San Diego judge says public school’s yoga instruction not religious

Children practice yoga at El Camino Creek Elementary School in Carlsbad, Calif. Photo by Lilly Fowler

SAN DIEGO, (RNS) A California judge ruled Monday (July 1) that the teaching of yoga in public schools does not establish a government interest in religion.

The decision came after parents sued the Encinitas Union School District to stop yoga classes introduced to elementary schoolchildren in the upscale suburb just north of San Diego.


Children practice yoga at El Camino Creek Elementary School in Carlsbad, Calif. Photo by Lilly Fowler

In his opinion, San Diego Superior Court Judge John Meyer explained that although yoga is rooted in religion, it has a legitimate secular purpose in the district’s physical education program. He also said the practice, contrary to parents’ complaints, does not advance or inhibit religion.

Finally, Meyer said although he had some concerns about the K.P. Jois Foundation, an organization launched in 2011 that awarded the district a $533,720 grant to start the program, the district’s yoga curriculum does not create any kind of excessive government entanglement with religion. That’s because it is the schools — and not the foundation — that are ultimately responsible for supervising the yoga instructors, Meyer said.

The National Center for Law and Policy, a nonprofit based in Escondido, Calif., that represented the plaintiffs, said that it plans to appeal.

“We strongly disagree with the judge’s opinion on the facts and the law,” said Dean Broyles, who as president of the center represented Stephen and Jennifer Sedlock, whose child attends El Camino Creek Elementary School in Carlsbad, Calif., which is part of the Encinitas Union School District. They first sued the district in February 2013.

“It’s absolutely incredible, but it’s not surprising,” said Sian Welch, who pulled her daughter out of the yoga classes offered at Capri Elementary School in Encinitas. Welch said she believed the judge’s decision was at least partly influenced by the money involved in funding the program and by an anti-Christian bias.

“We will have a society very soon where Christians will be the weirdest people,” said Welch, though she said she has no plans to pull her daughter out of the school district. “They will just be touted as crazy.”

David A. Peck, a lawyer with Coast Law Group LLP, a firm based in Encinitas that represented parents who are for the yoga program, explained that the judge had aptly applied the so-called “Lemon test,” a legal litmus test first established by the U.S. Supreme Court in 1971. The test poses three different questions to determine whether a government’s action violates the First Amendment in matters of religion.

“The judge got it right,” said Peck, while adding that Meyer had conceded the case was not black-and-white. The judge took the parents’ concerns seriously, Peck said.

El Camino Creek’s principal, Carrie Brown, said she looks forward to the district moving forward with the yoga program.

“I’m so happy that this is over,” said Brown. The program is “true fitness for the children and I’m glad the judge could see that.”

About the author

Lilly Fowler


Click here to post a comment

  • Frankly the idea that fundamentalist Christians will in the future be thought of as weird or unbalanced is a good thing, IMO. The reason I think this is because as a fundamentalist Charismatic Christian I was required to suspend my own rational thinking and I was required to suspend disbelief for a belief system that beggars belief.

    The hard thing about fundamentalist Christisnity, is the fact that these people though they believe in freedom of religion the freedom of religion is only for them and no one else. The rights enumerated in the Bill of Rights according to the fundamentalists of Christianity are only for fundamentalist Christianity, by example Google, Bryan Fischer, David Barton, Phyllis Schlafly, Marion G. (Pat) Robertson,

    The pervasive thought pattern among fundamentalist Christianity is a overblown sense of self-importance.

  • Well said Nelson. These poor people are aggrieved not because their sacred ox was gored, but that is was bumped up against by a member of the “dirty unwashed”. Pity the poor dears.

  • I went to a seminar to hear a former Brahmin priest who became a follower of Jesus Christ. I’ll never forget what he said about yoga. “Yoga means: to be yoked with the gods. There are over 300,000 little gods.”

    Now, you tell me! It’s my opinion that the judge who handed down that decision is sorely uninformed! He needs to ‘bone up’ on various religions!!!