Let the US Commission on International Religious Freedom expire

A federal commission originally devised to show up the Clinton administration now only serves to furnish Trump court evangelicals with a bully pulpit.

USCIRF commissioners Johnnie Moore, left, and Gary Bauer speak about the 2019 annual report during a news conference on April 29, 2019, in Washington. RNS photo by Adelle M. Banks

(RNS) — On Dec. 21, the United States Commission on International Religious Freedom, more commonly known as USCIRF, will run out of funding. After 21 years of problematic existence, the time has come to let it expire.

USCIRF was created as part of the 1998 International Religious Freedom Act, which came about because of a House Republican effort to portray then-President Bill Clinton as a do-nothing when it came to religious freedom. It was a false portrayal, as John Hanford, religion point man for Sen. Richard Lugar, realized; after intense behind-the-scenes scrapping, the legislation was cleaned up, embraced by the Clinton administration and passed into law.

At the last minute, however, the instigators succeeded in rolling a Trojan horse into the bill in the form of a seven-figure (now $3.5 million) annual budget for USCIRF.

RELATED: Reforming USCIRF to death

Rather than serving, as intended, as an advisory body to the new ambassador for international religious freedom, the commission came into existence as a microagency unto itself, independent of the State Department, even as the act gave State responsibility for monitoring religious freedom around the world.

The new entity comprised nine commissioners appointed by Democrats and Republicans along with, ex officio, the ambassador, and a staff of 15 to 20. In short order, it assumed the role of a freelance religious liberty scold, issuing its own country reports alongside the State Department’s and denouncing other countries’ behavior — all to little if any avail. The principal denouncers proved to be a few continually reappointed GOP-appointed commissioners intent on highlighting the persecution of Christians.

Eight years ago, USCIRF had a near-death experience when its renewal was held up in the Senate. It recovered, but thanks to the efforts of Sen. Dick Durbin, commissioners’ terms were limited to two years, renewable once.

Nadine Maenza, left, commissioner of the U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom, speaks at the April 29, 2019, event when USCIRF released its annual report in Washington. Commissioner Tony Perkins is on the right. RNS photo by Adelle M. Banks

This year, Democratic senators have insisted on more stringent rules. Under the terms of a bipartisan renewal bill, normal government standards of planning, accountability and personnel management were to be put in place and commissioners were to be forbidden from using outside funding for official travel.

And then there were these provisions:

When a member of the Commission is speaking at a public event in his or her capacity as a private citizen, the event sponsor shall not identify the member’s affiliation with the Commission in any printed materials or when introducing the member.

When a Member of the Commission is invited to speak at an event in his or her capacity as a Commissioner, the Member shall provide notice of the request to all Commissioners and the Executive Director as soon as the Commissioner becomes aware of the request. When a specific Commissioner is requested to speak at an event, but a different Commissioner has more relevant subject-matter expertise, the Commission may propose that a different Commissioner speak at the event. If more than 1 Commissioner would like to speak at an event and interested Commissioners cannot reach a timely, amicable decision on who shall speak, the Commission, as a whole, shall decide who shall speak by majority vote. Speeches and responses to questions at events shall reflect the views of the Commission. Speeches and other prepared materials must be circulated to all Commissioners in advance of the event.

When you consider that USCIRF now includes such prominent Trump court evangelicals as Tony Perkins (chair), Gary Bauer and Johnnie Moore, it’s little wonder that they don’t want their official activities subject to commission agreement. The proposed rules, court evangelical pooh-bah Richard Land recently told Christianity Today, would “neuter” the commission.

No, they would require that commissioners, in their official capacity, speak on behalf of the commission’s common position, instead of using their status to give the impression that they are speaking for the U.S. government.

But of course, in deference to them, the Republican co-authors withdrew the bill — with Marco Rubio, that profile in senatorial courage, whimpering that they shouldn’t be blamed for the offending provisions.

So be it. Mssrs. Perkins, Bauer and Moore have at their disposal sufficient bully pulpits from which to denounce the persecution of Christians.  Let USCIRF rest in peace.  

Donate to Support Independent Journalism!

Donate Now!