News

Muslim inmates sue over combined faith services in Arkansas prisons

Layers of razor wire surround a prison. Photo courtesy of Creative Commons

(RNS) — Muslim prisoners in Arkansas have sued the state’s prison system for requiring them to attend a combined Friday prayer service with members of the Nation of Islam and Nation of Gods and Earths.

The Council on American-Islamic Relations, a Muslim civil rights advocacy group, filed the lawsuit Mar. 1 against the Arkansas Department of Correction on behalf of Tucker Maximum Security Unit inmates Gregory Houston Holt, Rodney Martin and Wayde Stewart.

Though the three groups, which overlap in their histories and theology, follow distinct religious teachings, the Arkansas Department of Correction requires followers of Islam, the Nation of Islam, and the Nation of Gods and Earths who want to worship to attend a single prayer service.

“Religious freedom protects everyone’s ability to worship with those who share their faith,” CAIR National Litigation Director Lena Masri said in a statement. “Followers of Islam, Nation of Islam and the Nation of Gods and Earths should be permitted to worship separately in a manner of their choice, just as Arkansas currently offers such accommodations for Catholic, Baptist, Jewish and Buddhist worship services.”

The Nation of Islam, founded as an African-American Muslim movement by Wallace Fard Muhammad in 1930, combines elements of traditional Islamic teachings with black nationalist ideas and is now led by Louis Farrakhan. It’s estimated to have about 100,000 U.S. adherents. The Nation of Gods and Earths, also known as the Five-Percent Nation or the Five Percenters, split from the Nation of Islam in 1963 and has fewer than 50,000 followers.

Muslim inmates say that attending Friday prayer services with other Muslims is a mandate of their faith. The Arkansas prison system policy requires that Muslims attend the combined Friday prayer services or risk losing their designation as Muslims — which could cause them to lose religious accommodations such as a specialized Ramadan meal program.

CAIR claims that when Holt stopped going to the prison’s combined Friday services in protest, his other Islamic accommodations were taken away.

The suit, filed in federal court in Little Rock, claims that Arkansas has violated the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution and the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act.

“It is unacceptable that Arkansas thinks it may define who is a Muslim based on whether or not they attend Friday services, all while refusing to provide spiritually valid Friday services,” said Carolyn Homer, CAIR’s national trial attorney. “No one checks how often Christians in the facilities attend Sunday services before letting them celebrate Christmas.”

She also noted that Arkansas’ prisons currently recognize seven different Christian denominations and offer separate prayer services for those who identify as Catholic, Jehovah’s Witness, Baptist, Seventh-Day Adventist, Pentecostal, and Protestant and offers general Christian services.

The Federal Bureau of Prisons lists Islam and the Nation of Islam as separate faith groups. CAIR’s lawsuit asks for Arkansas to do the same and to recognize the Nation of Gods and Earths as a separate faith group.

The lawsuit follows other recent high-profile cases of Muslim inmates being denied religious accommodations, including a Supreme Court decision last month to greenlight the execution of an Alabama man without allowing his imam to be present in the death chamber with him.

Another lawsuit filed last month by the group Muslim Advocates on behalf of five detained Somali refugees alleges that Immigration and Customs Enforcement denied them halal meals, ability to perform daily prayers, access to prayer rugs and other accommodations. And a Muslim man detained by Customs and Border Protection claimed last month that the only food offered him was a pork sandwich. Muslim dietary laws rule out pork.

Holt, known as Abdul Maalik Muhammad after his conversion to Islam, has sued Arkansas’ prison system successfully before. In 2015, the U.S. Supreme Court unanimously ruled that the prison’s no-beard policy was unconstitutional.

A 2008 report from the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights on Religious Freedom in U.S. prisons found that from 2005 to 2007 Muslim inmates submitted the largest number of religious discrimination complaints of any religious group and initiated almost 30 percent of federal lawsuits under the Religious Land Use Institutionalized Persons Act from 2001 to 2006.

About the author

Aysha Khan

Aysha Khan is a Boston-based journalist reporting on American Muslims and millennial faith for RNS. Her newsletter, Creeping Sharia, curates news coverage of Muslim communities in the U.S. Previously, she was the social media editor at RNS.

14 Comments

Click here to post a comment

  • On line jobs increasingly becoming a trend all over the over world now. A recent survey indicates higher than 78% of the people are being part of on-line job opportunities at their house without having complications. The Online world is flourishing day by day and we are having an ocean of make money online opportunities via intenet to generate an income. Everyone would like to hang out with his/her friends by getting out for any beautiful place in the world. So on-line earning enables you to do the work at any time you want and enjoy your life. However choosing the right strategy and also setting up the right objective is our ambition in the direction of financial success. Already plenty of people are bringing in such a good paycheck of $41000 every single week through highly recommended and successful ways to making money on the internet. You can start to get paid from the first day when you check out our site. GET RESULTS NOW >>>>> http://www.yet.tf/2odiiu

  • The solution? Post a copy of The Great Kibosh of All Religions on all the prison bulletin boards.

  • Shouldn’t have committed the crime if you can’t do the time. Poor crying babies are all going to hell, anyway.

  • Southerners are going to give Muslim prisoners as little as they can legally get away. They don’t like them.

  • Well, Sunni Muslims are certainly members of a different religion from the other two. Why not make Southern Baptists attend Cathoolic Mass each week? Same thing.

  • True, they have to serve their time. But if they are attending religious services it might mean some of them have repented and that Allah has forgiven them and they will not go to hell. Remember to hold hope for their souls to the end.

  • In Alabama every prisoner gets as little as they can legally get away with.

    The state is not rolling in money.

  • https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/482/342/

    O’Lone v. Estate of Shabazz, 482 U.S. 342 (1987):

    “Respondents, prison inmates and members of the Islamic faith, brought suit under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 contending that two policies adopted by New Jersey prison officials prevented them from attending Jumu’ah, a Muslim congregational service held on Friday afternoons, and thereby violated their rights under the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment.”

    ^

    “The Court of Appeals erred in placing the burden on prison officials to disprove the availability of alternative methods of accommodating prisoners’ religious rights. That approach fails to reflect the respect and deference the Constitution allows for the judgment of prison administrators.”

    ^

    “Even where claims are made under the First Amendment, this Court will not substitute its judgment on difficult and sensitive matters of institutional administration for the determinations of those charged with the formidable task of running a prison.”

  • Am not sure that Allah has any power to forgive them or save anyone’s soul from hell. But, thanks for your comment about holding on to hope for their souls to the end.

2019 NewsMatch Campaign: This Story Can't Wait! Donate.

ADVERTISEMENTs