Anti-Muslim rhetoric puts Sikhs on edge too

Print More
The Gurdwara Singh Sabha in Buena Park, California shows banners clarifying it is a Sikh temple and they support the victims of the terror attacks in San Bernardino, California. Sikhs have often been confused for Muslims and made the targets of xenophobic crimes following Islam-linked terror events. Religion News Service photo by Katherine Davis-Young

The Gurdwara Singh Sabha in Buena Park, California shows banners clarifying it is a Sikh temple and they support the victims of the terror attacks in San Bernardino, California. Sikhs have often been confused for Muslims and made the targets of xenophobic crimes following Islam-linked terror events. Religion News Service photo by Katherine Davis-Young

(RNS) It’s a weekday afternoon, and Jaspreet Singh is usually at work, but power drill in hand, he’s attaching new “security cameras in use” signs to the outside of the Sikh temple in Buena Park, Calif.

Singh took the time off from his job as an information technology manager to protect the temple where he serves as a board member after he learned it had been vandalized.

“I was definitely shocked because our community is very peaceful. We don’t preach any hate. We respect all religions,” he said.

Jaspreet Singh. Photo courtesy of Jaspreet Singh

Jaspreet Singh, took the time off from his job as an information technology manager to protect the temple where he serves as a board member after he learned it had been vandalized. Photo courtesy of Jaspreet Singh

He was less surprised when he found out that the graffiti painted onto the walls of the temple’s parking lot and a truck parked there included slurs about “ISIS” and “Islam.” “Whenever terrorists attack, or any such incidents happen, there have always been backlashes,” he said.

And anti-Muslim backlashes have often targeted Sikhs, who are frequently mistaken for Muslims. The turbans worn by Sikh men in particular prompt the perpetrators of hate crimes to assume that their targets follow Islam.

The graffiti at the temple, Gurdwara Singh Sabha, was discovered on Dec. 6, four days after terrorists with apparent connections to radical Islamists killed 14 people in San Bernardino, about 50 miles from Buena Park. Leaders of the gurdwara, or Sikh house of worship, asked authorities to investigate the vandalism as a hate crime.

Graffiti is seen on the walls of the parking lot at the Gurdwara Singh Sabha in Buena Park, California on Dec. 10, 2015. The vandalism was first reported on Dec. 6. Religion News Service photo by Katherine Davis-Young

Graffiti is seen on the walls of the parking lot at the Gurdwara Singh Sabha in Buena Park, Calif., on Dec. 10, 2015. The vandalism was first reported on Dec. 6. Religion News Service photo by Katherine Davis-Young


READ: American mosques trying to protect bodies and spirits from hate


The Sikhs in Buena Park, where the gurdwara serves 1,000 people, were hardly the only members of their faith targeted after the San Bernardino massacre.

“We’re already seeing a spike in incidents. We’ve had several reports of community members experiencing hate speech,” said Gurjot Kaur, attorney with the Sikh Coalition, a national organization that provides legal assistance to Sikhs facing discrimination.

Sikhism is the world’s fifth-largest religion, with about 25 million practitioners, including more than 500,000 in the U.S. It originated in Northern India independently from Hinduism, Islam and other religions. Most Sikh men wear turbans and beards as signifiers of faith.

Their style of dress lines up with stereotypical symbols of terrorism, said Simran Jeet Singh, professor of religion at Trinity University. (He is not related to Jaspreet Singh; many Sikh men use the surname Singh.)

“My father came to this country in the 1970s. Back then, he was called ‘ayatollah.’ When I was a kid I got called ‘Osama bin Laden.’ Now we’re being called ‘ISIS,’” he said. “All of these xenophobic slurs come from a misunderstanding of who Sikhs are.”


READ: Japanese-Americans remember Pearl Harbor backlash and support Muslims


Simran Jeet Singh said often anti-Muslim political rhetoric lumps together unique religions and Middle Eastern and South Asian ethnic groups, he said.

Soon after terrorists linked to the Islamic State group attacked in Paris in November, for example, Canadian Sikh journalist Veerender Jubbal was photoshopped to appear as one of the suicide bombers. The image spread widely around the Internet and some news media even published the image, believing it to be authentic.

Sikhs have also often been targets of violence. Days after the terror attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, a man ranting about “towel heads” shot and killed a Sikh gas station owner in Mesa, Ariz. In 2012, a white supremacist killed six Sikh worshippers in their Wisconsin gurdwara. And in September, a man shouting “terrorist” beat a Sikh man unconscious outside Chicago.

That perpetrators of these crimes should attack Sikhs, mistaking them for Muslims, is not surprising, said Randy Blazak, a professor of sociology at the University of Oregon who researches hate crimes.

“The notion of hate crime is always based on not just who the target is, but the perception of who the target is,” Blazak said. “There are often anti-gay attacks where the victim isn’t gay or anti-illegal immigrant attacks where the victim is not actually an illegal immigrant.”


Read: Top US Catholic bishop denounces anti-Islam backlash


Simran Jeet Singh said excusing discriminatory acts as cases of mistaken identity skirts the larger issue.

“By framing it as mistaken, there’s an implication that there’s a correct identity who should be targeted,” he said. “And it takes away agency and accountability from perpetrators, like it should, in some way, be forgivable.”

Whether or not attackers strike their intended targets, Simran Jeet Singh sees anti-Muslim sentiment and actions as evidence of a larger problem. “Political rhetoric now is certainly fanning the flames of ignorance and fear,” he said.

Buena Park’s Sikh community understands that firsthand.

When Jaspreet Singh headed to the store to buy security equipment and supplies to clean up his vandalized gurdwara, he said a woman in the store’s parking lot shouted expletives at him, telling him to get out of the U.S. Still, he said he has loved living in the U.S. since arriving from India 12 years ago, despite the bigotry directed at him and his community.

The teachings of his faith remind him to stay optimistic.

“If a tragedy happens,” he said, “all the communities should come close and protect each other rather than splitting ourselves and hating each other and blaming each other.”

  • Pingback: Anti-Muslim rhetoric puts Sikhs on edge too | Christian News Agency()

  • Pingback: Anti-Muslim rhetoric puts Sikhs on edge too - mosaicversemosaicverse()

  • Larry

    So we have an entire ethnic group which has suffered violence, threats and property damage because violent bigots are too lazy and stup1d to figure out who they are supposed to hate.

  • Pingback: Anti-Muslim rhetoric puts Sikhs on edge too | English Sikh()

  • Observer

    Larry, you just figured it out.

    The irony is that Sikhs have suffered greatly at the hands of Muslims in south Asia from Iran to the partition of India when thousands were killed or forced out of what is now Pakistan.

  • Garson Abuita

    I remember seeing similar “Proud to be an American Sikh” as a bumper sticker on taxicabs in NYC in the days after 9/11. Those who do not learn from history…

  • Larry

    The Sikhs suffered very much at the hands of Hindus in India as well. Indira Gandhi was assassinated by Sikhs who were PO’ed at their treatment at the hands of her government. Being a minority faith in the developing world tends to be a tough row to hoe in general.

    That being said, it says little for the intelligence of islamaphobic Americans that so many Sikhs get attacked by them, despite no relation to that faith. I guess to them, one brown skinned person with unusual head covering is the same as the next.

  • Pingback: Markierungen 12/18/2015 - Snippets()