AME General Conference debate on same-sex marriage continues after bill is voted down

The measure would have repealed a section in the AME Book of Discipline that prevents clergy from performing such marriages.

Bishop Wilfred T. Messiah, center, delivers an invocation during the opening worship service at the African Methodist Episcopal Church conference July 6, 2021, in Orlando, Florida. (AP Photo/John Raoux)

(RNS) — A bill concerning same-sex marriage failed to pass on its second reading Wednesday (July 7) at the African Methodist Episcopal Church General Conference, the denomination’s quadrennial meeting taking place in Orlando, Florida, this week.

The proposed bill was submitted by Ravi K. Perry, chair of the political science department at Howard University who specializes in Black politics and minority representation, among other topics. It was designed to repeal a section in the AME Book of Discipline that prevents clergy from performing same-sex marriages.

“By simply deleting the section,” Perry wrote in his proposal, “the church would be then permitting local churches and pastors to welcome LGBTQ parishioners into full membership in God’s house … (T)he Holy Scriptures (do not) explicitly forbid same-sex attraction, companionship, love, and marriage — particularly, not as it is practiced in monogamous partnerships and is largely understood as today in the 21st century.”

But the assembled delegates agreed with a motion that the bill could not be debated on the floor because it violated a 2004 decision that stated same-sex marriage was not the will of God.
After the vote, motions to revive the bill on “procedural and ethical issues” were made and, according to the Rev. Renita Marie Green, lead correspondent for the AME’s official publication, the Christian Recorder, the debate “is not over until the General Conference is over.”

“There are people who care about the divine in all humans who are working hard to make sure that the whole person is fully included in the life of our church without penalty to pastors who choose to love others as God has loved us,” said Green.

While the AME Church prohibits clergy from performing same-sex marriages, it does not bar LGBTQ individuals from serving as pastors or otherwise leading the denomination.

“The ban penalizes clergy for fully pastoring members of our church,” said Green. “So, there are many people who, while they may not agree theologically with same-gender marriages, disagree with the penalty that pastors would suffer for fully pastoring members of their congregation and community.”

RELATED: AME Church bishops address COVID-19, critical race theory as major meeting opens

From left, Senior Bishop Adam J. Richardson, Jr., Bishop Anne Henning Byfield, Orlando Mayor Jerry L. Demings join together with other colleagues for a press conference during the 51st annual AME general conference. Photo courtesy of AME Church

From left, Senior Bishop Adam J. Richardson Jr., Bishop Anne Henning Byfield and Orlando Mayor Jerry L. Demings join with other colleagues for a news conference during the 51st annual AME Church General Conference. Photo courtesy of AME Church

The issue of same-sex marriage is complicated for any denomination to consider, but perhaps especially for the AME Church, whose members in Africa and elsewhere in the developing world often hold more traditional theological views.

Any individual in the AME Church can propose legislation. After it is submitted, the proposed bill is reviewed by a revisions committee that considers whether the measure is legal and necessary, and what its implications may be. The committee then decides whether to recommend the bill to be presented to the General Conference — currently, there are 55 bills in the queue for consideration at the 2021 General Conference.

The bills are then voted on by the delegates and are decided upon based on Robert’s Rules of Order: They need 50% plus one for a bill to pass. According to Green, once a bill is passed, it becomes effective immediately.

RELATED: AME Church continues 200-year journey toward racial justice

Before the second reading, Perry, who is gay, said that passing the bill would be a momentous occasion for the oldest Black denomination in the world. 

“We are a church that was founded, because we were marginalized,” he said. “If this were to pass, the vote would symbolize our commitment from the beginning to be a beacon of light for the marginalized. And this particular generation, that’s for LGBTQ people like me.”

This story has been updated. 

Donate to Support Independent Journalism!

Donate Now!