Newton-Yale arrangement, I still get a lump in my throat thinking of my few glorious experiences at that shining campus on the hill. It was there that I met Episcopal educator Verna Dozier, who taught us to view being a baptized Christian as a lay vocation, and to resist the heresy that only the ordained clergy can be in ministry. Do we know yet who’s buying the campus? In any case, I wish them well.