Donate to RNS

Amazon algorithm recommends Bible-emblazoned spanking paddle

Online retailing giant Amazon.com has run into problems in the past because of controversial religious products.

Sales page images for The Montgomery Line wooden child discipline paddle. Images via Amazon.com

(RNS) — For $35.95, parents who want to discipline their kids “God’s way” can buy a handmade paddle, complete with Bible verse and free Prime shipping from Amazon.

The “Board of Education” child discipline paddle is “handcrafted of solid wood,” with a predrilled handle for hanging but otherwise no holes to “weaken paddle causing it to split,” according to the product description on Amazon.

Emblazoned with the words “Proverbs 29:15” — a reference to a Bible verse that reads, “A rod and a reprimand impart wisdom, but a child left undisciplined disgraces its mother,” according to the New International Version translation — the paddle also comes with “laminated suggested spanking guidelines.”

The online retailer’s algorithm recommended the paddle, which was listed as an “Amazon’s Choice,” a label Amazon uses to describe products that best match a customer’s search. Other options under “child discipline paddle” include sorority/fraternity spanking paddles — both with and without holes — and wooden spanking spoons.

The “Board of Education” is one of a number of family resources offered by “The Montgomery Line,” run by Christian speakers Clarence and Susan Montgomery from Georgia.

Married for more than 40 years, according to their website, the couple has seven kids and 14 grandchildren and advises Christians on how to have a happy marriage and properly discipline children.

The Montgomery Line wooden child discipline paddle, left, with the Amazon's Choice designation. Screengrab

The Montgomery Line wooden child discipline paddle, left, with the Amazon’s Choice designation. Screengrab

For about $40, they also sell a keepsake journal for recording memories about raising sons and a book on “Biblical Child Discipline Made Plain.” That book is also offered for free through Amazon’s Kindle Unlimited service.

The familiar phrase “spare the rod, spoil the child” does not appear in the Bible, but a similar sentiment is found in Proverbs 13:24: “Whoever spares the rod hates their children, but the one who loves their children is careful to discipline them.”

In their book, the couple advocates spanking as part of God’s design for parenting and offers a step-by-step guide on how to spank.

The couple warns parents to not spank in anger and to do so only in cases of willful disobedience — when a child knows what a parent wants them to do but refuses to follow instructions.  

Sales page images for The Montgomery Line wooden child discipline paddle. Image via Amazon.com

Sales page image for The Montgomery Line wooden child discipline paddle. Image via Amazon.com

That’s where the paddle comes in.

“Using an object to administer discipline is more suitable than using your hand,” the couple advises. “The paddle or belt can inflict enough pain to communicate the message that disobedience hurts and creates pain. Using your hand typically does not inflict enough pain (except for pain in the parent’s hand).”

Child welfare experts have increasingly argued that corporal punishment is bad for children. A review of 69 longitudinal studies published in The Lancet earlier this year concluded that corporal punishment did not improve children’s behavior and could lead to negative outcomes. 

“The consistency of these findings indicates that physical punishment is harmful to children and that policy remedies are warranted,” according to a summary of the findings. 


RELATED: Five myths of ‘biblical spanking’


About two-thirds of Americans believe that spanking is sometimes necessary, according to the 2018 General Social Survey. Researchers from the GSS have found in the past that born-again Christians are more likely to believe spanking is necessary than non-born-again Christians.

The Montgomerys did not immediately respond to a request for comment. In a YouTube video, Clarence Montgomery talks about how the Bible taught him and his wife how to have a happy home.

“All across this great country, a mighty movement of God-fearing parents is emerging,” he said in the video. “Yes, a crusade of dads and moms who are embracing and excited about embracing God’s model for the home.”

Amazon customers who bought the Board of Education gave it mixed reviews. One reviewer said that the sight of the paddle “inspires good behavior,” while another complained that it broke the first time they used it.

The online retailer has pulled controversial religious products in the past, such as bathmats featuring Quranic texts and a doormat depicting Hindu gods.


RELATED: Amazon pulls offensive bathmats with Quranic texts